[reward for our labour. I am not surprised…]
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
reward for our labour.
I am not surprised that the Government's 5% guideline is being ignored. No doubt the Treasury officials did advise Jim Callaghan that the country could not afford more than 5% but it would not be the first time that they have got it wrong• Most other authoritative views reckon that ten to fifteen per cent 1s more appropriate. The Government may wel have known that, and used the 5% in the hope that some unions would settle for the lower figure. A cunning ploy, perhaps, but not very honest.
Who reaps the benefits of this onslaught on inflation? Can it be the ordinary working class people, or is it our rea overlords, those financial Tory wizards in the City of London who are more interested in the bank balance of their shareholders, or of their foreign bank accounts.
It always seems to be the working class that have to toe the line.
High wage settlements have never caused inflation (for which the working class is always blamed). But while the Dear Comrades, The article US gives the nod to Chinese attack on Vietnam by comrade Cheung Siu Ming in the March issue of Socialist Organiser was a very welcome one. Ite tone and position was n sharp contrast with the exoressed opinions of the maior. ity of the left here in the US.
Most of the left here has reluctantly drawn some proper conclusions about China's reprehensible conduct and international orientation over the past six to seven years and has condemned its invasion of Vietnam: but it has nevertheless tended to link the demand for Chinese withdrawal with a call for Vietnamese withdrawal from Kampuchea (or, in the better cases, to draw wholly inappropriate parallels between the two actions).
I believe a very good case can be made that Vietnam's political and military support for the Kampuchean opposition to the Pol Pot regime was a industrial struggle. This seems to coincide with their attempt to gain additional powers. The sort of thing they want can be seen from their evidence to the Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure:
• Arrestable offences to be increased. The right of the police to go to the home of any person (included someone not suspected of an offence) and ask what they were doing the previous night. If they refuse to answer or seem evasive, the right of the police to arrest them.
_ The rignt of police to search suspects would be extended to people simply because of their presence at a particular spot.
• The use of 'necessary force in searches.
• To be able to hold suspects for 72 hours before having to charge them or bring them to court, and to have this extended by a further 72 hours on application to a magistrate in private and without the person detained having the right to be represented.
The right of police to photograph people after they are charged.
progressive response to a situation all socialists recognised as intolerable. But what other term can one use to describe the Chinese invasion of Vietnam - to teach them a lesson' for their militancy - than purely and simply reactionary?
We do not know whether President Carter encouraged the Chinese in their adventure, actively playing the Chinese card against Vietnam and its ally the Soviet Union - or whether he merely indicated that he would stand by and let them do it. But he was undoubtedly warned of the invasion beforehand.
So far as Vietnamese participation in the armed overthrow of the Kampuchean regime is concerned: well, the communist movement is not based on pacifist or abstentionist principles. That is, it has always refused to condemn military action in and of itself, rather, it has always asked whether any recourse to arms has a progressive or regressive content.
Toward the end of the article comrade Cheung, while rejecting any parallel between the Chinese and Vietnamese actions, weakens an otherwise excellent argument with an unfortunate qualifying phrase: 'Whatever reservations we may have on the Vietnamese regime's intentions...
Perhaps these reservations reflect a conservative reflex to Vietnam's decision to offer aid and participation in a liberating insurrection against another workers' state, but I do not see why without any evidence one should question its intentions: they appear to be quite straightforward.
What is really unfortunate is has not been Vietnam's intentions, but the barbaric and murderous course of the Pol Pot regime over the past few years, beginning - uniess everything I have read has been a lie - the day they came to power. The regime's cruelty is well-attested, and it would be incredible to attribute all knowledge of this fact to a few fertile brains in the US propaganda machine.
Comrade Cheung : suggests that perhaps a majority of the population of Kampuchea welcomed the Vietnamese as liberators, and I see no reason to dispute this.
I would suggest that the Vietnamese response to the situation in Kampuchea is in fact precisely what used to be known as proletarian internationalism (in the good sense of the term, before it acquired a more sinister flavour under Stalin). And if this seems too high-flown let me ask, what else could - or should - the Vietnamese have done? And, once more, had we the opportunity or the power to have done anything, would we not do exactly the same thing?
DAVE CUNNINGHAM Berkeley, California Dear Comrades, I'd like to support lan Dunn and John MacDonald [March SOJ on the issue of gay rights. To place preconditions on our support for gays is despicable - are we trading our support for theirs?
On the question of gay caucuses, particularly in the unions: in my experience the 'left' in unions have a a great the SCLV must maintain a principled position: unequivocal support for gay rights and the right of gays to I would like to take very strong exception to your comment in the SCLV Briefing lat the London Labour Regional Conference]. You wrote in the report of the debate on composite I D, on employment: 'As usual the right wing tried to confuse the issue with empty rhetoric, notably the Newham South delegate...
It's the first time I have ever been called right wing! The report of my speech did not get it right. I did not say we ought to support government interference in wages because it can lead to the establishment of a minimum wage. I did say that you will not obtain a minimum wage if there is no government interference in wages.
I prefaced my remarks with the comment thai I did not believe in wage restraint, that I was against the 5% limit, publie spending cuts, the government's economic strategy and high unemployment.
Resolution D on empioyment did not put forward an alternative economic strategy, nor did it make clear in places what was meant. Nationalising firms that threaten redundanrights are vita caucus without preconditions. lan and John refer to the question of gay teachers but we should also remember social workers - comrades will recall the case of lan Davies who was victimised by the [Labour controlled] Tower Hamlets Council in 1976, and he fight by Nalgo for his reinstatement.
Comrades in the SCLV must fight for the Party as a whole to adopt a policy of uncompromising support for gay rights.
DAVE STATHAM Brent East CLP cy and bringing the careers service under full trade union control are slogans and it is not clear what they mean. To disagree with a resolution does not mean that the speaker is right wing nor a supporter of government economic policy.
The composite D had some good phrases in it, especially in its condemnation or gover!!" ment policy. However I felt it could not be supported because of what it required the London Region to do.
I do feel that a four-day week without loss of pay would gó a long way towards solving unemployment, together with voluntary earlier retirement.
South Staffe LP have already expressed their amusement at your comments - the same GMC criticised me last month for my constant attacks on government policy in the local press - I had demanded Healey's resignation!
By the way, not everyone from Newham South has the same political viewpoint.
GRAHAM LANE Newham South delegate to London Labour conference; PPC for South Staffordshire
Scan page 6
managers (
----- pull-quotes -----
STRIKE CALLACHAN OUT are rig