London Labour ducks the
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
By Cllr.
'LABOUR councils are faced with a situation similar to that of thé women who were sentenced to the Canterbury ducking stool' Arthur Latham told a special conference of the London Labour Party on cuts (22nd September). 'If they survived the ducking stool they were proved to be witches; if they drowned they were innocent' • Unfortunately, the Conference offered no way out of the water. the SECt prepare by GuRU accepted that the Tories will last their full term, and offered only proposals for a publicity for pullie se vices dure need lifetime of the present government'. . The Statement came down in favour of drowning -cuts in public services were unacceptable, and rate increases were 'the biggest cut 01 all' but 'Labour Councils should not shirk significant rate increases to protect essential services.' The confusion of the Executive's statement could not be resolved at the Conference as no amendments or resolutions were aliowed, neither could delegates vote on the separate parts of the 4-page document. A move by Streatham CLP to refer the statement back and to take an emergency resolution from Greenwich CLP was lost on a card vote by 786-417. Of the 51 delegates who took the rostrum, few faced up to the dilemma which will confront Labour councillors at next month's rate-making when the only legal action open to them will be either huge cuts or massive rate increases — or, worse still, a combination of both. For exEast Region TUC, talked of buying time' , and of the importance of Labour councils explaining to people the effect of Tory policies.
Among those delegates who did face up to the issues three different positions emerged.
Ashley Bramall, leader of one 'of the largest Labour-controlled authorities, recognised the 'desperate dílemma' that the Inner London Education Authority, and other Labour authorities, are in. But, he said, if you refused to put rates up or to make cuts, the money will merely run out half way through the year, employees won't be paid and the trade unions won't stand for it. He claimed that if ILEA made cutbacks, Labour could defend education against the Tories' desire to change the whole education system. If Labour authorities made cuts themselves, at least they could determine the priorities, he said.
Lambeth Council leader Ted Knight, speaking later, used same arguments Bramall for refusing to follow the example of Poplar in 1921. The Town Hall unions won't stand for empty wage packets, he told the Conference. His answer was rate increases rather than cuts - having resbonded to pressure from the Lambeth Labour Parties to go back on the cuts he had announced — and he is now in the position of leading a council which refuses to make any spending cuts.
A number of delegates rejected both options put forward by Knight and Bramall, and spoke against rate rises as an alternative to cuts in services. The point was put most forcefully by Robert Lee, a delegate from Hammersmith North. Both cuts and rate rises were ways to make the working class pay for the crisis, he explained. If Labour is to regain office we must show that we have a clear socialist alternative to the Tories' trap.
Councillors should have confidence in the wider labour movement, he said. If Commissioners were put in as a result of a refusal by a Labour Council to make cuts or raise the rates, then mass trade union action could be mobilised to ensure non-implementation of Tory cuts.
The delegation from the TGWU Region No.1 urged that the labour movement should not repeat the mistakes made when Clay Cross was isolated and stood alone. The GIRC must lead a campaign which unites the Labour Councils and public sector unions in London.
By the end of the day, the political argument had slightly Begure so coatrone the cor had ion over the crisis facing De u v cia be cumas Labour authorities. But the formal conclusions of the Conference had been determined before it started and, while the debate will no doubt continue, by adopting the GLRC Executive's statement, the London Labour Party is now formally committeed to a policy of drowning in the floods of rate increases in order to prove itself innocent of the witchcraft of public expenditure cuts.
Scan page 6
organıse the left!
the Labour Party as a gen- they will not do so with Continued Continued from front page the ruling class of right wing control of the political wing of the labour movement was shown more clearly than for a generation.
The ruling class agents inside the Labour Party will fight tooth and nail to preserve it in a condition to play the same sort of role for the ruling class in the future. The signs of serious trade union opposition to the Tory government probably conthe Labour Party as a genuinely socialist party seeking to overthrow capitalism on the basis of the class struggle of the working class, and build up a mass membership around such policies.
Or there will be a serious prospect that the rignt wing will be able to go on the offensive and purge the left with which it can no longer live in comfort. If in the next period the working class were to suffer a big defeat, the right could become strong enough to turn the party into something more they will fight.
The Right has positions of great reserve strength and support within bourgeois society. The have backing from the bourgeois press. They could count on support Irom passıve Laoour voters lI they could organise them -and there are powerful forces in British capitalist society which would be eager to help them organise. They have powertu support also within the bureaucracy of the trade unions. The left must organise. For Bernard Dix and Michael Meacher about the Labour Coordinating Committee and SCLV A LOT of people have heard about the Labour Coordinating Committee, but not many have a precise idea of what exactly it is. Even to its leaders its political physiognomy is still in the gestation stage. 'It's early days yet, we are just emerging. All that's visible is the top of the head we don't even know whether we are a boy or a girl yet' , says LCC launch committee member Bernard Dix. whatevet iths, must se In c, a lot of people in the labour movement to be just what they have been looking for. Almost 50 CLPs have affiliated and applications are coming in at the rate of one per week. There are 500 inangry' (Economist) Bernard Dix (Assistant Gen. Sec. of NUPE) to compare the positions and prospects of the LCC and SCLV/SO, to seek areas of collaboration between the two campaigns ... and to interview them for How does the LCC differ from Tribune? It does not, politically. It considers the ¡allure of the ribunites to organise a grass roots left as its major weakness. The LCC Is not seeking a parliamentarv intuence but to coordinate the left in the constituencies' , i.e. it is not in comcome up with a formula at the last minute. Already Callaghan is trying to ofiset the ettect of the changes by making the trade union inquiry into the Party the major decision. He could well introduce a third option to win over the smaller unions, given the whole thing hinges on them.' Victory would open up the possibility for the Labour Party to become a real mass membership organisation.
If we won what then? On gested that un colored up suck struggle which ively beat the r could be faced yeal or so by a right wine ons ... AND I SAY WITH
----- pull-quotes -----
Mike Davis & John O'Mahony talked tr