Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Fisher angles for defeat

Socialist Organiser (unnumbered), April 1979 · scan p. 10 · about 653 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

by JOHN MACDONALD [Edinburgh South Hospitals NUPE] THE NATIONAL Committee of the National Union of Public Employees [NUPE] has voted to call off action by hospital ancillary workers. As we go to press it is considering ending the ambulance crews' industrial action too.

Commenting on the London crews' vote to return to normal working, NUPE official Giles Duncan made it clear: "There is still considerable dissatisfaction among London ambulancemen with their pay offer" • Many of those voting to go back to work have simply given up trying to push the union leaderships into fighting on their behalf. They know they haven't got justice.

They know that Alan Fisher, NUPE's leader, wanted to sell out. Fisher has hidden behind the excuse that NUPE can't "go it alone" when the other three health unions - CoHSE, TGWU and GMWU - have agreed to the 9% plus £1 offer. But NUPE has a majority among the hospital workers. Behind the scenes, Fisher was strongly encouraging the other unions to 'compel' NUPE to go back.

Fisher was sacrificing his members' interests in order not to 'rock the boat' for the Government. He has admitted that "The general election is clearly a factor which has to be taken into account. It is possible... we may see the Government defeated and a general election declared"

While Fisher wriggled, NUPE's rank and file was showing its militancy -fighting not only for their claim, but against wide- scale organised scabbing and the threat of dismissal by Health Authorities. While the national negotiators were agreeing the 9% plus £1 offer, 8,000 ancillaries in Derbyshire walked out because the Area Health Authority sent fifty laundry workers home for working to rule.

In Stafford, 150 workers walked out of the General Infirmary after management threatened to cut off their pay if action was not stopped.

YOUSUEE In Scotland, NUPE members voted 8-to-1 against the present deal, and the back to work call will not be readily followed. As that call went out, Glasgow hospitals were admitting emergencies only, because of a laundry workers' strike.

In Edinburgh, the ancillaries' anger against the Lothian Health Board spilled over on the 26th when members from the North and South hospitals occupied the Board's offices while the unions were negotiating the deal. In Edinburgh the strike wave has been growing, not petering out.

The fact that the nurses' representatives have accepted an offer was, of course, a setback for the health workers. Fisher will not be slow to use it to justify his call for a return to work. Yet there are hardly any health workers that have failed to draw some important lessons from this strike:

* An all-out strike would have been infinitely more powerful than the 'selective action' strategy.

* Keeping key sectors out of the fight - like the watér workers - weakens the efforts of the others.

* Strong rank and file organisation is needed. Reliance on the Fishers of this world, let alone the Donnets, Spanswicks, and Evanses, is a recipe for failure. of the rank and file have to the Labour Party has had a subduing effect. And a series of packages — bonus schemes, travelling time and washing allowances, and a watered down version of the NUM's early retirement demand — have sugarcoated the token pay awards made since 1975.

The incentive bonus scheme accepted in the last ballot reintroduced productivity bargaining into the industry and also threatened the national unity of the above the horizons of regional militancy and celebrity demagogy. Now it seems the gravitational pull of the presidency is also having its effect.

The task facing socialists is to build a rank and file movement in the NUM, which will rely not on one or two celebrities but on 200,000, and which will fight for a working-class answer to the National Coal Board and any wage-freezing, job-slashing government.

----- pull-quotes -----

ENU LOW PAY TOOT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser (unnumbered)

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →