Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[honS are amentary influence eements. n Labour eform.)…]

Socialist Organiser no. 12, October 1979 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,724 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

honS are amentary influence eements. n Labour eform.) ind-water with conSo where NYE MIKARDO He hopefully suggests that 'a degree of intelligent and democratic planning could supercede the concept of market forces' • Yes, it could - but only after the market system, capitalism, had been scrapped and with it the class that profits from capitalism. That aim can be achieved - by a vast, concentrated organisation of the power of the working class in struggle against the capitalists. That is hardly the same as a degree of intelligent and democratic planning'.

Like his vision of the trade union representative sitting alongside the investment manager, Benn's ideological world is a planet without struggle, one where agreement and collaboration are the result of intelligence and where the winds of force refuse to blow.

This is the central error in Benn's thinking: he does not deal with real social forces. He talks of the labour movement without mentioning its domination by those committed to the maintenance of capitalism (because consciously or not he shares their concern); he talks of the trade unions without mentioning the trade union bureaucracy (because, again, he shares their basic outlook).

Why is it that the capitalist class and its press see benn as bogeyman?

Tony Benn has come forward as the champion of industria. democracy, workers' cooperatives, the UCS work-in, Labour Party democracy and open government. In most of these areas his ideas have been wrong. But so unresponsive are Labour MPs usually (contrary to Benn's own picture of them) to grass roots movements which demand that the workers have a voice, that Benn's stance has been a factor in stimulating the development of a left wing within the unions and, even more, within the Labour Party.

Such a left-wing threatens the capitalisis and their agents in the Labour movement far more than Benn's ideas themselves. So long as workers ally behind Benn's banner for • fight, he will remain Public Enemy No. 1 for the capitalists and for Callaghan.

DRIBERG /CROS

Mike Davis interviews Vladimir Derer of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy • What are the prospecte for winning mandatory reselection of MPs at Party conference?

• It all depends on how the vote is going to be arranged.

It is not at all certain that there will be a straightforward vote on mandatory re-selection The NEC recommended that the vote should be on the same alternatives as in 1978. The Conference Arrangements Committee ruled this out of order. But the NEC would still be free to put a motion of confidence in the existing position: this is the Mikardo formula, which extends the principle of accountability only to a few MPs. Most MPs are likely to be re-adopted, because CLPs wouldn't want to go the oh e-selection ult it in e automatic, we'd see maybe u re-selections, instead ot the we had in the last parliament - but that's still only a sixth of the PLP. It's a totally inadequate method of accountability.

If the NEC do put a motion to reaffirm thelpresent position and it's upheld before a vote on the re-selection composite motions, then they won't even be put to the vote. However, if the NEC position is defeated step in NUPE was to confine appointments of officials to NUPE members. The second stage could be to move to the election of officials....

He went on to say that he saw himself as a revolutionary socialist. Then he rejected the idea that a socialist transofrmation of society through parliament was possible?

That sort of question wasn't relevant or useful at present, he said. It was a matter of a succession of 'revolutionary moments'. Here and now the immediate breakthrough would be on democratising the Labour Party. We agreed. But what would quality in society as a first qualitative breakthrough? I clear answer to that one somehow didn't emerge in the conversation, unless we missed it.

Meacher explained that and the mandatory re-selection composites also fail, it would be even worse than at present. The voting procedure is of crucial importance.

• How strong is the union support? -L The AUEW vote will be decisive. It is unlikely Terry Duffy (AUEW President) will do a Scanlon and cast his votes against the delegation. He's more likely to do a Carron (the tyrannical 1950g and '60g AUEW chief) on the strength of his EC backing him. The power of the President has never been effectively curtailed. Carron defied his delegation's wishes with impunity and the AUEW constitution was never enforced, therefore Dutty would have a precedent.

The most immediate danger though is the denial of the right to vote. If we want mandatory re-selection we must be entitled to vote on it democratically. We must put pressure on the NEC not to put a motion, or if they do, that it be taken aiter the composites. That is the correct procedure.

What would be the implications of achieving proper accountability of MPs?

• The implications would e considerable, thou sh not felt immediately. The ri nk and file will gain effecti re influence on policies. It would The answer to two questions will determine the future of the LCC. Whether it can in fact organise the broad left which certainly exists in the labour movement. And whether it can maintain a sufficientiy democratic structure to allow a proper democratic thrashing out of the political answers needed to solve the problems of the labour movement. We will have a clearer answer to *!: second question after the November LCC conference. Supporters of Socialist Organiser will be participating in that conference.

SCLV/SO has proposed to the LCC that we explore the Paunching of soles on me.

ings, to be organised jointly, against the cuts.

RA transform the Labour farty from a talking shop in which resolutions are discussed, passed and then ignored. The parliamentarians will be in a very difficult position if they defy party policy because they would be accountable to their CLP members.

For the left the possibilities are obvious. Far left critics will no longer be able to say the Labour Party is merely a smokescreen for bourgeois policies. It should encourage socialists outside the Labour Party to join instead of just dismissing it as a charade.

• If we lose, obviously the struggle will continue to democratise the party. But how do you think Callaghan and the parliamentary leadership will react if accountability wins the • If precedent is anything to go by, their threats to reverse such a change will not materialise. Some of the most right wing will leave like Prentice did. The very fact that Shirley Williams declared she would not serve in the Labour Party if these democratic changes went through reflects the opinion of many in the PLP - but the majority will conform. Party policy will also be different because it won't be decided by a parliamentary caucus. And it's likely that Callaghan will retire once the status quo is defeated. huge council estate. Its windows are made of a special reflective glass, giving it a sinister, eyeless appearance; obviously the people of Moss Side are not meant to know what goes on in there.

But the people do know, and if they can't see through the windows, they can certainly Bee through the cosy myth of the friendly neighbourhood bobby.

Random arrests, beatings and trumped up charges are a way of life for a lot of people in this community. Only a couple of weeks ago the local Tactical Aid Group [TAG] - Manchester's own Special Patrol Group - went on one of their periodic rampages, attacking 300 young blacks as they returned from a local fairground.

In the light of this, the resolution from Moss Side CLP to this year's Labour Conference has a clear local relevance. It's a strong resolution condemning the anti-working class nature of the police, and was passed while the evente al Southall were stil fresh ir everyone's minds.

We call for the immediate disbandment of the SPG, the TAG, and other similar units, and the Special Branch. We demand an end to police harassment of black communities. We clearly spell out the real role oi the police - to suppress any and all opposition to the state that employs them:

The police today have more power than ever before. The new National Police Computer can store information on forty million people. The Public Order Act can be used against a demonstration, march picket which the police decide is not wanted. The Police Immigration Unit is used for surveillance and extra harassment of blacks, while the Prevention of Terrorism Act has been used against Irish and left wing activists, allowing up in the country. He sees his patch as a guinea pig for what may become standard treatment.

Last year terrified people in Collyhurst, near the city centre, were woken in the middle of the night by gunshots, when the TAG took over a block of flats for a special unannounced manoeuvre designed as a test of the force's capacity to fight 'terrorists' At the GMC when we voted on conference resolutions, we spelled out exactly what the real purpose of the police force is and catalogued a long list of examples [Grunwicks, Garners, Southall etc].

But supporters of the Militant grouping were not convinced. They argued that the police were only 'workers in uniform' who should be approached with appeals for socialist solidarity. The movers of the resolution, supporters of Workers' Action, replied that the police are far from being just misguided. The coppers who attacked and arrested one of our GMC members at Southall knew perfectly well what they were doing.

The meeting gave its judg. ment, the right wing voting against our resolution and for the Militant resolution which called for the nationalisation of the 200 top monopolies. It's high time that the labour movement took a position on the police. Already we are under attack. But that is nothing to what is likely to come, as workers take to the streets in increasing numbers to defend what's left of the welfare state and to keep the Tories' hands off our trade An understanding of the real role of the police in the class struggle will help prepare the working • class for the real

Scan page 8

Socialist Organiser 88:9

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 12

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →