Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Reselection or rubber stampfor MPs

Socialist Organiser (unnumbered), October 1978 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 967 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

AT THIS year's Labour Party conference, the NEC will present proposals which effectively neuter the struggle waged over recent years to make Labour MPs liable to re-selection by their constituency Parties. Against the NEC Majority Report, two formulas will be proposed: one in the NEC Minority Report, another backed by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy.

In this article, CLPD Secretary Vladimir Derer explains the CLPDs proposals, and why they differ from the Minority Report.

The SCLV takes no sides in the tactical dispute: but we support every move to extend democratic accountability in the labour movement.

WILL LABOUR MPs be made more accountable to the Labour Party? This is the issue which Will dominate this year's Labour Party annual conference. It is also the issue over which the bitterest battle will be fought.

The issue will be over what looks like a margimal change in the way Labour's parliamentary candidates are selected. Why is it then so important? For more than 10 of the last 14 years Labour governments have been in office and had the opportunity — in parliamentary terms - to carry out at least some of the policies on which they were elected. The present massive demand for greater accountability of Labour MPs is a reflection of the fact that they have failed to do so.

It has therefore to be viewed as an attempt to ensure that future Labour governments should stand for the interests of those who elected them and who work to get them elected.

The popularity of mandatory re-selection underlines the dominant political fact that, at present, change is sought through the reform of the existing institutions rather than the creation of entirely new ones. It is in this context that the minor procedural issue has acquired a very different significance.

The defenders of the status quo clearly recognise this. Their opposition to making Labour MPs subject to periodic re-selection has been stubborn, consistent and highly charged with emotion. Since it is difficult to argue' against this simple democratic reform, every procedural obstacle is being used to prevent its realisation.

In both 1975 and 1976 the "three year rule" was invoked to keep re-selection resolutions off the Labour Party conference agenda - despite the fact that in 1976 by far the largest number of resolution on a single subject demanded reselection.

Last year a ruling originally devised for minor constitutional proposals from odd CLPs was used against 67 affiliated organisations which passed an identical constitutional amendment on automatic re-selection. This meant that the debate and vote on these proposals was postponed to await the NEC's recommendations in 1978.

Nevertheless the fact that there were also eight re-selection resolutions submitted as ordinary resolutions meant that it was almost impossible to prevent a debate on the subject.

At this stage the NEC declared themselves also to be in favour of re-selection "in principle". It did not stop them from quickly finding reasons to prevent a vote on the 'composite' of these eight.

The forthcoming Labour Party conference will have three choices before it. * The NEC' s own proposals: These have fallen far short of the pledge given to conference last year. They make only a minor concession to the automatic principle: instead of mandatory. automatic selection all we get is a mandatory meeting at which a confidence vote in the sitting MP is put, thus heavily weighting the process toward the MP's automatic re-adoption.

The remaining two choices are either the proposal put by 67 affiliated organisation in 1977, or the proposals of the Minority Report of the NEC's working party on re-selection.

* Minority Report: There are serious snags in this. Firstly it contains a provision which would make mandatory reselection inoperable during short parliaments, a possibility which could result in MPs being exempt from mandatory re-selection for as long as 6 or Secondly it retains the provision for both mandatory and optional re-selection. It was the misinterpretation of this demand which prevented a straight decision on the principle last year.

Its retention this year threatens to confuse the issue once again. Yet the advantages of retaining it are no more than marginal. This is demonstrated by the fact that it has only been used on a handful of occasions.

To risk the principle of mandatory re-selection for the sake of such an illusory advantage is therefore tactical madness.

In the circumstances it is hardly surprising that the proposals of the Minority report are receiving favoured treatment from the opponents of reselection. The two amendments this year supporting it feature next to the NEC's proposals in the conference agenda. Whereas there is no reference whatsoever to the '67' Thus a completely false impression is created that the Minority Report is the sole alternative to the NEC's * The '67' : In fact the 67 resolutions must, if their movers so demand it, be debated and voted on this year. But unlike the Minority Report the proposals of the 67 are hidden from view.

For some mysterious reason the NEC's report to conference does not mention them, although constitutionally they are obliged to report on them. Whatever the reason for this serious omission - which, unless rectified, will amount to a breach pects of the 67 will have bees.

damaged.

Many delegates will not be mandated to vote for them because their CLPs did not realise that this choice was still open. The fact that some misguided supporters of the Minority Report have chosen to direct their fire on the 67 instead of the NEC will not help either.

Nevertheless there is an excellent chance that the good sense of conference wil prevail. You cannot fool all of the people all of the time!

VLADIMIR DERER Hon. Secretary, Campaign for Labour Party Democracy

Scan page 5

Socialist: Organiser 3 The Tories

← Contents of Socialist Organiser (unnumbered)

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →