Scotland: dangers of diversion and division
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-06-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
unemployment is that they verdict we must accept. But are unprofitable areas to in- we can still re-assert that an vest in: *"The only way round Edinburgh Assembly will BKINLEX Heaven, in nis letter in the May SO, complains about 'know-nothing politicians' who ignore 'specifically Scottish or Welsh questions' on the grounds that these areas get as much economic aid as any other region.
Unfortunately, the comrade has ripped this point in the SO Electior Special out of its context ir order to make his point. In fact the article argues, in agreement with comrade Heaven, that current regional policies are restricted to 'mitigating the least acceptable effects of the problems experienced by the less faunu nanto lavuurcu paris Ul me u planned economy' There is, however, complete disagreement between comrade Heaven's solution to the problem and that put forward in the Election Special article. The article stated, correctly in my view, that the reason why regions like Scotland and Wales suffer particularl from denression and IN THE last Socialist Organiser, Ann Dummett argued that we should be calling for non-racist immigration controls. Either a completely open door... or freedom of entry from the Commonwealth", , she thinks is impractical.
But how does Ms Dummett define practical? She says, "No change in immigration control can happen except through Parliament. MPs are the people who have got to initiate any effective change". Thus her idea of what is practical is what can catch the ear of parlia mentarians, and her idea of strategy is lowering your sights till they coincide with the whites of an MP's eyes.
We do not accept that. As revolutionary socialists, we see the working class as the force to initiate change, and our politics are determined by what will best moblise the working class to fight Its oppression and exploitation. The question Ann Dummett should ask herself is, would the call for non-racist immigration controls further the struggle to break workers from racism. (I was about to inter, but cer — ices UNFORTUNATELY Socialist Organiser has not given much coverage to the European Assembly elections. Indeed, SO has been in danger of reections: ignore them cise the majority in the Labour Party for focusing too much on elections rather than mass action. Now the firmest believers in the 'parliamentary road to socialism' have suddenly turned round and become anti-electoralists - and for no other reason than that it is an international election. Many Labour Party branches and activists are refusing to anything for the EEC poll.
The reasons given will not stand up. EEC or no BEC, economic and political affairs are inescapably international. Any chance, however limited, to extend political action beyond national limits should be welcomed.J We should work to elect Labour Euro-MPs - and then demand that those MPs speak out in the Assembly as represunis is to attack the protit system"
Comrade Heaven, on the other hand, believes that the answer lies, in Scotland and Wales at least, in 'bringing government closer to the people' , 1.e. regional policy should be left in the hands of regional assemblies — who are bound to make a better job of it than Westminster. He brushes aside the ohjection that this just ignores the existence of classes in society' by claiming that the majority of the labour movement back him up.
But in Wales an overwhelming majority of the working class rejected devoInon. 10 De sure, many people voted no for all sorts of backward reasons, one of them being fear of the Welsh language, but there was also the grain of a realisation that an Assembly in Cardiff would not substantially change their lives.
In Scotland a majority of the working class does support devolution. and that is a ly Ann Dummett has given up on the second of these. One can hardly have nonchauvinist immigration controls)The answer is provided -at least the key to it - by an observation Ms Dummett makes herself. She bemoans the fact that the issues of race and immigration have become confused. Now bemoan it as she may, she must take this confusion as a starting point.
Suppose Ann Dummett meets a worker who says, "I'm no racist, but you do need immigration controls". What does she say? We can only assume she says, "I'm glad you're no racist. I hope you'll support this campaign to keep people out of Britain for reasons other than race".
Precisely because the issues of race and immigration are confused, we ought to be prepared for the fact that support for immigration controls means racism, even if it is combined with the plea, "I'm no racist". Thus we would reply, "Why do you want immigration controls? Apart from anything else, there are more people leaving Britain than coming in". The response to this is g and We entatives of the common interests of workers throughout Europe, not as representatives of Britain. If even a tiny group of militant socialist MPs did that, they would be making better use of parliament as a forum for socialist agitation than could ever be possible in a national parliament.
If our Euro-MPs will not act as socialist internationalists, we should at least demand that they act as democrats and press for the EEC Assembly to have sovereignty over the EEC Commission and the Council of Ministers. The arguments against this in Labour's Euro-manifesto are disgusting in their pig-headed chauvinism.
*The basis of democratic control" , says the Manifesto "must continue to be vested firmly in the right of the European peoples to govern themselves, far as possible through their own national Parliaments" . But isn't international democratic control -to the extent that it can be won - obviously a higher form (and one more suited to the close international connections be more of a diversion than a rallying point, thus forewarning and forearming the working class against the internal divisions that will probably grow because of the referendum result.
In the short term the SNP has suffered a blow and Labour has assumed the tartan mantle, but unless the divisive tendencies in the move. ment are actively fought the nationalists will eventually reap the rewards.
As socialists we accept the majority decision of the Scottish working class, but we must not hide (as comrade Heaven does) behind illusions that majority has in tne powers and unctions ot a - Scottish Assembly. We must fight these illusions in the same way that we fight illusions in the Westminster Parliament. Re-shuffling responsibility tor Scottish regional policy will not help those on the dole. The only way forward is to attack the profit system.
Martin Barclay very likely to be, "Yes, but It's the whites who are leavIng..." At least at that point we can get down to talking about racism and forget the numbers game.
Or the reply might be: "That may be so, but there are still too many people". Then we can discuss the real origins and solutions to the problems he or she thought we cause or made worse by "too many people", How would Ann Dummett's approach be a better "strategy for enlightening this worker? Of course, as Ann Dummett's work focuses on the question of race, she might feel she had got somewhere; If it focused on the question of unemploy. ment she would realise that she had got nowhere.
Ann Dummett's Idea of strategy is a drawing-room one - both because it does not relate to the working class, and because it does not take as its point of departure the struggles or ideologIcal confusions of the working class. Its point of departure is the supposed reasonableness of MPs.
Andrew Hornung itminster of the modern economy) than the largely mythical sovereignty of national parliaments? Since the Manifesto does not propose to abolish the EEC Commission and Council of Ministers, why does it not of Peter Grimes -and raises some questions about police surveillance and interference in movement. "AT THE bottom of my bed there is a spare razor, razor blade, toothbrush, toothpaste, towel, flannel, and a change of underwear. It's got so bad that I have to sleep with a bag ready so that when they come in the morning i get into my clothes and go with them"
The people who 'come in the morning' are the Special Branch and the Anti Terrorist Squad. Peter Grimes, former British organiser for the Irish Republican Socialist Party (IRSP) until he left that organisation for reasons of health last rebruary, can't remember whether il is seven or eight times that he has been taken into police custody in the last 3½ years, to be held under the Prevention of Terrorism Act for periods of up to seven days. Arciltect of the FTA: Loy Jenkins, then Labour Home Secretary Two weeks ago he was released from Paddington Green station after his solicitor had applied for a writ of habeas corpus on the grounds that his mental health might be at risk. The police had been demanding information from him about the killing of Airey Neave. Grimes denies all knowledge of the affair; but by the time he was released se vers so frightened i obs server, prepared to write anything, confess to anything, name anybody, just so they would give me a period of peace" It had been his third detention in two months.
Despite seven or eight arrests, Grimes has only been charged once. At the end of 1977 he got three months under Section 11 of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (PTA) for 'withholding information' After talking at length to Peter Grimes about his experiences with the police and about his political activities and beliefs, it seems to me that not only has he been harassed to the brink of a nervous breakdown by police using the special provisions. of Roy Jenkins' 1974 PTA, but also the police have recase has many parallels to that of Kenneth Lennon, who was found dead in ditch in 1974 after being blackmailed by the police into being first an informer and then a provocateur. The difference is that Peter Grimes has repeatedly blown the whistle on the police.
A dark, slightly-built Mulingar (Co. Westmeath) man of 32, Grimes, who works as gardener, has lived Britain since he was 10 years old. During five years in the British Army in the '60s he saw service against guerillas in Aden and in Borneo, and in putting down the Maoist riots in Hong Kong in 1967. Moved into Northern Ireland with the first British soldiers when Jim Callaghan sent troops onto the streets in 1969, he was based for some weeks in Palace Barracks, Hollywood, Co. Down. After Aden and Borneo, he may have had less faith than many people then had in the peacekeeping mission of the British Army. He bought himself out of the Army in 1969 for £250.
He became politicised in the squatting movement org anised by Ron Bailey and others in the East End in the early '70s, and "received the Marxist classics (except Trotsky, whose work he hopes to catch up on) and by Mao and Guevara.
He is also a Catholic who believes in Jesus Christ, though he has not practised his religion for years. He had always felt himself to be Irish, keeping in touch with his hometown - and eventually he joined Clann na hEireann, the British offshoot of the Official Republican Movement. When in 1975 a section of the Officials formed the IRSP, he helped start a British support group, eventually holding the position of National Organiser in Britain.
Peter Grimes' political views now are a not too well integrated mixture of socialist republicanism, the sort of grass-roots community Past.
tics he learned in the End, and quasi-Maoist rationalisations for the Irish Republican practice of organising private armies. He respects the military role of the Provisionals but has 'very little respect' for Sinn Fein (the Provisionals in politics). A Provo Ireland would be a capitalist Ireland. He wants a 32 County workers' republic.
He believes armed struggle is a last resort, and it has come to that in Northern Ireland. He supported the Officials (and now the IRSP) because he thinks they are the only people who have tried to bring Protestant and Catholic communities in Northern Ireland together.
What effect on the communities' relations does the Provisional IRA (and the Irish National Liberation Army [INLA]) have? He does not see any direct relationship. It is a parallel phenomenon to the communal conflict, concerned essentially with the problem of the British presence.
The Provisionals are people's militia, unlike the police and Army who serve the bourgeoisie. There is a need for a people's militia. Division Northern land is the result of sectarian indoctrination by the British Government, «he FreemasOrder, and ons' ', dividing to rule. He believes that perhaps the creation of local action committees in the streets of the Protestant and Catholic ghettoes could lead to unity in Northern Ireland.
He says he is motivated in politics by hatred - of the treatment meted out by the capitalist system to his family and other such people. He speaks bitterly the beggars in Dublin streets, tells of the sight of a ten year old boy with no shoes pushing a heavy cart up a hill in Dublin, of houses without running water and electricity - amidst the 'real mineral wealth' of Ireland, exploited by Irish capitalists and 'the multi-nationals'.
He talks of his dealings with the police as if he has it all off pat. But the facts of the number of his arrests are a matter of record.
Grimes' political organisation, the IRSP, took off essentially from dissatisfaction with the Official Republican Movement's failure to provide the necessary physical protection for the Northern Ireland Catholics against the British Army and the Orange murder squads. The split in 1975 was quickly followed by a blood feud in which a number of people died. An organisation called the Irish Nat. ional Liberation Army (INLA) came into existence. Formal connection with the IRSP is denied, but the INLA is generally probably rightly understood to be to the IRSP what the Provisional IRA is to Provisional Sinn Fein.
It is the INLA that has claimed responsibility for killing Airey Neave.J It might seem then that Peter Grimes, given his views and associations, might well be involved in the Neave killing and is anyway DAVID Frost's Global Vill'fair game hunting Ne Not so. the IRSP ; Whatever exist, the !! ness of pol propagandi ence in th ment. If a exișts betw the INLA ( case at it IRSP is an itical orgar ctions in strictly wit advocate th ed socialist not illegal.
But are supporters cause of th ction as aux those who police clain with Grime to know w telligence' Not accordi experience ional IRA These have y or people tical 'form' connection in Britain. on why the such diffi And certa Neave wou great deal d have otherv selves to l with Grime ing political An army work of ti ering ope The progn
----- pull-quotes -----
the Irish community and the labour
political education of sorts". He was influenced by