Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

RATE INCREASES: SALTIA OMI begin Raise rates, begin the

Socialist Organiser (unnumbered), April 1979 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 972 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

by KEITH LICHMAN IN THIS election year, with Tories promising ever more beguilingly to give everything away if only they can get their hands on it, the paradoxical position of socialists in local government has reached crisis proportions. Throughout the country Labour councils, fundamentally committed to the extensive provision of public seryices and urban improvement, as part of the socialist redistribution of resources, have been forced to raise local rates by unprecedented amounts.

The biggest increases have been in London. In Hackney, the proposed increase, much paraded in the Tory press as à 'swingeing' 50% (on the domestic rate) is in fact 23p, a similar figure to the increases in Brent (22p; 38.6% on domestic rate), Haringey (22.0p; 29.5%), Islington (20.3p. 32 %) and Lambeth There are two main causes for these increases. Firstly the annual rate of inflation of about 10%. Secondly the loss of subsidy on the housing. accounts brought about by the Government's policy of discouraging new building developments, for which High Cost Subsidy was available, and encouraging rehabilitation, which does not draw significant subsidy. In Hackney, the Housing Account received 53% govIn '79-'80 it will receive only 40% subsidy. To make up the deficit from the rates on this alone would mean roughly a 10p increase.

The position has been further worsened in Hackney by the cumulative misjudgements of an incompetent right-wing Labour council. Between 1975 and 1979, the barely ate increase was She Darely a pelliy a ycal result was that in "78-'79, the Hackney domestic rate of 46.5p was the lowest of the 33 London boroughs, and in most cases by a wide margin.

As a consequence, the borough that was compelled to instate the highest percentage rate increase in the country is in the ludicrous predicament of levying the 14th lowest rate in London, while needing to cut services and jobs in order to prevent the increase from being still higher.

To further embitter the pill. the 1978 council election manifesto. seen by the left as a minimum programme of improvements, desperatel! neeeded in Hackney, has been jerisoned by the ruling right-wire majority The need to contron: s problem realisticails cas thrown the left into disarra:. with some of the usual most reliable comrades reaching for their deadliest utopian rhetoric. A number intend to vote (with the lone Tory on the council) for no that central. government should be made to pay for Hackney's problems, and that if we cannot have all the manifesto at once, then we should have none of it.

The left is agreed that we must fight for a new and socialist system of local government funding. In Hackney, loan charges alone swallowed up a quarter of the borough's £92 million expenditure in '78-'79. Clearly this money would have been better spent in Hackney than by City financiers.

To expect, however, that money will be handed over to us by. a government breathing its last gasp, or by an incoming government, whether of the blue-nosed Callaghan variety or of the true-blue Thatcher type, simply because we demand it, is so far fetched as to Money-men like Keith Joseph gain from council's debts Grimm's Fairy Tales.

The issue — whatever we would like it to be — is not whether Hackney's services are paid for by central government or by the people of Hackney. The issue is whether we have the services at all. The necessary implication of a nil rate increase, of savage cuts in services and jobs, seems to have been overlooked by some members of the left, in spite of the fact that such cuts are the rallying cry for Tories throughout the country.

The only principled position that doesn't avoid reality is to resist all cuts in, services and to fight for an expansion in accord with manifesto promises. Unsatisfactory though they are, rates in inner city areas effect a significant redistribution of income from capitalists to the working class. Even in Hackney with its shortage of industry and employment, 58% of the rate revenue in '79-'80 will come from nondomestic sources, including commerce and industry. In 1978-79, the average Hackney domestic rate payer paid £2.24 a week. The new rate will put the weekly average up to £3.34, compared, say, to £6 in Camden. Even the poorest inhabitant of Camden would prefer to remain there where the services are better. than move to lowrated and poorly-serviced Hackne!.

An increase 40p instead of 23p on the rate would mean an average weekly rate of £4.16 and would net an additional £5.8 million, enough to ensure no cuts in services and to make worthwhile starts on key programme areas from the manifesto. It would also enable the Council to begin a campaign to educate the Hackney ratepayers about where their hard-earned money goes, and in particular to explain that debt charges in '78-'79 cost them a rate equivalent of 66p in the pound. The fight against capitalist finance needs to move people - not a handful of idealists — and to move, people need facts, and decent services to defend.

There is no doubt that the higher rate, although much less than neighbouring Haringey, would cause hardship. Not to levy it, however, would cause even greater hardship. Those most in need of the homes, jobs and social services and amenities a Council can provide are the poorest in the community, and they would benefit most from a steep rate increase.

It is not a solation to Hackney's problems, but it does at least begin the fight. A party that washes its hands of difficult immediate problems while waiting piously for the revolution has nothing to offer, and contributes nothing to the struggle for socialism. The fight is about today's issues, not tomorrows.

Scan page 9

WOMEN'S KURDS FIGHT FOR "ERNA

----- pull-quotes -----

Two Hackney councillons debate the issue fight

← Contents of Socialist Organiser (unnumbered)

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →