Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The lions and the law THE BIGGEST THREAT SINCE TAFT VATE

Socialist Organiser no. 11, September 1979 · scan p. 4 · about 1,002 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Police tried to limit Grunwick pickets to six to 'stop intimidation'... but who was intimidating whom?

The most right wing of to give the minimal support large group of pickets". trade union leaders will not necessary to secure victory willingly surrender the at Grunwicks in 1977. But the Tories on the closed power on which their own the biggest capitulation is shop: "The closed shop need position is based, although contained in the February not be a rigid arrangement. they equally dislike mili- 1979 "Guidelines' accomp- Its scope can be as flexible anying the so-called 'Con- as the parties concerned wish This combination of atti- cordat' produced after the it to be and unions might TUC, echoing Tories, calls for ballots, not mass meetings, before strikes by PETE ROWLANDS (secretary, Hounslow Trades Council)

ONE OF THE key debates at the Trades Union Congress in Blackpool will be on the Tories' proposals to amend trade union law.

Their 'Consultative Docu ment' proposes to amend the law In three crucial areas: picketing, the closed shop, and secret ballots. The Torles clearly intend to Implement their proposals in statutes early in the next session of Parliament, consistent with their rapid moves In other areas, and this is why this issue is now the most important one facing the British trade union and labour movement. and blacking — l.e. the most common forms of solidarity action. Picketing was also undermined in 1974 by a House of Lords ruling that pickets have no right to stop vehicles. The Prebbles case (1975) established that there was no right to picket outside of Industrial disputes. Police rules limiting pickets to six were enforced in the recent Garners dispute.

The police have also used their powers under the Public Order Act 1936 to ban demonstrations in London and Leeds in 1978, and the recent spate of local authority bills (no doubt police-inspired) requiring seven days' notice for demonstrations are now likely to become law.

The Labour government generally did not seek to change the law to reverse the reactionary effect of judges' rulings. Indeed it appeared to actively condone the winter Injunctions against secondary blacking and picketing. Labour also passed the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 1977. This Act restricts sentences for conspiracy in trade union matters • (the charges used against the Shrewsbury pickets) but Introduces new penalties which can be Incurred in occupations (the Criminal Trespass_law). The first successful prosecutions under this law have now taken place. The Prevention of Terrorism Act 1974 provides, and has been used as, a means for the victimisation of trade union militants.

This combination, of course, is exactly what the Labour and trade union right wing want. They fear the potential strength of the rank and file. At the same time their position is based on the existence of large and effective trade unions. (At least, they must be deemed to be effective - otherwise they would not be large). They want the unions controlled from the top, but on a voluntary basis - by the leaders rather than the state.

PICKET tant action.

TAIN tudes has determined the trade union leaders' attitude to attacks on workers' rights In recent years.

In 1973 they capitulated disgracefully over the that legislation such as the Industrial Relations Act, threatening rank and file and bureaucracy alike, was more likely to arouse opposition than the use of the erlminal law, which enabled them to characterise the Shrewsbury pickets 88 criminal thugs rather than trade unionists defending their rights.

Shrewsbury was a bad defeat and gave the Torles heart.

The TUC's attitude was shown again in their failure winter suike ware.

This desperate attempt to return Labour to power by demonstrating 'responsible' trade unionism misfired, with the TUC General Councile totally compromising Itself before the declared Intention of the Tories to curb the unions' power.

Ballots

The Guidelines called for "ballots [not mass meetings] to be held where a strike is contemplated".

In strikes, there should be "arrangements... for the maintenance... of supplies and services essential to the health or safety of the community".

*Unions should in general, and save in exceptional circumstances, confine picketing to premises of the parties to the dispute or the premises of suppliers and customers of those parties". And the Guidelines agreed that pickets should be kept small. "The police may regard a large body of workers as obstructing entry to premises or as intimidation towards those who wish to enter. And trade unions need to be aware that it can sometimes be difficult to control a The TUC even gave way to bear this firmly in mind".

Despite the TUC Guidelines the proposed legislation represents a considerable gamble for the Torles. The more level-headed sections of the Tory party and of big business are concerned about it - even the militantly right-wing Engineering Employers' Federation has said that some of the proposed laws would do more harm than good.

Some Tories foresee a confrontation which they will win, others think the trade union movement is weakened by adverse publicity and therefore prone to compromise. But many also remember that the last Tory government was brought down by trade union action, and that voluntary codes under Labour are completely different from enforced statutes under the Tories, even if the content is similar.

What are the specifie proposals of the "Consultative Document'?

On the closed shop they propose to extend protectIon against dismissal for those refusing to join a union to those who object on grounds of deeply held per ready appiles for grounds of religious bellef) and to those already employed. It also wants an 'overwhelming majority' In favour of a closed shop and a statutory code of practice.

These proposals can be regarded largely as ideological gloss for the Tories middle class supporters rather than a major threat to trade union organisation. No closed shop agreement is instituted without overwhelming support, and most are 'post entry' anyway.

The Torles also propose

----- pull-quotes -----

Socialise Orgamiser 4 Tory anti-union laws

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 11

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →