Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Did it ever did it eve go right? go right?

Socialist Organiser no. 12, October 1979 · scan p. 10 · about 1,698 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

proposed is to retreat 'time for doctrine' it would alisation and industrial de- benev

an island economy, have been all right.

UP NO!

Tia FOOD iR WAGEST February 1979 — Leyland workers walk out in the "winter of . reviews "What Went Wrong?" edited by Ken Coal es, published by Spokesman for the Institute for Workers' Control.

"WHAT Went Wrong?" is an attempt by the mainstream Tribunite left to assess the failures of the Labour Government and work out a strategy to prevent those failures in the future. Richard Clements wrote in Tribune that it gives us 'the socialist answers for the future from our experience of the immediate past" Terms Unfortunately, even in its own terms, the book is disappointing for two prime reasons. It attempts no self-criticism. There is nothing on the failure of the Tribunite left itself to challenge the leadership which they so indict in this book while it was in power. Tony Benn in particular is praised in several essays, with no comment on the fact that he not only remained silent on the anti-working class policies of the Government, he also participated in the Government that carried them out.

Worse, the book has nothing at all to say of direct relevance to now. Not a single writer in this collection even mentions how the labour movement should combat the Tory government now it is in power. All the policies outlined relate to what a future Labour government could do (when?). The authors also say nothing about how we make sure the future Labour government does carry out those policies, or how we deal with the present Labour leadership which obviously will not carry out the policies the authors recommend.

Both these failures of the book arise from the overall political conceptions of the writers.

"What Went Wrong?" is a series of articles covering a wide range of issues, from Labour's record on economic policy and industrial policy (with particular reference to, industrial democracy) and the relationship between government and Whitehall, to internal Labour Party affairs.

The main criticisms of the Government centre on economic policy. Despite promising in 1974 'a fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of wealth and power in favour of working people and their families" the Government did the opposite. Useful statistics are given.

Entry The authors argue this happened because the government did not heed Tribunite advice to reflate the economy, impose import controls, etc. As Michael Barratt Brown puts it:

"If Harold Wilson had not joined with the Establish.

ment to argue for Britain's entry into the EEC... Britain could have taken independent measures to impose import controls, refuse loans, and embark on the first steps of a democrati:

cally planned economy with socialism as its objective"

(pp.42-44).

Here all the problems are put down to foreigners in the International Monetary Fund and the EEC. and the solution into --. :11 with measures like import controls which only threaten workers' jobs in other countries. But why, according to Barratt Brown and his coauthors, did the Labour Government knuckle under to the IMF and the BEC? They cite several reasons.

• The undemocratic nature of the Civil Service, which has close links with industry, in general prevents, radıcal legislation from being implemented.

• Further, the House of Lords can block legislation.

• The Parliamentary Labour Party and the Cabinet are subject to no control by the Party as a whole. Consequently they can ignore Party PAKE SHAT SOCiAL CONTRACT discontent" over Labour's policies. policy:

Why did the Government choose to ignore Party policy and go along with what the Civil Service wanted? The answer given is that they accept the prevalling ideology in society (i.e. bourgeois liberalism). As Ken Coates puts it:

'The Callaghan administration was not mad, nor deliberately wicked... but it was composed of people who, in the main, had no time for doctrine" (p.14).

And Coates bemoans the demise of those old social-democrats who honestly believed in fighting for social justice ana full employ• ment. The basic message is that today's social democrats don't even live up to

'time for doctrine' it

would have been all right.

As the authors themselves show, the Callaghan government did not merely fail in an attempt to be good old-style social democrats. It deliberately acted in defence of Capital. It deliberately increased unemployment, deliberately broke strikes, deliberately and savagely attacked the working class — not only in Britain, but specially in Ireland. It was, quite clearly, a capitalist government.

Stuart Holland calls it 'left-wing capitalism, an outdated disorder', but draws no political conclusions from this other than 'good advice' for the future. The obvious conclusion, that it was necSMASH THE essary to fight that government tooth and nail, is not drawn.

The authors fail to see the relation between socialists and the Callaghan leadership as a relation of struggle between opposing and irreconcilable class loyalties. It is all a matter of a 'doctrinal' 'retreat from Keynesianism' and bowing down before monetarist policies. The Wilson/Callaghan government should have stuck to old-fashioned Keynesian economics and thus not sold out to the IMF, the EEC and all the lesser devils. Their anti-working class policies were merely an unfortunate by-product of this lack of 'time for doctrine' alisation and industrial democracy are considered in - wit mocracy are considered in abstraction from the class struggle.

For the Tribunites represented here, nationalisation is not a means by which in struggle the working class can defeat the bosses and lay the basis for control over production. Nationalisation is a way in which Governments (including 'left-wing capitalist' Governments) can introduce a little more social justice. Or, alternatively, they can do this by securing shares in the top companies and negotiating planning agreements. Nationalisation is reduced to being a means of helping capitalists plan their economy better and avoid crisis. Such a conceptCARS benevolent gift from above - with nationalisation as an optional extra.

Coates even quotes approvingly from proposals calling for 'parity representation" for trade unions on boards of directors, both of existing nationalised industries and of private companies. Given that there would always be at least one sell-out merchant on the trade union side, this would leave actual control still in the hands of the capitalists. The race for profits would continue, but with workers drawn into aiding the management of a capitalist The concentration on legislation through Parliament, to the extent of ignoring altogether struggles beyond the gates of Westminster and in particular struggles now against the Tories), is also reflected in the authors' stress on the problems of government. Things are made difficult even for radical governments because of the Civil Service and the House of Lords, they say, without seriously considering how such radical governments are to be obtained, or how the working class should be mobilised to counter the capitalist class power of which the bureaucratic power of the Civil Service is only one aspect.

Of course, there is no doubt that the Civil Service and the House of Lords are undemocratic and that we must campaign for the abolition of the House of Lords and reforms in the Civil Serv. ice. But behind the Civi Service stands the army, the police, the judiciary... the entire state machinery is capitalist through and through, and the enemy of the working class. The conclusion we ong", he was out to bear down draw is that the state must be overthrown and replaced by a state under the control of the working class: a workers' state, a workers' democracy.

Yet for these writers the State is fundamentally neutral. It is biased but the "Capital, Labour and the State" is the most important in this collection and deals precisely with this question: with the political and economic 'power relationships' in society.

Holland argues that at present under all governments, "both the political process [i.e. popular involve. ment in it] and labour tend to be marginalised within the system, which is concentrated on the State and capital, and serviced by the dominant ideology.. " (p.216).

In other words, the State and Capital are the twin dominant factors in society. The task therefore (for a future Labour Government, of course) is to establish:

"both the political process, and labour as a social and class interest, at the centre of the system of democratic power" (p.232).

In this, "the State apparatus... would have a role in, but not dominate", government, while:

'the interests of labour [would transform] the ownership and control of capital in society — effectively transforming capital itself" (p.233). This requires changing the dominant ideology, which involves, amongst other things, greater public control over the media. Virtue In place of the class struggle and the fight for workers' control, we have a Labour Government of a hypothetical sort securing workers' control over capitalists - presumably by virtue of good intentions. Having established that the State.is closely connected to Capital, Holland does not draw the logical conclusion that the State (and the capitalists) are likely to resist this attempt to change 'power relationships' — if necessary by violence.

His strategy, ignoring the class struggle, would condemn us to a second Chile.

In substance, despite the pretentious theoretical presentation, Holland's scheme for the future is no different from the old Tribunite schemes. Import controls (now the planning of foreign trade), planning agreements, increased public spending, more public ownership, and so on.

The movement of Ford workers, lorry drivers, and public sector workers against the Labour Government is not mentioned. For these writers, the working class is the passive recipient of policies, not the agent of change. The lessons of mass struggle - against Heath as well as against the last Govern. ment — and their relevance in the coming battles with Thatcher & Co., have also passed these writers by. Everything revolves around their own Parliamentary subcommittee.

The measure of the value of this book's indictments of the last Labour Government will be the preparedness of the Tribunites to fight not just Thatcher but also Callaghan. Yet Holland, who, alone in this book, stresses the need for democracy in

----- pull-quotes -----

SOCIAL CONFLICT:

SOCIAL EONTRACT

* WE BUILD PRINCESS

SOCIAL CONTRACT SOCIAL CONFLICT RIKE CALLACE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 12

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →