THE BENNETT REPORT Mason tries to cover up
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
1 May 1978, shop steward Brian Maguire was found hanged cell in the Royal Ulster Constabulary's Castlereagh barrack Torkers struck in West Belfast and 3,000 marched in protest IN THE JANUARY Socialist Organiser we launched a debate on the EEC elections. Donald Sassoon argued a pro-EEC case; and Alf Lomas the anti-EEC position. Mark Douglas argued that socialists must 'break out of the nationalist ambush', and Simon Temple put the view that "In or out of the EEC is not an issue for the working class; international unity in struggle is". In the March SO, Graham Durham called for a vigorous socialist camThis month STEVE BUNDRED calls for an offort to send socialist anti-EEC Euro-MPs to Strasbourg.
Steve is the Labour candidate for London South-East on June 7th. He works for the NUM, belongs to Islington North CLP, and is an active supporter of the SCLV. He is a former Islington councillor and was a leader of a tenants' campaign there to get a slum estate demolished. By PETER Islington Central CLP • FOR THE second time in ten years, the British government has been forced to admit to ill-treatment of detainees in the north of Despite the government and media attempts to portray the brutality as the work of a few rotten apples in the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC), the Bennett Report reveals otherwise. * Injuries 'sustained in police custody were not self inflicted.
Well documented cases of ill-treatment being used to extract confessions have been made public by both Amnesty International and the Northern Ireland Police Surgeons Associations (of which Dr. Robert Irwin is Secretary). RUC chief Sir Kenneth Newman's rejection of Irwin's statements on Weekend Television as unsubstantiated shows the extent of the cover-up. A week later the Bennett report proved him wrong and it has since been announced thet Newman is 'transferring' from the RUC. (Once the facts became undeniable, Newman had the arrogance to tell reporters he 'would not guarantee' that brutality wouldn't continue.) * There should be closer supervision of interrogation by uniformed RUC officers.
This recommendation has been seized on to imply that the uniformed branch of the RUC emerges unblemished from the Inquiry. Bennett actually commends the already existing role of uniformed chief inspectors supervising interviews. Clearly this means that he finds that the kind of brutality highlighted by police doctors and by the occasional acquittal of suspects who allegedly confessed could not have gone unnoticed. * 'Disquiet about the effectiveness of the complaints procedure.
Bennett implicitly accepts the role of the RUC hierarchy in covering up brutality. Despite the acquittals in the courts and the extremely high rate of complaints (671 for assault by the RUC 1977 when altogether 3571 suspects were questioned), not a single conviction of a police officer has resulted and in no case have disciplinary proceedings been brought.
Can the RUC be trusted? No, according to Bennett, who recommends the use of senior officers from Britain to investigate serious allegations in future. Even the Director of Public Prosecutions is asked to 'give fuller explanations' of why so many substantiated cases of illtreatment have been dropped.
Bennett's proposals, not as yet accepted by N.Ireland Secretary Roy Mason, hardly alter the present position of complaints held up for months. Mason's much publicised new Police Complaints Board has no power to investigate allegations of criminal misconduct.
The Police Authority has commented that the Report's proposals 'do not in themshe As thority Sale improve * 'The consistent refusal to allow access to a solicitor throughout the whole period of detention Bennett accepts the RUC view that a suspect is unlikely to make a confession if a solicitor is present. However, even his suggestion that 48 hours of custody should be long enough before access is unconditionally granted has in paign to get Britain out of the EEC.
Instead the issue will be whether the Community has advanced or impeded the cause of socialist internationalism; and whether continued membership will make the advent of socialism more, or less, likely. As in all political campaigns the key issue is how best to control the power of capital, and who is best able to represent the interests of workers in debates about their future. In this context it is clear that if the Tories cannot be trusted in the UK then we have a already been rejected Mason. •* Failure by the RUC to observe the rules governing access to medical examination.
Paragraph 244 of the Bennett Report mentions a case in which RUC officers failed to arrange an examination following an assault allegation. More common is their zealous application of a change in the rules since June 1978 allowing them discretion as to whether to permit a prisoner to be examined by his/her own doctor. The virtual ban on private doctors that resulted was a factor that contributed to the concern felt by police surgeons who saw their reputation threatened by the continuous public denial of ill-treatment that they had documented.
The collusion of the RUC hierarchy and the British direct rule administration in the use of brutality has been justified (and even welcomed by Unionists) by the high rate of convictions obtained in the no-jury Diplock courts. That 80% of these convictions are based on confessions is justified on the grounds that evidence is impossible to collect and witnesses intimidated.
Hence the only basis for arrest is Army Intelligence and the only evidence in court is a confession.
The Bennett Inquiry assumed from the outset that this system 'will continue for the immediate future' It is imperative that Labour's recent record in Ireland does not go unopposed in Britain. Both Gerry Fitt of the SDLP and Labour MP Tom Litterick have called for Mason's removal. Constituency Labour Parties should add to this call and not let the Bennett Report get shrugged off. We must ensure a fuli debate on Ireland takes place at this year's conference. duty to uppuse uiem in Europe also.
There is no shortage of arguments to show that joining the EEL was a political and economic blunder. Far from promoting internationalism, the Community fosters a belief that there are only nine countries in Europe that matter. It remains at present closed to weaker European states such as Greece and Portugal; and its relations with developing countries are characterised by the dumping of surpluses A basis for class unity?
----- pull-quotes -----
TVUVDO OFF