Econo Policy for Left
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-06-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
participation plans, put into practice in British Leyland, have proved to be just a means of co-opting trade union representatives into plans for speed-up and jobcutting.
The nationalisations with 'prompt and fair compensation' promised, of course - were more welcome than otherwise to the capitalists in the ailing aircraft and shipbuilding industries.
As for the rest, Benn's plans certainly promised more state control over industry. But in modern capitalism the state already has a very large influence on industry. The 'fully market economy' which Driver and Harrison speak of was already a thing of the part long before 1974.
The state organises the supply of labour power and the provision of transport and communications. It is the direct capitalist employer in many industries. It actively intervenes in the concentration, centralisation and restructuring of capital. It tries to manage and alleviate the crises of capitalism, providing vital safe markets for many industries. And it provides the legal framework for capitalist economic life.
STATE
Thus the modern state is a form of oppression specific to and inseparable from capitalism. Its leading personnel, its hierarchies and its structures all reflect that.
Capitalists still can and do differ among themselves about how far the state should extend its functions of economic regulation. Thus most bosses denounced Benn, while a few (like Don Ryder, chairman of Reed International) approved his plans. But the dispute was not about socialism.
At best, the 1974 policies confused socialism with state capitalism. (And not a very radical programme of state capitalism, at that: for the "planning agreements' were a right wing, less radical, alternative to nationalisation) They looked to the state (guided by well-meaning politicians) to secure progress towards socialism.
For that reason, the 1974 policies were not genuinely anti-capitalist, even if they had been pushed through. And for that reason, they were not pushed through, but became mostly mere fictions. For a strategy of achieving socialism through through, then more than ever a bold, well-organised revolutionary left wing is needed which will prepare to fight the capitalist backlash and go forward to the complete overthrow of the present system.
Socialists do have to fight for demands short of our complete programme. But those demands find their meaning in the developing mobilisation and consciousness of the working class, not in a perspective of gradually reforming capitalism through the existing state. Our agitation for limited demands must always be linked to propaganda for the more advanced demands which can become agitational to the extent that the struggle develops round the first limited The great workers" struggles of 1972-4 were focused on limited trade union demands, with the political horizon arching above them being that of Labour's 1974 policies. Thus, instead of workers seeing a way forward to overthrow the state which their struggles had resisted and replace it with a workers' republic, there was a division between industrial and political struggle.
The industrial struggles crippled the Tories, but then the political follow-up was left to Wilson and company in Parliament. And even if the government's intentions had been much better than in fact they were, they would have been impotent in the face of the power of capitalist interests in the economy and in the permanent state apparatus. Only through mass action can the labour movement counter that capitalist power; but the labour movement, apart from a small revolutionary wing, had no political programme of mass action.
MISERY That is the lesson of the cycle of struggle which went from the great battles of 1972-4 to the misery of Labour's wage-curbing, jobtenth anniversary of the Stonewall riot in New York which is often described as the birth of the Gay Liberation Movement when people fought back against police raids. It will be celebrated in many parts of the world with demonstrations, and in London by a Gay Pride Week at the end of June.
However, with the election of the most reactionary Tory government since the war, gay socialists may have little to celebrate. We need to assess the gains that have been made and to buila a basis on which these advances can be defended in the face of economic and moral reaction.
Gay men and women still do not have basic civil rights in many areas. The 1967 Act gave only limited legality to male homosexual acts. keeps the age of consent at and does not apply to Scotland and Northern Ireland. We still face harassment from the police, and courts have taken children away from lesbian mothers who are seen as 'unfit' to be parents. People have been sacked from their jobs for being gay, with as yet no success at industrial tribunals for unfair dismissal, while it is often difficult to get union backing to fight such victimisation.
Under the Labour government, the hope for some kind of limited reforms remained alive, though only with difficulty. The government sold out on the issue of extending the 1967 Act to Northern Ireland, in exchange for the tacit parliamentary support of moral bigots such as lan Paisley with his 'Save Ulster from Sodomy' campaign. Meanwhile the Labour leadership offered little opposition to the Bills aimed restricting women's rights to What can we expect from the Tories? Of course, worse - but it would be wrong to say that immediate disaster will befall us such as a repressive change in the law. What we will more likely experience is a slower; decemeal attack on our iberties and a strengthening of the morally reactionary climate that has been growing in past years with the general move to the right.
Attacks experienced by gay people at the hands of local police forces such as in Manchester under the authoritarian Anderton, and Brighton where gay clubs have been closed, may grow and spread with the demands for morality, law and order. Gays in London have suffered attacks from the Special Patrol Group in their spare moments from harassing the black communities and demonstrators. The limited funding that some gay self-help groups and law centres have had may disappear.
Our independence and rights as gays will be restricted in both the economic and civil liberties aspects while the strength of a morally reactionary ideology will grow.
What then are the tasks that face us as gay socialists in both the gay movement itself and as socialists? At the present time it is difficult to talk about a gay movement as a coherent force. There exist a number of disparate groups ranging from the Campaign for Homosexual Equality, the Gay Activists Alliance through to gay union caucuses and self-help groups such as Switchboards and Icebreakers; while many lesbians focus their activities in the Women's Movement.
It is important for gay socialists to be involved and help build these autonomous groupings, to take up specific issues affecting gay people which can win the support of a broad alliance of gays such as was done with the defence of Gay News after the Mary Whitehouse prosecution, while also making links with the socialist movement on these issues. The autonomous movement gives us an arena to put forward our ideas and activities to a wide audience of gay people which it would be difficult to reach otherwise.
Our work in the socialist movement and trade unions time to comes from our commitment as socialists and of course we need to participate in the broad struggle against the economic and social policies of the Tory government, against unemployment, social service cuts and so on. However, we must be aware of a danger which is already apparent in some socialist groups, of a return to a narrow, economist analysis and struggle in the period ahead, a sense that other aspects of our lives and forms of struggle can be jettisoned for the 'real' conflict. We need to defend the importance of those areas of struggle around sexual politics and the 'personal' which may get brushed aside in the rush to the point of production.
The fight for socialism has to be carried forward on a broad front and all aspects of our lives are at issue. Unity and growth in our struggles can only come about through a récognition of the specific forms of oppression that groups such as gays, women and black people face and by confronting these in the socialist movement itself.
A call to "join the party" as the way forward will have little response. We need to reiterate the importance of autonomous movements, for gay socialists to give one another support and work out perspectives and actions which will gain a wider involvement from the gay community. Only by this will more people be prepared and be able collectively to resist the threats posed by the policies of the Tory government and be drawn into and build the struggle for socialism.
The Stonewall Inn was a bar for homosexual men in Christopher Street, Greenwich VillWage, New York. Like many other small bars, it was regulEarly raided by police using alleged abuses of the liquor laws as an excuse for harassment. On Friday 27 June 1969 he bar was raided, but against all precedent the customers fought back. Police reinforcements were called and a three day riot ensued. Gay people took to the streets. That, symbolically at least, was the beginning of the modern gay movement in the USA. In Britin, the London Gay Liberation Front was founded in 1970 after two English students, both gay, had witnessed the commemorative Christopher Street Gay Pride March in June 1970.
----- pull-quotes -----
navs gay