Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Nuclear Power: a Policy for Workers' Unity

Socialist Organiser (unnumbered), April 1979 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 2,163 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

IN APRIL 1976 a weekend camo held on the site pronosed for the Torness nuclear power station in tast Lothian was attended by about 100 people. Two years later a march and two-day occupation involved three to four thousand people.

On May 4.7 this year, a lorness gathering, organised by the Torness Alliance, ..ill hen hold isnt off the nita will vt utiu just un uit silt, where work has now started. It is expected to attract as many people as last year, or even more.

This growing anti-nuclear movement has provoked debates within the Scottish labour movement. At a heated debate last summer in Edinburgh Trades Council (TC), a motion from a branch of CoHSE calling for outright opposition to Torness and support for SCRAM (the Scottish Campaign to Resist the Nuclear • Menace) was narrowly defeated.

Official labour movement policy is in favour of the ranid develonment of nuclear power. The submission of the TTIN IUl to the windscale Inquiry sums it up: 'Economic growth is needed to secure full employment and rising living standards... Economic growth requires increasing supplies of energy... The nuctear industry will need to be able to make a sizable contribunon to britain s en- Data we who ergy supplies by the 1990s.' The main unions in the industry, such as the GMWU, TGWU, EETPU and AUEW, all support the Government's nuclear programme. So do ASTMS, TASS and the NUM although some of them express concern about health and safety.

However, the bland acceptance of government nuclear policy by these unions is now coming under question. Both TASS and ASTMS have debated anti-nuclear motions at annual conferences. The Mayors and leaders of the West Bank and Gaza issued this declaration We stand as one with all of our Palestinian people. We have reviewed the Camp David Agreements, and we wish to state that we reject them.

The so-called 'selfgovernment proposals for the occupied West Bank and Gaza only legitimate and strengthen the Israeli occupation. 1. The Palestinian Arab people insade and outside occupied Palestine are one; united through history, destiny and struggle.

The 'self-government' proposal is totally rejected in form and content because it strengthens Israeli occupation and perpetuates IsNUM in Scotland are opposed to Tarness and INATT ТАТ 591т99 ТТ2,9А flas Dasscu d molon yaCh questions the desirability of the programme.

At the 1977 TUC, local government union Nalgo proposed an amendment critical of nuclear power. It was rejected. In 1977 Dumtries and Galloway Nalgo had a motion against nuclear --- a dead ne L-- waste aumpıng passed py the Scottish TUC, although the STUC's general policy is in favour of nuclear power.

Last month at the Scottish Labour Party conference, a strongly pro-nuclear motion from the EETPU was passed, as well as a motion from Edinburgh Pentlands CLP which called for more public debate. Next month a CPSA motion is to be put to the STUC which also just calls for debate in the labour movement.

These motions have been inspired by the 'left wing' of the anti-nuclear movement, THE NEW Egypt-USIsrael deal lays down a timetable for Israel's withdrawal from the Sinai peninsula, the abandonment of Jewish settlements and military bases there and the creation in the Gaza strip of a degree of limited local autonomy. The diplomatic "breakthroughs' did not lie in any solution to the question of Jerusalem or the West Bank, but in persuading Sadat to make a deal which did not commit Israel to the slightest change of policy on these questions.

Sadat, of course, in order to cover his sellout of the Palestinians, tried to make Sraeli oppression of our The Palestinian people affirm and insist that the PLO is its sole legitimate representative and refuse any trusteeship or alternative, no consisting of the Socialist Environment and Resnurees Association (SERA) and energy ovo (president, zann Arthur Scargill). Armed with facts and figures they have highlighted some of the key issues: the erosion of trade union and civil rights, the inadequacies of safety standards, the problem ot disposal of nuclear waste, the resulting unempioyment in orner industries such as the coal industry.

However, at the same time as knocking down the myths propagated by the establishment, the anti-nuclear movement sets up a new myth -the idea that public debates, Government policy reviews, or (for the more radical) bans on nuclear development, can solve the problems under capitalism.

In short, the socialism of SERA is utopian; it becomes a new kind of reformism which Tribunites and MPs out that the agreement did provide points of linkage with those issues, even if they weren't spelled out clearly. But that idea was shot down within hours by Begin himself.

Addressing the Knesset, he ruled out any possibility of Palestinian statehood in the West Bank or Gaza, or of a comprehensive withdrawal. 'It will not happen. We shall not agree to it, we shan't allow it, we shan't make it possible.' And in replying to an opposition MP, he made it clear that 'autonomy will not lead to Palestinian statehood - there is no power on earth that will force us to allow a matter in what form shape.

We look forward to a just and lasting peace in the area, achieved only through our people's exercise of their right to self-determination. and like Robin Cook can latch onto.

On a different tack, a motlon passea recently by Edin- 11 _ 1_ burgh South NUPE to go to Edinburgh Trades Council put the issues of nuclear power in the context of class struggle.

It calls for full trade union rights and workers control ot safety in the industry. 'All measures Juaged loy ine RYґ.І th= workers' investigations) necessary (for safety) to be taken even if these make the further development of the nuclear power programme financially unviable compared to other energy options'. The resolution insists on acrion to protect jobs in the energy industries, through shortening the working week.

Although the TC did not select the motion to go to the STUC, the TC delegates will be supporting guments.

Our approach Palestinian state in Judea, Samaria and Gaza...

Begin also stressed that expropriation of Arab lands and Zionist settlement on the West Bank would continue.

Israel had to be dragged to the negotiating table by the US and granted billions of dollars to shift at all. Egypt is bankrupt and very much a US dependency now. The deal will help stop up the holes in her economy and at the same time tie Egypt more closely to the US.

For the present, the other Arab states are expressing unanimous hostility to the agreement.

JAMES DAVIES national independence, after total Israeli withdrawal from all the occupied territories and after establishing an independent Palestinian state.

Arab Palestinian sovercriticised as unrealistic, as the level of conscinueness of the workers in the nuclear industry is not such that they are raising demands for safety protection and shorter hours. This is hardly surprising considerable the political vetting that goes on before and during employment in the industry. But recent actions at both Aldermaston and Wiwdaw. 1 L. yy muscale suggest tnat писlear workers, given the solidarity and encouragement of the rest of the labour movement, will find the confidence to start raising these Unity of nuclear and non-nuclear workers must be at the heart of any labour movement strategy on nuciear power.

DAVE SMITH Secretary, Edinburgh e for the People group [in personal capacity] JOHN MACDONALD eignty must return to Arab Jerusalem which "is an indivisible part of the West Bank. This is a historical and spiritual cause which cannot be compromised.

Signed by over 121 individuals, including the mayors and deputy mayors of 18 major towns and villages; municipal and village councillors; representatives of unions, professional associations and charitable societies.

NB: Point Four implies that there are legitimate boundaries to a state of Israel which would be respected if the Israelis withdrew within them.

For our part, we do not accept the legitimacy of the state of Israel at all. The Zionist state is nothing but the imperialist-backed expropriation of the national rights of the Palestinians.

Scan page 10

Why the miners The crisis in shipbuilding is world wide. Orders have s umped by PETER TEBBUTT [PPC, Falmouth] 200 WORKERS at the Falmouth Ship Repair Yards have already accepted voluntary redundancies. These are part of the 450 job cuts demanded by British Shipbuilders as their price for temporarily withdrawing their threat to close the yard completely. Accepting the redundancies is a big defeat in the fight to keep the yard open. It undermines the case for saving jobs, and shows the bosses a weakness they will exploit.

Now the management are using their opportunity to get the Falmouth workers to work themselves out of a job faster. Overtime is being worked again in the yard, and the workers' main adyantage in any bargaining — having ships stuck in the yard waiting for repairs - is being lost.

Of the three ships that were in the yard when British Shipbuilders threatened to close it, one has already left and another (a large terry) is due to have its repairs completed by Wednesday 28th March. It was partly the thought of having ships worth £15 million left stranded that forced British Shipbuilders to any sort of deal at all. Now they have no such fears.

For the workers who accepted redundancy, the future looks none too rosy either. The actual amounts they are to be paid have not yet been announced, and the chances of getting other skilled work - or any work at all - in Falmouth are slim. For most, getting another job will mean leaving the area altogether, and adverts for skilled jobs in towns hundreds of miles away, in Coventry or Scotland, are the only ones in the local papers. The management are making the generous offer of paying the interest on any bank loans needed for moving house -out of the workers' own redundancy pay!

The Falmouth Docks Action Group is still fighting against the very real prospect of a closure. It is calling for the Government and the nationalised British Shipbuildto the lowest level since 1965. ers to open the yard to new work, to invest £2½ million immediately and a further f4 million over the next 12 months, and to push through no more redundancies. The group is also calling for a guarantee from the Government that the yard will be kept open for at least the next two years.

However, two years would hardly be a real guarantee for jobs. The world crisis in shipbuilding is not a passing problem.

At the end of 1978, world shipbuilding order books were down 30% from 1977. For British Shipbuilders, new orders fell by December 1978 to only a quarter their 1977 levels in both tonnage and prices.

It is the Falmouth workers, and other shipyard workers, who are being made to pay for British Shipbuilders' problems in the dog-eat-dog world of international capitalist competition. These problems will not simply go away. The question is: must the workers pay?

An offer by Christopher Bailey of Bristol Channel Shiprepairers to buy out Falmouth was met by the government with immediate talks, before they even bothered to talk to the workers in the yard. Now it's been dropped only because Bailey himself has lost interest -probably waiting for a better opportunity when the workers might accept such a deal with the "gratitude' and at the sort of price, which he wants.

This is a familiar story in Cornwall. 'Entrepreneurial spivs' move in with offers to 'save' the area. The local papers splash front page headlines like 'new hope for the unemployed', and any real fightback is deflected by false hopes. The last example was the offer by a shadowy American businessman called Sprinkle to save the Wheal Jane tin mine. It later turned out Sprinkle had no money.

The attempts to buy off workers in Cornwall with 'new hopes', while redundancies are pushed through, can't go on working for ever. You can't compromise with capitalism, the only option is to fight the redundancies and closures or be driven under. voted by PAUL OWEN.

THE MINERS' majority vote to accept their 9% offer is a measure of how the Labour Government and its agent of intervention in the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), the bureaucracy, have been able to control and manipulate the miners over the last four and a half years. The 'don't rock the boat' loyalty which a large majority es NUM by setting regions with rich coalfaces against those with poor and difficult faces.

The vote by several areas to reject the current pay deal - which forced the ballot - showed militancy is not dead in the rank and file. But Arthur Scargill's silence didn't help. An energetic and aggressive campaign for the 40% and 30 hours claim was needed. Scargill has never risen much

----- pull-quotes -----

A fake- peace im fhe Middle East

← Contents of Socialist Organiser (unnumbered)

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →