Nationalisation: Socialist Cause or a Prop for Profiteers or a Prop for Prof
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Nationalisation
Steel: nationalisation did not stop redundancies an industry they had lett in coal. Four years ago while virtual ruin. And they've individual consumers were gone on taking their cut ever paying 90p for a hundredsince. In 1963, for instance, weight of coal, private firms they took £50 millior in inter- and power stations got it for est on compensation, out of 50p a ton. the NCB's operating profit of Meanwhile, tens of thousShipbuilding: a failure of private enterprise TWO THINGS characterise of the Labour Co-ordinating the Bennites in the Labour Committee. Briefly, they Party: their undying optim- want an increase in public ism and their unwillingness spending of £3,000 million a to go along with the CBI. The year to reduce unemploysnag is that they are optim- ment; and the introduction of istic about the behaviour of import controls, coupled with businessmen and city money compulsory planning agreemanagers, and they are un- ments and a beefed-up willing to recognise what is National Enterprise Board to correct in the CBI's analysis halt Britain's industrial of the problems of British decline. capitalism for fear of having The problem with this is The Bennites' alternative correct analysis of what is manifesto for the election has wrong with British capitalism recently been published in and a fanciful view of the Labour Activist — the paper ease with which institutions TO MANY people, and not all of them Tories, nationalisation is a dirty word. But it was not always this way. Before the takeover of rail, coal, steel and shipbuilding, most workers had fought hard for nationalisation, with the confidence that it would benefit them.
Nationalisation is an old aspiration of the labour movement. It is written into the Labour Party's constitution - Clause 4, dating back to 1918. Nationalisation was a byword for socialism.
What has gone wrong?
State-run
Today the Tories try to make hay from the problems of the state-run industries. They are doing all in their power to further discredit the idea of nationalisation and their big business friends are spending millions of pounds to stop any more of it. Building industry bosses alone spent £500,000 on a big advertising campaign.
The Tories say they will hive off to private industry the profitable sectors of nationalised industry like telecommunications and shipbuilding.
But they had plenty of opportunity to de-nationalise the whole of the coal industry and the railways, steel and post and telephone services long ago. Why didn't they do it?
And why have right-wing, Tory-minded governments in France, Italy and other countries carried through just as many nationalisations as Labour has in Britain?
Many sectors of industry - especially the most basic to support their solutions.!
Revolutionary socialist weekly.
From May 19th, Workers' Action will be going from 8 pages to 12 pages, with four extra pages of background analysis, in-depth discussion, debate and polemic. The price will go. up from 10p to 15p to meet the increased costs.
Special offer: until the end of May, o-Lacriptions at the old rate, f4 for 25 issues, €7.50 for 50 (in Britain and In magazine format. 32 pages for 35p plus 15p påp from 60 Loughborough Rd, London SW9.
sectors, which supply and
service others - have simply outgrown competitive capitalism. They must be operated on a vast scale and with huge doses of investment, and they cannot be allowed to go bust for fear of wrecking the whole national capitalist economy. So the state steps in.
Private capitalists had bled dry the railways, the coal industry, steel and numerous other industries in their search for a quick profit. But the rest of capitalism needed steel, coal and rail transport.
Nationalisation has become a prop for private profiteers. Through price fixing and direct and indirect government subsidies, through compensation and interest payments, the rich make a bonanza out of it.
Just look at the National Coal Board. When the mines were taken over in 1947 the pit owners got an initial handout of t3,000 million tor that it springs from an inhostile to the idea of state control can be persuaded to cooperate with such a policy.
There is a view pedalled in the Bennite literature that British industry is enormously profitable but is refusing to invest and is instead shipping its money overseas.
Certain parts of this picture ed their efforts on building up their overseas operations so that now investment in overseas subsidiaries by British firms is almost two fifths of investment in Britain — twice the level of the early seventies.
It is also true that British companies manufacture much more in their overseas offshoots — at the expense of British exports - than German and Japanese companies do. However, much of this overseas expansion is financed by local borrowing, and direct investment overseas by British companies is more than offset by the in£72 million. The NUM estimates that well over £2,000 million has been squeezed out of the industry in this way alone since 1947.
Meanwhile private industry was subsidised with cheap flow of repatriated profits.
There is a simple reason why British companies have concentrated on building up their overseas business: Britain has been an unattractive place to invest. Profits in Britain have been under severe pressure. Despite the recovery in profits over the last four years, they still only account for about 6 per cent of company output - half the level at the end of the sixties.
There is some evidence that the profits of the largest companies have recovered much more sharply than those of the economy as a whole but this is largely due to the North Sea oil bonanza, and the growth of companies' overseas profits as a result of the tall in the value of the pound.
Thus far the CBI probably agree: the solution, they say.
is to increase profits at the ands of jobs were axed, to try to make coal mining more efficient and ... profitable.
Between them, British Rail and the NCB shed 700,000 jobs over the past 15 years.
The Post Office in 1974expense of wages, so as to encourage investment and create jobs.
The Bennites — who dare not agree with the analysis for fear of agreeing with the cure - say planning agreements will force companies.
to invest and, if they refuse, the NEB can act. The question simply is: how credible is it that British business will do something which it believes is not in its own interest?
A similar problem arises with the LCC's plan to increase public spending. Although part of this will be self financing, as money will be saved on unemployment and social security benefits, some will have to be found elsewhere. Assuming that the ten percent increase in income tax necessary would not be the chosen option, the Bennite government would have to borrow the money. But the the last 75 mysteriously made a deficit of £307 million. But then it was revealed that it had actually made a record profit of £800 million - before interest payments, depreciation and tax. It was all a matter of ... accounting.
Price fixing through government subsidies on contracts to major companies means another profit spree for the suppliers to the coal, steel, PO and power industries. In 1975 alone this cost British Gas £180 million.
Handouts to private enterprise and the old owners are not the only problem. The total absence of workers' control in the state industries further seals their capitalist function - though workers are constantly exhorted to greater efforts for 'their' industries.
Workers" participation schemes have simply twisted the aspirations to control into traps designed to make workers share in their own exploitation and take responsibility for speed-up and rationalisation. This happening at British Leyland and the Post Office. Profit The basic problem is the existence of a hostile capitalist state and system of production which demands profit. Profit is the real problem, not nationalisation. State takeovers while the system operates for profit can only mean Ja form of state capitalism.
For socialists, nationalisation should mean a shorter working week, better pay, and modernisation for social benefit. But even as it is, we there is no evidence that investment managers in City would provide it: year they showed that they nad considerable power to force policy changes on the government.
An economic policy completely out of line with thinking in the financial community would almost certainly precipitate a monetary and Can NEB chairman Leslie Murphy [above] impose socialism on the Stock Exchange currency crists It is revealing that when very similar arguments were rehearsed in the New: Statesman recently, the LCC replied saying that the analysıs was pessimistic and that policies for taking contmust support nationalisation. It deprives the capitalist class of direct control over important areas of industry, and is an advance in the direction of at least the forms of a future planned non-capitalist economy. But we must work to remove its present capitalist content and the dead weight of a diseased system which can no longer provide for workers' basic needs.
Coalmining: owners are stil getting compensation In the first election issue of Socialist Organiser, we wrote: under the Labour werent Son has not been discredited it was never tried".
But official Socialism cram die ser date dien long debates and political battles are needed to revive genuine working.
class Socialism.
MIKE DAVIS argues
above] that nationalisation is still a central Socialist demand - - but it must be coupled with a fight for workers' control and a ing capitalist State, replacing it with a workers"
state.
And CHRISTOPHER HIRD (deputy editor of the New Statesman] argues [below] that the •Bennite' Labour CoordEating committeen scheme of planning agreements a sort of half-hearted substitute for nationalisation - - пергасents an unworkable and naive attempt to tinker with capitalism, failing to face up to the need for radical answers.
rol of the financial and business community would have even less chance of success than the policies of the LCC, As things stand at the moment this is undoubtedly true and at the heart of the LCC approach is their ob.
sessive belief that problems of society which it has taken years to construct can be Solved quickly and simply be the government. Yet it seems quite unrealistic that any complex economy can be successfully supervised by national government planning agreements which are opposed by most of those charged with implementing them.
This is not, however, the counsel of despair. British industry is generating plenty of surplus at the moment; it is just that it wants freedom to invest it where it thinks fit. There is a pressing need to develop ideas about-how rank and file workers can, in a socialist society, control the means of production in their own interests. The size and difficulty of that task should not encourage us to fall for the fantasies of the Labour Co-ordinating Committee.
----- pull-quotes -----
ies of the LCC Fantas
WA: PO Box 135, London NIODD Chartist
are correct: many British companies have concentrat-