Political-Economy- AN ECONOMIC POLICY FOR LABOUR'S LEFT 1. Half-way to socialism
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-06-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
In an article written for the London maga- the election - was gathering behind the Driver's and John Harrison's article zine Time Out before the general elect- 1974 Manifesto's ideas. Though not fully dealing with Labour's policies, plus a ion, CIARAN DRIVER and JOHN HARR- socialist, those policies would open up different view from COLIN FOSTER. ISON argued that a strong movement - great chances for socialist advance. John Harrison is the author of 'Marxlikely to come out on top if Labour won Here we reprint the part of Claran Ist Economics for Socialists' [Pluto].
By February of this year, registered unemployment had risen to 1,452,000, with an estimated further one million desiring work but ineligible for benefit (including many married women). And this despite four years of wage restraint under the Social Contract. (When Phase 1 of the Social Contract was agreed in July 75, the registered unemployed numbered only 791,000.) By 1976, the Economist could contidently state that 'British manufacturing industry has the lowest labour costs in the EEC'. For the low-paid, including most of Britain's nine million women workers, this meant conditions of real poverty (43.2% of full-time women workers earned less than £40 a week in "76).
Wage controls were supposedly introduced as an alternative to cuts in public spending, yet, as the New Statesman recently noted, total public expenditure for the fiscal year '77-78 was E7 billion less than Labour originally promised. Instead of the promised 13% growth in the four years after Heath there was no growth at all."
INROADS
Yet in their 1974 election manifestos, Labour promised a programme more radical than any since 1945. If successfully implemented, it would have made major inroads into private control over economic activity and achieved a significant redistribution of income and wealth. Indeed the committed itself to bring about a fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of power and wealth it favour of working people and their families.' These original proposals included the nationalisation of a significant proportion of manufacturing industry by the newly created National Enterprise Board. The NEB was to take a controlling interest in 20 to 25 of the 100 top manufacturing companies, accounting for half of the employees of those 100. In contrast to previous nationalisations, the companies taken over were to be profitable ones. Public investment would be pumped into these firms in order to stimulate technical innovation and productivity. Faced by such high-powered competition, the theory went, the remaining manufacturers would have to get into gear and invest.
Other major firms were to be subject to Planning Agreements - quotas for investment, employment and so on to be agreed between private firms and the government. Such firms would be required to meet certain government objectives (say, the creation of jobs on Merseyside) but the details of precisely how the objects were to be met would be left to the firms to decide.
The freedom of shareholders and management to control their companies operations was to be further restricted by compulsory worker participation. All major firms were to establish a Main Policy Board, half the places on which 'would be available for workers' representatives, elected through the recognised trade union machinery' (Labour's Programme for Britain 1976).
The now infamous Social Contract was originally offered as a further method of trade inion participation, this at the national level. In exchange for voluntary wage restraint (unlike the Tories, Labour traditionally avoid the statutory method, preferring to let the TUC discipline its members), the TUC would have a major say in determining social priorities and allocating public expenditure.
Such proposals didn't constitute socialism, but they were a commitment to reduce significantly the control of private firms over economic activity. As such it was an anti-capitalist programme, and violently opposed by the CBI.
Some redistributive measures were carried out in the The Housing Finance freeze instituted and pensions raised. But by the Autumn of 1974, as the world recession set in, and the mass working class : mobilisation which had brought Labour to power dissolved, this emphasis was reversed. Redistribution towards lower income groups gave way to redistribution away from them towards profits and investments. And the conception of state intervention in industry shifted from reducing the control of private firms to a meeker attempt to influence their decisions.
SHIFTS
These two strategy shifts are, of course, related. Once the project of curtailing the power of firms is abandoned, distributional politics must be geared to firms' needs if they are to be persuaded to invest. And in the present context of low profitability and stagnant sales that means a redistribution to profits and a push on the export front. As Healy put it: Firms will only expand and invest if they can see scope for making profits' This new emphasis on persuasion rather than control brought Labour's objectives into line with the Tories; both were now concerned to create an economic climate in firms which would significantly step up their level of investment. Tr differed only as to 1 the degree of state intervent required to create such IRDS EYE Birds Eye, Kirkby: -right of private fir climate. This remains the position today.
Having changed course, Labour effectively abandoned the original notion of planning agreements, used the NEB only to bail out and rationalise bankrupt companies and watered down the industrial democracy proposals. But despite this turnabout, despite the largest recorded cut in real wages in UK history and significantly reduced social service provision, UK industry has not been regenerated. Although profits have risen by almost 50% since the summer of *76, they are still less than half of the mid-'60s level. ibour's 1974 policy challenged the to shift investment as they wished. And investment has not risen in line with profits; manufacturing investment is running at only a third of the 1961 level.
As expected, Labour "79 manifesto is far less radical than its predecessor. The vagueness of its pledges to expand the NEB and institute back-up statutory powers' to secure planning agreements were rightly greeted as a Callaghan victory over the party's leftwing. The word 'compulsory' for instance was deliberately excluded from the discussion of planning agreements. And the 'Concordat' struck between the very unmilitant leaders of the TUC and the Government in February "strongly recommends' wage restraint, the prevention of unofficial strikes, industrial action only 'in the last resort' for public service workers, and restrictions on picketing.
ment to restrict government borrowing (ie additional cuts in state spending), and the total Callaghan package suggests an intensification of recent policies. The effects on jobs and living standards would be nothing like as severe as those resulting from a Tory victory, but they would nevertheless be serious if left unchallenged.
But will they be? If Labour is returned, the Callaghan strategy could come in for some heavy opposition -opposition which would obviously have far less influence in a Tory-dominated parliament. The broad commitments of the "74 Manifesto are still cherished by Benn and the Tribunites within the Parliamentary Labour Party, and in the party at large by the supporters of Tribune, Labour Activist, Socialist Organiser and the Militant, who together control a significant number of constituencies. The leaders of the TUC and every major union are similarly committed.
More importantly, in the face of predicted economic deterioration in the '80s, the implementation of further anti-working class measures will be difficult. As this winter's breakdown in incomes policy has shown, the TUC leadership cannot dam forever the mounting opposition of its members to the PLP's current policies.
The result, if Labour wins, could be a confrontation between that party's left and its current leadership. The ensuing erection of the "74 Manifesto's halfway house between a fully market economy and a centrally planned one wouldn't conjure away the problems of UK industry — only an economy based on social utility instead of profitability could manage that. But the emergence of a popularly-supported left alternative would open up immense opportunities to build a genuinely socialist edifice.
----- pull-quotes -----
SEVERE Add on Healy's commit-