What the Voting Figures Showed
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Right: Tariq Ali got a tiny vote for Socialist Unity de- rop: Jonn maxion won unasgow camcar sur spite the tense political situation in Southall and the miserable record of Labour MP Syd Bidwell: Left:
ion time, some people have A series of polls and sursuggested the opposite: that veys have shown a steady Labour's losses were mainly right wing shift in the averamong the middle class and age answers given by Labour The election results - the their attitude to nationalisatcrude constituency totals, at ion, strikes, expanding social least - give no support to services, and similar issues. either of these theories. No significance can be Constituencies with very attached to the absolute large majorities - which are figures produced by these almost always the most heav- surveys: opinion polls alily working class areas — ways tend to get the sort of showed almost exactly the answers the polsters want. average swing and almost But the shift probably repexactly the average increase resents something: not that The Tory press suggested capitalism (for the shift conthat there was a specially tinued during the great class large swing against lett- struggles of 1970-74), but wing Labour candidates. In that they are more cynical fact. the average swing in about the socialist ideals offns 3S bili IP for rbyla drift st four t happen paign. talist back. se picked vernment nty of boat. The the it that ge the and that ge contwould nade ding. le right r wingtoo. even of didn't s last taken ir se who limit to g they ility is sur is as ing res it party ey are counts genthe our Par e Cabin om reponal ways or it rushing led to the vas like ment lelations cause a d to have h it. / constrial se won picketders to go to ake their artyl e we're he right e an all/ policie: e next ust stop es to a y like thered by secret leen a by COLIN FOSTER LABOUR'S worst results were in four safe seats in East London: Barking, Dagenham, Bethnal Green, and Stepney & Poplar. In all these constituencies the Tories doubled, or almost doubled, their score, and the Labour vote fell by at least 15%. In Bethnal Green the Labour vote was down 28%.
In Tower Hamlets - the borough covering the Bethnal Green and Stepney constituencies - the council workers' strike was particularly hard-fought. And the Dagenham and Barking constituencies are near the biggest British Ford plant, at Dagenham.
Clearly the Labour government's efforts to beat down the Ford strike and the concil workers' strike disgusted many Labour voters — while the anti-strike agitation also stirred up Tory voters to come out in force.
And what the election results showed overall is that the attempt by a Labour Government to manage capitalism at the expense of the working class over five years of economic slump and stagnation has driven general opinion to the right. Numerically, the Labour vote was slightly up on October 1974, but the total turnout was also larger, The Tory vote went up by no less than 31%, and Labour's share of the total poll, at 36.9%, was the lowest since 1931 (though Febtuary 1974's share was only marginally higher).
There were three apparent offsetting factors to this trend. In Wales, and more spectacularly in Scotland, the Nationalist vote slumped -by 20% in Wales, and by 40% in Scotland. As a result, Labour had markedly better results than in England. The devolution referendums, and their results, evidently succeeded in undercutting the Nationalists, In northern England, too, the anti-Labour swing was significantly lower than in the south. It seems that voters feared that a Tory victory would mean jobs disappearing even faster. Thus Newcastle, Sunderland, South Shields, and many Liverpool constituencies showed small swings, though Liverpool Edge Hill stayed Liberal by a large majority.
A big and well-organised turnout of the black vote for Labour also helped to limit the Tory advance in many areas. Southall showed only a 0.3% swing to the Tories; Brent South, 0.4%, Birmingham Sparkbrook, 0.3%; Leicester East, 1.3%; •Leicester West, 2.1%; Bradford North 1.6%. Manchester Moss Side, Leicester South, and Bradford West all showed pro-Labour swings.
The widely-predicted collapse of the Irish vote for Labour was not shown by the figures. The two Luton seats went Tory, but not through specially large swings, and Brian Sedgemore actually increased the Labour vote by 3% despite losing Luton West. In London constituencies with large Irish communities, the swing was rather lower than average: Brent East, 3.4%; Hampstead, 2.1%; Islington North, 5.7%; St. Pancras North, 5.4%. (London's average swing was 6.4%).
Some surveys • before the election suggested that Labour's working class vote was being eroded, while middle class support was remaining relatively solid. Going on impressions at electCommunist Party candidate Alex Maxwell skilled workers. in the Labour vote. constituencies where well-known left-wingers were standing was almost exactly the same as the overall average. Tony Benn suffered a marginally bigger than average swing in Bristol South East - 7.1% as against an average in southern England of 6.9% - but there was a much bigger deviation from the average trend in Leeds North East, where Keith Joseph, the figurehead of right wing Toryism, is the MP: the constituency showed a 0.8% pro-Labour swing.
The five candidates backing the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, who did to varying degrees campaign for left-wing policies, suffered an average 5.3% proTory swing — slightly less in most cases than the average swing in their areas. voters to questions about workers more readily accept well- icially icially proclaimed by the labour movement. And that's no surprise, when official "socialism' has proved so irrelevant in the great capitalist crisis of the 1970s.
The cynicism has a positive side, insofar as it expresses working class selfreliance and impatience with the gradualist, bureaucratic methods of the Labour leadership. The SCLV campaign was a small step towards linking up that impatience with socialist politics and freeing socialist politics from the straitjacket of drab Fabian welfare-statism.
The left-of-Labour campaigns had little success. The Communist Party's 38 candidates scored an average of 420 votes, as against 745 for their 44 candidates in February 1974. And it wasn't really a left-of-Labour vote: the CP manifesto was flabby and gradualist, and in Hackney North CP candidate Monty Goldman was well to the right of Labour candidate Ernie Roberts.
The Workers' Revolutionary Party got an average of 227 for its 60 candidates, well down on the 466 average it got in February 1974 for 9 candidates. Again, it it doubtful how much that represents a real left-wing vote: wherever the WRP's crackpot mixture of Islamic socialism, catastrophism and vile slander campaigns stands on the political spectrum, it is certainly nowhere near rational working class politics.
Socialist Unity got an average of 283 votes for its ten candidates, only marginally more than the International Marxist Group (the main backers of Socialist Unity) got for their candidates in February 1974. Their best score was Tariq Ali's 477 in Southall, and mostly they got only the sort of fringe-vote totals that the WRP's zany campaign also managed to pick up.
The best vote for a radical fringe candidate was Brendan Gallagher's 638 in Barnsley. Gallagher stood against Roy Mason in order to campaign for British withdrawal from Ireland and to publicise the case of his son, jailed in Long Kesh on the basis of a written confession extracted from him by police.
The most gratifying feature of the election results was the drop in the National Front's vote. Although their total poll was up to 191,267 (as against 114,415 in October 1974) that was sp'ead out between many more candidates. Their average score was only about 750.
In Leicester East, the NF had 3662 votes in February 1974; in October 1974 they were down to 1967, and this time to 1385. In the two West Bromwich constituencies, they got 6014 votes in February 1974, 3714 in October 1974, and only 2526 this The East London seats John Tyndall and Martin Webster were standing als i showed a drop in the Nazi vi te.