[DEMOCRATIC socialism' says Tony Benn is very much…]
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
DEMOCRATIC socialism' says Tony Benn is very much a home grown British product which has been slowly fashioned over the centuries. Its roots are deep in our history and have been nourished by the Bible, the teachings of Christ, the Peasants' Revolts, the Levellers, Tom Paine, the Chartists, Robert Owen, the Webbs and Bernard Shaw who were Fabians, and occasionally by Marxists, Liberals and radicals who have all contributed their analysis to our study of society?
So varied are there sources that there can be no real doctrine of democratic socialism, as Benn calls his cause, beyond the desire to replace the arbitrariness and injustice of tyranny and privilege by the rule of reason and the cooperation of equals..
The appeai of this democratic socialism is above all ethical rather than political. It is strongest when it is attacking power and patronage, and weakest when it is outlining a strategy for defeating these evils.
Take one of the central themes of these 'Arguments for Socialism': the attack on the enormous powers in the hands of the Prime Minister. 'Harold Wilson' he points out 'appointed or reshuffled 100 Cabinet ministers and 403 ministers of state and junior ministers, created 243 peers, appointed 24 chairmen of nationalised industries controlling twenty per cent of the nation's gross production and 16 chairmen of Royal Commissions to administer various policies or make recommendations for future policy, controlled all top appointments within the Civi Service and. of course. the Honoars List. For not one c! jese appoins. ments is a P-=e constitutio e public or party. The Premiership in Britain today is, in effect, an elected monarchy. No medieval monarch in the whole of British history ever had such power as every modern British Prime Minister has in his or her hands. Nor does any American Presidens have power approaching this. Con. gress would not permit it. To remedy this, Bear proposes an end to the House of Lords - though it appears that he is not against the monarchy! - and an enlargement of the power of parliament to the detriment of the power of the Prime Minister.
Bu: at no poiht is the in= of parliament itself is sure sated that it is basic and the best. A commitment to 'democratic change through parliament' is, tor benn, the sine qua non of Labour Party membership. Yet because his view of the necessity for parliamentary democracy is always argued against those who want a less democratic system (like corporatism), his tone appears radical.
In fact, however, Benn's inordinate faith in parliament and its processes is wildly unrealistic.
For instance, he claims that 'Parliamentary democracy means that all British governments, ministers, and the civil servants under their control, can only act within the laws of Britain and are accountable to parliament for everything they do, and hence [sic] parliament is accountable to the electors as a whole.' Or again, 'Parliamentary deтостасу ... entrenches the rights of the people to elect and dismiss members of parliament, lit also secures the continuing accountability of members of parliament to the electorate, obliging members of parliament to listen to the expression of the British people's views at all times, between, as well as during. general elections, and thus offers a continuing possibility of peaceful change through parliament to meet the people i 's needs.' As Tommy Cooper would sar: Just like that!
Not only does this contradict the experience of millions of people every day, but this description contradicts Benn's own statements about pairon"ge, about the impotence even of ministers, about the huge concertrations of power that
Scan page 7
ays: we're ng Brighton, of us sugSS the left a victory by rious class puld decisht then we n the next determined ight which could rout the left and perhaps even transform the party into a tight and intolerant continental-style social democratic party. The contradiction we saw in 1974-9, of a left wing party and a right wing government, was only ossible because the party lad no wav to control the Mrs or the party leader. Democracy would end such possibilities. Either the left or the right would have to FORM... take full control.
They agreed that the left must organise. Michael Meacher thought Callaghan would try every trick in the book to reverse or nullify the effect of the proposed changes if they go through. We might even see Callaghan making the sort of 'Fight Fight, and Fight again' speech Gaitskell made when the unilateral nuclear disarmament motion won at vickuy SCARBOROUGH sepat.28.54. Scarborough in 1960.
Bernard Dix said that the Labour Party was unique in its relationship to the unions. And so long as there was an open valve between Labour Party and trade union membership this limit or exclude the possibility of the Labour Party being transformed into a continental style social democracy. Yet even today, and ever since the mid-1920s, the CP is excluded, though CP members are in the unions and often even pay the political levy to the And the unions were not exactly pillars of democracy, were they?
Both Meacher and Dix thought that democratisation of the trade unions was an inseparable part of the work of democratising the Labour Party. Bernard Dix cited the example of his own union: 'In NUPE-ten years ago we had a king but not even a crown Row the condiet an ensures that the powers of our executive are evenly spread' It would not be very useful to push for a detailed programme of democratie demands for all unions. The first the LCC was concentrating on four main campaign areas: Labour democracy; control over the press and the media; full employment and the problem of deindustrialisation; and Europe. We explained that though the SCLV had cambalgned on questions lke reland and organised the rent and rates conference, which we saw as a stage in the fight against the cuts, our approach was more "total', based on the politics of the SCLV Platform. The left had to be organised: a certain minimum range of class struggle politics were necessary for that.
Bernard Dix then explained that the LCC was in some ways in the gestation stage. And Michael Meacher mentioned the unfortunate failure of the LCC to have a policy on Ireland. The LCC will be discussing it.
The LCC is, as we said at the beginning, still working out where it stands on a number of questions. That is, the LCC as an organisation is. It is recognisably a Petitical part of the Tribune DAVE LUNZ of Moss Side CLP describes the background to their call to disband the SPG MOSS SIDE police station stands alone on the edge of a to seven days' detention fore someone has to brought before a court. In Manchester the notorious Chief Constable James Anderton is keen to put the Greater Manchester Police at the top of the league of most hated forces
----- pull-quotes -----
IUT FEF lIS PLAT