2. Mass action or 'state socialism
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-06-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Chile 1973: soon the workers with pikes, hoping for a parliamentary road to socialism, were mowed down by the army's machine guns Ciaran Driver and John Harrison argue that Labour's though not fully socialist; they represented a 'halfway house between a fully market economy and a centrally planned one'.
Thus those policies could be the basis for a powerful movement for 'a popularlysupported left alternative' Ciaran Driver and John Harrison saw a Labour victory in the election as opening up big chances in that direction. But in the discussion over new policies following Labour's defeat, their article still stands as an appeal for organising the left behind 'the broad commitments of the '74 Manifesto' I would argue that a 'halfway house' between capitalism and a socialist state is impossible. The fact that the 1974 policies aimed at such a 'half-way house' made their failure inevitable. Our task now should not be to rally the left round the 1974 policies once again, but to build a really fighting left wing round a clearly revolutionary socialist programme.
Ciaran Driver and John Harrison, after describing Labour's 1974 policy as anticapitalist. write: By the Autumn of 74, as the world recession set in, and the mass working class mobilisation which had brought Labour to power dissolved, this emphasis was reversed' In fact strike activity did not decisively turn down until the summer of 1975, when much of the left was demoralised by defeat in the futile battle it had waged for the nationalist cause in the Common Market referendum and the Labour Government imposed the E6 limit. And tha ntiien 1100 nata unC was spontaneous process: it was actively engineered by the Labour government.
In 1974, as Driver and Harrison point out, the Labour government did repeal the Housing Finance Act, freeze rents and raise pensions. Those measures represented the concessions agreed by Britain's ruling circles in view of the tumultuous working class militancy of 1972-4; they were after all approved by a Parliament where Labour was in a minority. At the same time the government kept the Shrewsbury pickets in jail, retained the National Industrial Relations Court for some months, and continued the Tories' Phase 3 pay policy.
What of the policies that made some Tories scream about 'Marxism on the march"? Benn's Work Programme of the Department of Industry' (June 1974) and White Paper on The Regeneration of British Industry" (August 1974) proposed:
• Nationalisation of the aircraft and shipbuilding industries.
Planning agreements.
The National Enterprise Board.
• Workers* participation and come measure of compulsory diselosure of business information.
Disclosure of information was limited by the clause
Scan page 7
by KEITH BIRCH I'Gay Left' and Islington North CLP] 'except where disclosure could seriously prejudice the companies" commercial interests' . The workers' AN THIS SUMMER sees the
----- pull-quotes -----
1974 policies were 'an anti- capitalist programme'.