Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Letter: Lets have less cynicism on the LCC…]

Socialist Organiser no. 11, September 1979 · scan pp. 2–3 · about 1,388 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Letter: Lets have less cynicism on the LCC A RANK and file conference is to be held in Manchester in November, sponsored by the Labour Coordinating Committee, the Institute for Workers' Control, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, and Independent Labour Publications. The Conference is also backed by the TGWU and NUPE, and will be open to all Labour Party members in constitu ency parties, trade union branches, and branches of the sponsoring organisations in the North West.

Socialist Organiser spoke to Michael Meacher MP. chairman of the LCC Launch Committee, about the aims of the Conference and the LCC's own first annual meeting, to be held at the same • • What are the the conference?

The LCC COLIN FOSTER really needs to develop some sense of proportion in his analysis of developments within the mainstream Labour Left. His article on the Labour Coordinating Committee (Trying to put the lid on' SO July 1979) accuses these comrades of all manner of bad faith, duplicity and general anti-democratic manoeuvring in the proposed draft constitution of the LCC. Irrespective of comrade Foster's specific criticisms, the fact which cannot be ignored is that the LCC is involved in a transition from being an ad hoc body ansWe and file conference as part of the regional conference we are pianning, aiming to bring together activists in the regions to decide on our political priorities and how to carry them out. As far as the LCC is concerned. there has been little discussion on the left's priorities. We've suggested our four main goals in Labour Activist 1 The ballot for the first Executive Committee of the Labour Coordinatin Committee will close on Sept.2nd.

Three Socialist Organiser supportwerable only to itself to being a campaign open to all people who support its basic aims, with an elected steering committee which has to produce an account of its activities to an Annual General Meeting of its entire membership. While criticisms can be made of particular proposals in the draft the overall thrust of the development of the LCC is away from being an ad hoc elite, and in the direction of a broad membership campaigr. with accountability of the national committee to the membership through the Annual General Meeting.

Dear comrades, Martin Barclay's letter on devolution deserves a reply.

He points out that capitalists avoid areas where they expect poorer profits and that Scotland often falls into this category. Devolution of any kind, he argues, should be opposed as a diversion from the profit system and a cause and 2, and a wider policy platform in LA 3. • • What do you say to criticism from LCC supporters who joined on the basis of the broad aims outlined in LA 1 & 2 — for democracy in the party, for accountability of leaders, and for the provision of a forum for discussion of left strategy - that the proposed constitution Peter Tebbutt, are standing. They say:

G commitment to develop | The first and basic the fight for democracy and accountability inside the Party by the launch committee must remain central.

Our ability to do this means How this can be presented as being a stab in the back, or 'putting the lid on democracy' is beyond the present writer and I suspect beyond the majority of people who support the LCC, The SCLY should be in the forefront of welcoming all moves in the direction of opening up dialogue and debate between sections of the Left, regardless of how partial and limited these developments might be in of 'internal division' in the labour movement.

The evidence points the other way Far from retarding working class unity throughout and beyond Britain, the pro-devolution Scottish labour movement has, if anything, been among the leaders of left wing struggle For example, in the develnarrows the base of LCC by makıng inembership conditional on support for the policies in LA 3, and pre-empts discussion of policy by the Annual Meeting? •• We wouldn't expect everyone to agree with all the items in LA 3. What was in the minds of the Launch Committee when we published that platform was that we ›cracy that the LCC itself must be fully democratic, with the AGM sovereign and no bans and proscriptions'.

For the "political campaign at grassroots" , the LCC must remain an open forum of the left inside the Party and a campaign alliance for rank and file Labour activists, and not become an undemocratic grouping run exclusively for just one view of the way cynıcısm their initial stages. - We should be clear that the LCC represents just such a development and our criticisms of specific features of its organisational procedures are secondary to our desire to take maximum advantage of whatever opportunities for comradely debate and united action have been created.

It is particularly ironic that Colin Foster's cynical article should have appeared alongside a piece by LCC member Stuart Holland MP which attempts to argue, in a very fraternal tone, why the Left should be supportoping momentum of the lorry drivers' strike or earlier in the gearing up of the anti-Tory struggle under Heath (UCS, etc.). There is no serious prospect of Scottish or English workers being played off against one another on the basis of national feeling. Rather the dangers of negative differences and divbelieved rhese were the policies most LCC supporters would broadly subscribe to.

If people find they have differences with points in the platform, we can discuss them. We don't want a Bible. On the other hand we've got to decide the parameters of the LCC.

It was not intended exclusive.

left to socialism. We have criticised parts of the proposed Constitution and Rules as going in the latter direction, ind have put forward amendments to it. To fulfill the important potential of the LCC, we will continue to argue for a democratic and fighting body, and for policies taken up by the papers Socialist Organiser and Workers Action. ing the alternative economic policies advocated by the LCC. This rather contradicted comrade Foster's invective about attempts to 'impose a "Bennite" faction leadership on a supposedly broad grassroots movement.' The impression left after reading Holland's article is that the LCC places a high premium on having its position properly understood by activists in the Party and the trade unions, including the supporters of the LCC.

While no doubt many SCLV supporters do not support the policies advoisions in the movement stem trom attitudes epitomised by Martin Barclay's letter, which appear to argue that the spread and of formal political power under capitalism is not an issue for the labour movement. I expect that all these problems will be solved after the revolution...

Surely one of the most important functions of LCC is to provide a forum for debating out strategy and tactics for socialism. Some comrades say that the way the constitution has been drawn up could prohibit a tull dis.

cussion of strategy because the Annual Meeting will not have powers to decide on policy! •O At the ICC annual meeting and the rank and file conference we want to discuss the issue of strategy. If people want to put alternatives, that's fine.

The Left needs to debate strategy for the next Labour Government and examine the strategy of the last Government and the left alternative, to see if it is adequate or changes need to be made with particular reference to the extra-parliamentary struggle. cated by the LCC we should recognise that there is much that is positive in the attitude of comrades like Stuart Holland and we should seek to build a constructive relationship between our two campaigns. We will be aided in doing this if it can be ensured that there is less cynicism in the pages of Socialist Organiser and a great deal more willingness to seek out ways of cooperating with other left wing currents within the labour movement.

Comradely, Don Flynn There is more to it than the economic decisions capitalists make when choosing to invest (some US corporations seem to have a positive bias in favour Scotland).

Finally, I still want to know why Martin Barclay advocates a Scottish Assembly to which he is opposed?

BRYNLEY HEAVEN

Scan page 3

Socialist Orgav ser 3 Racism

----- pull-quotes -----

ors, John Bloxam, Nik Barstow, and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 11

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →