New ideas needed
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
by LAST WEEK the workers at Vickers Scotswood works, on Tyneside, occupied their factory, locked out the bosses, and began a work-in.
By Friday 4th, however, the work-in had ended. It was called off in return for the bosses offering further talks on their plans to close the factory. But the bosses offered no climb-down on the principle of closure.
The outlook for the Vickers job battle is grey, if not black: and the lessons to be learnt are vital for the coming years of Tory government.
The Tories are set on encouraging cut-throat competition, and that means more unemployment. Doubly so, since a serious world recession - maybe as deep as or deeper than 1974-5 - is clearly on the horizon.
Vickers' Tyneside plants epitomise the decline of traditional industries within British capitalism. In the 1940s Scotswood and the neighbouring Elswick plant employed 20,000. Now there are only 550 in Scotswood.
Vickers are pulling out of heavy engineering and putting their money into foreign buck investment and fastsectors like office equipment. They are deliberately refusing orders for Scotswood: one repair job from British Leyland was turned back when it was already on the motorway coming to Tyneside.
200 workers have already gone through the gate at Scotswood. Notice for another 100 expires at the end of May. The bosses want to sack nearly all the workers by the end of June, just keeping on a 'skeleton staff' to work on the rundown of the plant until September.
The workers are blocking the movement of any finished work from the factory. Yet the bosses seem unmoved. The Vickers combine committee has pledged call for national action is still making its way through union channels.
If Vickers Scotswood goes under, it will not just be because the workers have been sold out by cynical right-wing union officials. The union leadership in the factory is strongly organised, experienced, and left wing.
They have set up a Save Scotswood Campaign Committee, with wide support from the whole area. They have organised demonstrations. They have published campaign bulletins, hammering home the point that the issue is profits versus workers' interests.
But their demands have been geared to pressuring the bosses and the Government, rather than mobilising the rank and file. They call for:
• Opening the books to make possible a feasibility study on alternative. production at Scotswood;
• an investigation into Vickers' marketing and planning policies;
• negotiations involving Vickers bosses, the Labour Government, stewards;
• government aid to be backed by guarantees continued production.
The leading Scotsw ood stewards are socialists. Yet in their demands they very much bound by the lim - capitalist politics. Thus the basic aim of their demands was to get the Labour Government to help pressure Vickers to keep Scotswood open, and to provide funds.
The Labour Government did in fact offer subsidies to DUNLOP SPEKE WORKER 3 STAYS ACAINST CLASURES "BUR Vickers. Vickers simply said: No. The closure goes ahead.
To counter Vickers' hard stand, what is really needed is an indefinite occupation of the works, backed up by strike action throughout the combine, with the demand for workers' control in the combine so as to share the work out with a shorter work week, no loss of jobs, and no loss of pay. Under the Labour Government this demand should have been coupled with a call for nationalisation without compensation.
That strategy would mean a head-on collision with the logic of capitalism. It would mean the stewards having to go ahead against the horrified insistence of the union officials that they should do nothing so extreme. (Though 'extreme' actions once underway can gather enough momentum to compel official support). beating the experience of Dunlop Speke. There too the plant leadership is left wing. They published a broadsheet, organised pickets, demonstrations, civil disobedience, and an occupation of the local radio station. Dunlop... against the odds They called for a blacking on all Dunlop tyres, as a way of hitting the company without putting the workers formally into dispute and thus losing rights under the Employment Protection Act. They sent flying pickets out, and got support from dockers, lorry drivers, and carworkers.
But as the closure date approached, the stewards proposed a 'viability plan' which would mean 1,000 jobs being cut. Dunlop still said no. The closure date came — and Speke closed.
The stewards are continuing the battle: but with the workers now outside the factory, each individually facing the choice of whether to take the redundancy pay or to stick it out, the odds against them are huge.
The Dunlop and Scotswood stewards are well able to lead militant battles. But the usual run of militant battions are battles to strike a better bargain with capitalism. within the terms of capitalism. A factory occupation against the Scotswood closure would challenge capitalist property rights themselves.
Thus the Dunlop and Scotswood stewards find that neither the concepts of militant bargaining, nor their general ideas of socialism as a better society for the future, have any grip on the situation.
-Their experience adds another chapter to a momentous history beginning with Upper Clyde Shipbuilders work-in in 1971 and the Fisher Bendix occupation in 1972. UCS got another capitalist to take the yard overwith big cuts in the workforce. Fisher Bendix became a cooperative - KME -which has just closed down because it could not keep abreast in the world of capitalist competition.
With the fall of the Labour Government, the Scotswood stewards will have to reconsider their strategy. They need to ponder what Karl Marx wrote over a hundred years ago: "The right to work is, in the bourgeois sense, an absurdity, a miserable pious wish.
"But behind the right to work stands the power over capital; beyond the power over capital, the appropriation of the means of production, their subjection to the associated working class, and therefore the abolition of wage slavery, of capital, and of their mutual relations" • Any real gains for the right to work' can only be by-products of revolutionary struggle against the power of capital.
----- pull-quotes -----
support for the fight to save the jobs, but the committee's