After Brighton - two Labour Parties or one
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
for Wood Green THE RIGHT-WING is trying to get a confrontation between the Parliamentary Labour Party and the National Executive Committee. At the meeting later this week, there will be a resolution from the Shadow Cabinet criticising the NEC and pressing for substantial representation on the enquiry.
One thing we should watch is moves by the right wing to change the composition of the NEC. That might be their tack. They will try to break the left's grip by altering the rules for electing the NEC.
We're told that the resolution was passed unanimously by the Shadow Cabinet, but I don't think that's true. The Tribune members (Silkin, Booth and Orme), didn't necessarily agree.
At the PLP meeting there will be two amendments, one from Norman Buchan and one from the Manifesto Group. The Manifesto Group's position is that if the NEC doesn't accept a heftier representation from the PLP. then the PLP should not cooperate with the enquiry. This is going to be the right wing's major tack: they are going to try to use the PLP as a means of attacking the left in the party, as it is only the PLP that has a right wing majority This is in line with the threat from the NUR and APEX that they will pay the political levy in future direct to the PLP. They will remain affiliated but will cease to relate to the national Party.
What the left should do is call their bluff. We should say that it they want to spilt the Party, then they should come right out in the open and say which of them is going to stand by the PLP and which is going to stand by the Party based on the unions. I think they'll back down if we charge them" bluntly with trying to split the Party — after all, they're the one that are always on about unity.
So long as the inquiry is in operation, the left must make sure that it gets proper evidence before it. It must also press the issue of the election of the Party leader, so that we can win that issue at next year's conference.
As far as the real policy issues are concerned, top of the list must come economic policy, Heseltine made mincemeat of Hattersley in the Commons the other day. Of course what Hattersley is. now saying is nothing like what he was saying when Labour was in power. Linked with that are questions like public expenditure and, of course, incomes policy. This winter again the question of the public sector wage claims is going to be very important.
There needs to be a clear fight for a statutory minimum wage, for a planned economy and for public ownership to control the activities of the monopolies. That's what the left must push for.
JO RICHARDSON, MP for Barking I think the right-wing have gone mad. There's nothing they can formally do about the enquiry and the conference decisions, not now. They can pass resolutions, but... Well, there's nothing they can do to stop the enquiry, but they can boycott The resolution that will go before the PLP may win a majority to urge the NEC to think again. Rumour is that a boycott is what the rightwing is planning if the NEC don't cave in to their demands. I don't know what they are trying to achieve. They can go before the inquiry, they can give what evidence they like, they can talk their hind legs off. But they shouIdn't have any special place. I hope the rest of the movement will judge the matter correctly.
Some PLP members might be tempted to set up the PLP as a separate party. But the overwhelming majority of unions will continue to pay their money to the Party that matters, that is the national Party.
The CLPs should now be calling on their MPs to give an account of themselves, to say exactly where they stand on the threatened split, and to say how they voted in the PLP meeting.
The amendment proposed by Norman Buchan is a very good initiative. It isn't a Tribune group move. Norman Buchan and Chris Price drew it up and we only met as a group afterwards, but the Tribune group supports the initiative. Of course, three members of the Shadow Cabinet are group members, and I would be very surprised if they went along without demur Apart from the internal issues, I think that one of our priorities should be defence. We've not said a word about second generation nuclear weapons. What appeared in the Manifesto was a trimming version, but now with the Tories planning a second generation of Polaris submarines, we need to evolve a really detailed and firm policy on defence.
Employment, industry, education — these are all important areas. And, of course. there is the EEC issue: if Britain doesn't get her way on payments, we ought to say as a Party that we, Britain that is, should get out.
Callaghan wants the PLP to be the 'real' party