Bahro belongs with the Marxists belong
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-01-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
by RUDOLF BAHRO's book, The Alternative, which earned its author an eight year jail sentence in East Germany, has just been published in English. And people who have very little in common with Bahro's indomitable revolutionary spirit are rushing to try to make Bahro 'theirs' In Tribune Ken Coates set out to show that Bahro agrees with Coates' own ideas of what socialism is and how to achieve it. Bahro's book indicts the bureaucratic regimes of the USSR and Eastern Europe, and tries to develop a Marxist analysis of bureaucracy as rooted in the division of labour. A breaking-down of the division of labour must, Bahro argues, be central in the new revolution needed in these bureaucratised states.
Coates transfers Bahro's ideas to capitalist society and uses them to argue for a reformist perspective. "Because, in all sobriety, the overcoming of the fragmentation of people in mutilating and stultifying economic roles is a task for the long haul, life seems to be simpl er if the whole process is indefinitely postponed" Arguing that the abolition of alienated forms of labour is a task for the 'here and now', blurring over the fact that Bahro refers to postcapitalist society while he (Coates) is referring to Britain, Coates ends up claiming Bahro as authority for a concept of socialism as an exercise in moral persuasion rather than as a revolutionary political movement.
Already won But Bahro's comments on the social democratic parties show that he has little in common with Coates. "The existence of this party is tied to the relationship of critical loyalty of certain layers of workers, employees and intellectuals to the bourgeoisie. What can its specific task be after the liquidation of the bourgeoisie as a class? Its state-monopolistic option has been taken up only too well by the formerly Communist parties in power. For the defence of the terrain already won from the bourgeoisie it can be dismissed without any dispute.
"Its defence of democratic forms of political lite — in so far as it does not mean in critical situations a counterrevolutionary class compromise which benefits the bourgeoisie — has a certain historical legitimacy in that the communists have nowhere yet finally shown their ability to positively defend democracy. But as soon as it could be politically relevant to talk of the re-founding of social democratic parties in our countries, they would already be superfluous in precisely this respect. For then precisely that socialist democracy would prevail, which the social democrat Rosa Luxemburg left to the West European CPs at their founding"
Bahro, believing that the working class in the West now has no revolutionary potential, and rejecting the equation of socialism with nationalisation, does express ian pumpathy for the italIs strategy. But what distinguishes Bahro from many other oppositionists in Fastern Furner his commitment HUIKers' democrac! and to socialism as the complere emancipation, and his clear idea of how 'real existing socialism" differs from this and musi be changed.
Monty Johnstone. reviewing Bahro's book in the Morning Star. decided that the best way to deal with these awkward questions was with a front of brass. He ticked off Bahro for not being radical enough!
Johastone midded Bahro for failing to come our for a multi-party system. and for being "extremely vague" because he "takes us little further than" Marx's model of the Paris Commune as a truly democratic workers' state. And the new League of Communists advocated by Bahro would. Johnstone claims, just mean the creation of a new elite.
On the strength of the British CP's servile attachment to bourgeois Parliamentarism. Johnstone speaks as ar expert on democra.: enc "the plurals: ... "" I Socia ism su strongly indirealed by Western Communist Parties. including our own New Elite ern Europe is a movement like Dubcek's in Czechoslovakia in 1968. But Bahro is absolutely right to show that reform movements based in the Communist Party apparatuses — which above all represent the bureaucracy - cannot get to the roots of the deep problems caused by the bureaucracy's role in the economy and societi.
Johnstore ends with a rather pathetic-sounding plea for publication and discussion of The Alternative in the 'socialist countries. For him. the repression of the socialist opposition can be corrected by lobbying the bureaucracy to change its policy.
Changing it Bahro analyses the structure of East European societ to show why the repress: ? is huil: into the siciem and is to is a miniske. And .. • a nui a programme Wur hanging it. That is •' despite all his miss. belongs mi: Rudolf Bahro - sentenced to eight years' imprisonment and the warm appreclation of left reformists. The first because of his close relation to Marxism, the latter despite it.
Scan page 6
The Shah's apologists say that he has