Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Despite all this, the EOC's concern is not…]

Socialist Organiser no. 11, September 1979 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 971 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Repeal

Despite all this, the EOC's concern is not for workers unprotected by the Act but for big business, which it feels does not have sufficient powers to apply for exemption.

It argues for repeal on the basis that employers are using the Act in order to avoid employing women.

In order to investigate the possibilities of women doing shift work if the law were altered to give "equal opportunity" • the EOC commissioned a survey of 1700 women in a community with a high proportion of unskilled women factory take-home pay of those manufacturing industries was £25 to £32 per week, a figure on which the EOC did not comment.| The National Council for Civil Liberties, in its pamphiet "The Shift Work Swindle"*, accurately describes this survey, and the use the EOC makes of it, as "a truly astounding blend of distortion, understatement, vagueness and blinkered prejudice which *973 Conlerence of th discrimination law. can only suggest that the EOC was strongly predisposed to make the findings it did, whatever the evidence"

The survey first examines women's approval or disapproval of shift working, and their attitude to a change in the law. It finds that these are related to age: the older a woman is, the more likely she is to disapprove of working shifts and of a change in the law. It is then surprised to find that only 11% (predominantly younger women) express even qualified willingness to work shifts.

Then the reasons for not wanting to work shifts are examined: Most women's reasons for not working shifts were expressed in a personal context...The cluded a need for management of domestic routine; possible help with domestic organisation; a need to rearrange social life; not seeing enough of husband and children; and the need for additional child care"

The EOC's attitude is summed up by their doctor who suggests that "good housing, small families and happy marriage seem to be conditions for successful night shiftworking"

The EOC seems blind to the main factor forcing women into shift work: the need to earn, and the fact that those with young children can only go out to work when the children's father, or some relative or friend, is home from work and can take care of them.

In the case of both parents working shifts, the EOC sees the main obstacle as the husbands' alleged insistence -on a regular domestic routine! Adequate childcare, the provision of public transport, the sharing of housework and domestic responsibilities, and the care of other dependants are at most afterthoughts for them in their attempt to show that many women are prevented from doing shiftwork only by protective legislation. It adds that repeal would provide equality of employment to women "who do not have significant domestic responsibilities"

Health

By virtual sleight of hand, the EOC 'proves' that women suffer no more than men from shift work (there is no evidence against this as there has been no comparative research). They take evidence only from a state-sponsored research doctor who conveniently found no long term harm to health from shift work, and no immediate adverse effects on safety, in contradiction to practically every independent survey on the issue.

The NCCL, in a report "Women Factory Workers" (1975), found clear evidence of the danger and disruptiveness of shift work. It is done exclusively because of need. All the women said they would prefer day work if the wages were the same.

The EOC considers problem of job | security, and in this case is prepared to concede that women may need protection trom conditions of employment which are impossible to combine with their families! needs: a recent judgement by Lord Denning in an appeal eroded what rights the law provides women with in this case by pointing out that the woman has a free choice -to work the hours demanded by her employer, or to leave her job.

Halt

But at a time when, in the words of the EOC 1978 Annual Report, "there is strong evidence... that progress towards equality in more measurable respects, in terms of earnings, has almost certainly come to a halt" , the EOC has decided to pursue an illusion of equality by levelling down legislation which has been of some limited value in protecting a vulnerable section of the workforce.

The employers consider only their profits, and the EOC endorses their judgement without question. Nowhere does it seriously suggest that protection should be extended to men, and nowhere does it suggest that adequate childcare facilities, and relief from the burden of domestic responsibilities, should be a precondition for women working unsocial hours.

The NCCL in their reply to the EOC call for more democratic procedures for deciding on shift work and on the areas in which exemption to protective legislation is justified; for better facilities for night and shift workers; better maternity and paternity leave, with either partner entitled to work day shift only until the child reaches school age; and better protection for men in terms, of safe lifting, lead processing. radiation, and meal breaks,

Choose

The EOC echoes the bosses' organisation in assuming that all workers who work shifts do so willingly: workers know better, and it is no step forward to put women under the same pressures in the guise of equality. We must demand free 24 hour nurseries if women are to engage in shift work, and for the extension of maternity and paternity rights so that either parent can choose to be more involved in his or her children's upbringing.

MANDY WILLIAMS * The Shift Work Swindle by Jean Coussins. 45p from NCCL, 186 King's Cross Rd., London WCIX 9DE.

Scan page 11

Socialist-Orgavoider! Laborar

----- pull-quotes -----

workers, some of whom worked shifts, of aver in

problems foreseen in- Tose fighting for an antı-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 11

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →