Smoothing over the struggle
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
& GRAHAM BASH BETWEEN 1970 and 1974 the bosses tried to deal with the working class by direct confrontation, through \the Tory Government. The miners' strike of 1974, and the downfall of the Heath government, marked their defeat. A Labour government came to power.
Labour had promised a 'fundamental shift in the balance of wealth and power in favour of working people and their families' . Instead we got the Social Contract.
The deal was that the govGRAT Grunwicks - the law was no use to us ernment would give trade unions new legal rights in return for 'cooperation' especially in the field of wage restraint.
The deal has turned out to be a very one-sided attair. The new legal rights - generally only marginal imIt shall be lawful for one or more persons in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute to attend at or near a] A place where another person works or carries on business;
b] Any other place where another person happens to be, not being a place where he resides Conspiracy and Unlawful Assembly charges can still be used against pickets.
The right of picketing still depends much more on the balance of forces than on the law. As the Labour Research Department put it, the law gave Little more than the CIA SNIAOYO UNT icemanos seni gaition right for two pickets at the most to stand at each factory gate, holding non-offensive placards and standing on one side and bowing graciously as the blacklegs ride triumphantly by'.
The Labour Government has also positively restricted trade union action by making trespass a criminal (not civil) offence in certain cases. It introduced the law on the pretext that it was needed to prevent squatters occupying homes of people who were (for example) away on holiday. It can be used by the police to arrest workers occupying a factory, and in one case already (Smiths Crisps, Aintree) it has been used to stop an occupation by the threat of legal action.
The Government never intended to help workers with their disputes. What it wanted was to smooth over disputes with as little struggle as possible. Another measure along these lines was the setting up in September 1974 of the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS). Its role was to prevent what Harold Wilson called the 'manifestly avoidable the company was given a further two months in which to reply.
The company's reply was, in any case, No. And that was that.
UNFAIR
The Industrial Relations clauses on redress for unfair dismissal. They were and further strengthened by the Employment Protection Act. Unfair dismissal cases have been going to tribunals by the thousand — but mostLy to little avail.
Even if the industrial tribunal finds the dismissal is unfair, and even if it orders reinstatement (which happens in only 2% of cases) the employer still has the right to choose to pay increased compensation. Bosses can still victimise militants — they just have to pay a bit more for the privilege.
So much for Employment Protection.
The same Act has also given some new legal rights to have time off for trade union and public duties, and guaranteed payments for lay-offs - but these guarantees do not apply to workers laid off because of an industrial dispute, Or who 'unreasonably refuse' to do alternative work, or who fail to comply with 'reasonable requirements'. The minimum payments are so low anyway that many collective agreements achieve much more.
The Employment Protection Act extended the minimum period of notice that an employer must give under the Contracts Employments Act of 1972. It improved conditions for maternity leave, job security during pregnancy, and maternity pay for full time workers who had been in the same job for at least two years.
It is also supposed to give the trade unions new rights to be consulted about redundancies and to have information disclosed to them by companies. However, there is no legal compulsion on employers to take any notice of union objections to redundancies or to disclose any information they do not want to disclose!
The Equal Pay Act came into force in 1975, but it is not one of this Government's laws. It was originally in. troduced by Barbara Castle in 1970, Giving the bosses five years to 'make preparations' The Act says that a woman is entitled to equal pay if she is employed on the same or broadly similar' work as a man, and if her job has been rated equivalent to a man's under a job evaluation scheme. If a woman's job falls into either of these categories and she is not getting equal pay she can apply to an industrial tribunal.
The loopholes of the Act and the pro-boss bias of the Even for those women workers who do come under the Act, there were dozens of get-outs.
Part-time women workers have no right to the same hourly rate as full-time male workers doing exactly the same job, so one tribunal said. Women workers doing more demanding or skilled jobs than male fellow-workers can quite legally be paid less than them. At the Trico factory in west London the Tribunal decided that it was all right for men to be paid more than women for identical work because the men used to do a night shift.
Another firm had inspectors' (male) and 'viewers' (female) doing the same job.
They got over the problem by creating a single grade at the lower, female, rate pay - and paying the existing male staff a special bonus to maintain their old rate of pay'. • The Tribunal swallowed that too.
High Court re-wrote Labour's law to say this man had no right to picket And even if the Tribunal does decide in favour of the woman worker, there is no immediate legal compulsion on the boss to pay up. If he refuses, getting redress if a long and complex legal process.
Women's average weekly pay is still far below that of men's - and the gap is actually getting wider.
The record is no better on the Sex Discrimination Act. The Labour government's law-making efforts have produced a bonanza for the trade union leaders in terms of boards, committees, tribunals and quangos to get seats on. But for the working class they have meant few gains — and four and a half years during which the trade union leaders spared no effort to achieve by stealth and treachery what the Tories failed to achieve by open class war.
----- pull-quotes -----
incorporated in the new Act with some improvements,