Letters: Conference BEGGARING THE REGIONS
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Comrades, 'Blame the bosses, not the English' was the title of the Socialist Organiser's Election Special article on Scotland and Wales. It is a pity that the article was not attributed to any individual. I hope it does not reflect agreed SCIV policy.
The writer gives the impression of belonging to that know-nothing school of politicians who think that if unemployment is as bad in Liverpool or Sunderland as Glasgow chen you shouldn't be con cerned with specifically Scott. ish or Welsh questions at all.
The article argues that since they get lots of investment subsidies, Scotland and Wale: are not discriminated against by Westminster. I tend to agree that there is no secret plot against Scotland and Wales in the corridors of Whitehall. But there is a consensus which restricts regional policies of all kinds to mitigating the least acceptable effects of the problems experience by the less favoured parts of an unplanned economy, including Liverpool and Sunderland as well as Glasgow.
It is this minimal role which Westminster's regional policACOL ANG ANI Wales especially that policies originating within and appliec o Scotland and to Wales might at least do more than Westminster has done.
The writer of the article suggests that the nationalists' desire to bring government closer to the people just ignores the existence of classes in society' . It is true that the Scottish National Party and the leadership of Plaid Cymru do this, but remember that the labour movement majority is, correctly in my view, committed to similar objectives and has had modest success in keeping this issue alive at least in Scotland.
The article concludes with a convoluted argument which is illogical in my opinion. It Callaghan didn't reply to questions on Ireland in his election meetings. But in Edinburgh on April 28th there was an answer. It didn't come from the platform, but from the meeting's stewards.
They set about a lone troops out heckler and threw him out of the hall, hitting and punching all the way despite being offered no resistance.
Protests at this thug behaviour of the Labour Party stewards was met with more violence. Some stewards seemed overjoyed at the NOTE: the by Comrade fact an edit should have this was production.
Organisation..
Delegate(s) /visitor... blames the Labour Government for playing into the ands of the SNP by messing bout on devolution - which is fair comment, although at the time of writing the SNP don't appear to be reaping any advantage. We are then told that Devolution is irrelevant to the needs of the working class'.
Now, I have argued the socialist case for devolution in an earlier Socialist Organiser at some length and I won't go over that complex argument again here, but I suggest that bald assertions such as that just quoted compound the follies of this Labour government and render hollow the subsequent claim to support a Scottish assembly just because the Scottish people voted narrowly in favour of one.
To sum up, 1 am in complete disagreement with most of the main points made in your anonymous lection Special coverage Scotland and Wales.
Comradely, Brynley Heaven Hull article referred to Heaven was not in orial statement. It been by-lined but omitted during ment supporters "paid agitators Callaghan, a veteran and very well paid agitator for 'Socialism Out' in the Labour Party, was furious. He demanded, after the meeting, that infiltrators' be cleared out of the party.
Already the events at the meeting are being used as a pretext for a witchunt gainst SCLV supporters ictive in 'troops out campaigning in Edinburgh Central CLP.
But the responsibility for the violence lies with the people who used violence and smears to try and stop socialists raising an issue Callaghan found objectionable. The protests should be against those who infiltrate olice state methods into the abour Party.
FEES: £1 per delegate or visitor (cheques payable to SCLV).
Further details available from 'Local Government Conference', c/o 5 Stamford Hill, London N16 We wish to submit/enclose a resolution: D We wish to submit/enclose a background paper Creche facilities required: YES/NO
----- pull-quotes -----
Les tribe pate which has contreciation in Solanding