Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Non-racist immigration controls, are they possible?

Socialist Organiser no. 8, May 1979 · scan p. 7 · about 902 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Comrades, Bernard Misrahi wrote a generous but challenging review of my booklet for the Runnymede Trust on A New Immigration Policy, tor your February issue. I should like to respond to it, largely because the review took my suggestions seriously, even though not agreeing with them. And this sort of exchange is, I believe, the only way we can start moving towards a reversal of the direction that immigration policy under both Tory and Labour governments has taken continuously since 1962.

The reason why I attempted to suggest what a non-racist immigration policy might be like was this: if we want to reverse immigration policy we must have a strategy. So far, each new measure of restriction has been greeted with very small-scale opposition from the Left and from anti-racist and ethnic minority groups. the opposition has never had any alternative to ofter except either a completely open door (the Left) or freedom of entry from the Commonwealth (antiracist and immigrant groups).

The Labour Party took up the latter demand in 1962, but no MP in any party, so far as I know, has made it since, and no MP has demanded a completely open door. By now, we have a snowball's chance in Hell of getting any MP, or even many prospective candidates in the main parties, to adopt either. Thus there has been no real debate at all.

The restrictionists have had it all their own way. And the chance of really changing things seems to recede all the time. Yet no change in immigration control can happen except through Parliament. MPs are the people who have got to initiate any effective change. So how can we get them moving?

I think the answer lies partly my second reason for writing the booklet: we shall get no change until we can get MPs and the public at large to distinguish between 'race and "immigration' as issues. So long as they think immigration is all about race, they are scared of thinking about it like reasonable people at all.

I do not think we shall get an effective turn-around in the racial situation as a whole until Arrivals Now for the hurdles of official we get a turn-around in thinking about immigration. So I described report, some detail, the immigration control systems in four other countries: Norway, Sweden, Australia and Canada. The idea was to show how many different bases it is possible to have for an immigration poiicy: I mentioned a lot of other countries in passing, such as singapore, Swaziland, United States and Israel.

I could have mentioned any country, because all states now control immigration. Cuba, China, Tanzania, India, the Soviet Union all do so. In a world where immigration control has, sadly, become universal, we have no realistic hope at all of a sudden switch nere to an open door policy. To go on demanding an open door and ignore the possibilities of amending our law, while people suffer unnecessarily and appallingly under its provisions every day is, I think, to fail those people.

We need a system that does not imprison 'settled' residand unofficial racism ents without charge or trial before removing them from the country: that does not keep tamilies forcibly apart. And we can find examples in other countries to help drive home ne need for reform. Unce w et the ball rolling, we cal work for the next move, and the next, till we reach goal. But it has to roll first.

I stressed the Canadian example not because I think it perfect but because Canada used to. have very racist immigration laws indeed and now it has not. The policy discriminates against ünskilled workers, but not against particular racial groups, and this is a big change. The change has taken three decades, and results from two very different factors: a continuing need for labour during the first fifteen years after the war, and strong, continuing pressure trom voluntary agencies within Canada, particularly the churches, Trade unionism in Canada is and there are ALLELY other factors of which I do not have adequate knowledge to judge their importance in the debate one way or the other. But the important lesson is that change from a racist to a non-racist policy is possible at Bernard Misrahi's assumption that the racist nature of the state makes racist immigration control inevitable is only true as long as you have a racist state. But if you think everything a racist state does must be racist, there are only two possibilities open: either you despair and do nothing, or you try to change the racist nature of the state.

And the latter course means changing some of the things the state does. (Unless course you have a revolution and a new state. That is not the easiest thing to arrange at the moment.) In short, you have to assume something can be done and try to do it. That was the point of my report.

I know not everyone will agree with this strategy, but the demand for an open door has not been a very successful strategy yet. Anyone interested in the Canadian law can consult a Green Paper on immigration, published in four volumes ELLO obtainable through the High Commission for Canada. It does not have all the answers. But it sets one asking some new questions.

ANN DUMMETT

----- pull-quotes -----

"TROOPS NUIL HECKILEIRS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 8

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →