Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labor Party The Left disarmed over disarmament

Socialist Organiser no. 13, November 1979 · scan p. 9 · about 1,575 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Sacialia Organiser 9

AT ITS Scarborough conference in 1960, the Labour Party voted in favour of unilateral nuclear disarmament by Britain.

This decision had tremendous impliations for British politics, tor it opened a fundamental breach in Labour-Tory foreign and defence' policy bipartisanship, one of the pillars on which class collaboration rests, and on which depends the possibility of orderly changes in party government at Westminster.

British unilateral nuclear disarmament implied the disruption of NATO and probably British withdrawal from the western military alliances, all of which relied on nuclear weapons. In 1960 Britain still had an empire, of sorts, claimed a 'special relationship with the USA, and in general still had some weight in the affairs of the world. The Scarborough decision committed the Labour party to challenge policies and commitments which the British ruling class considered fundamental to its interests.

The story of how the ruling class fought back, relying on its supporters in the Labour Party led by Parliamentary Labour Party leader Hugh Gaitskell, and in a matter of months whipped the Labour Party back into line with its political needs, will be of interest to those faced now with fighting to implement the recent Brighton conference decisions on party democray. The struggle around the scarborough decision was one of the most important and decisive political experences tor the post-war Labour left (and for the revolutionary left too).

Much of the feebleness, demoralisation and ineptness which the Tribune left displayed in the '60s and '70s can be traced to the events of 1960-61.

A great wave of alarm at the prospect of nuclear war ran through Britain and many other countries in the late '50s. People had not got used to living in a long-term nuclear stalemate, and the idea that it could continue for at least two more decades would have been considered improbable. The eruption of the cold war into nuclear holocaust seemed an imminent threat in every conflict involving the USA and the USSR.

On a number of occasions, as is now generally known, the world was in fact on the brink of World War 3 - for example when the monarchy was toppled in Iraq and the US landed troops in Lebanon in the summer of 1958.

Bevan

Of 443 resolutions at the 1957 Labour Party conference, no less than 127 were concerned with nuclear weapons or general disarmament. A resolution from Norwood Labour Party. inspired by Trotskyists, advocating unilateral nuclear disarmament, was defeated at the 1957 conference after Aneurin Bevan, the personality around whom the Labour Left had crystallised since 1951, had marked his reconciliation with the right wing with a notorious speech explaining that he, as a future British Foreign Secretary, could not *• go naked into the conference chamber" denuded of British nuclear weapons.

But Bevan failed to carry the Tribune left with him.

Even Jennie Lee, his close political associate and wife, explained in Tribune that she had abstained on the At Easter 1958, '59, and 60, there were enormous Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament [CND] marches from the Nuclear Research Establishment at Aldermaston to London. Each year the march got bigger and bigger, reaching 100,000 by Easter 1960.

Support for unilateralism became so powerful in the trade unions, partly through the work of TGWU general secretary Frank Cousins, that by 1960 victory at Labour Party conference was in sight.

Even the Communist Party felt compelled to abandon opposition to CND, and that gave unilateralism a big boost in unions like the AUEW and threw the ETU. then led by the CP. behind unilateralism. (From 1957 to around the Easter march in 1960, the CP had denounced the CND for "splitting the broad peace movement"")

At Scarborough the National Executive Committee (NEC) resolution of support for the western military alliances and their nuclear weapons was defeated by 300,000 votes. A resolution from the TGWU committing the Labour Party to unilateral renunciation of nuclear weapons was carried by a majority of 43,000.

Moving the NEC resolution, Sam Watson struck the two keynotes of the campaign the right wing was to wage. Witchunting: unilateralists should not be in the Labour Party, "we have no rioht to accept in our movement communists. Trotskyists, and fellow-travellers"

And demanding that unilateralists draw the logical conclusions from unilateralism: he asked them if they actually wanted to leave NATO?

In fact, all the leading Labour Party proponents of unilateralism wanted to stay in NATO! The political level of the unilateralists tended to be pacifistic and utopian.

Generally they did not grasp how fundamental a challenge to the ruling class their proposal and its ramifications were. From opposite standpoints both the Right and the Marxists in the Labour Party pointed out what the implications were.

Before the vote at Scarborough. Hugh Gaitskell boldly told the delegates what the Right would do if they lost: the Parliamentary Labour Party, would not be bound by a decision it did not agree with. The MPs supported the NEC policy. "So what do you expect them to do? Go back on the pledges they gave to the people who elected them from their constituencies?... Do you think that we can become overnight the pacifists, unilateralists and fellow-travellers MARCH swung squarely behind Gaitskell. organising meetings for him and his supporters. Requests" that these meetings should also feature supporters of official Party policy were turned down. Naturally some of these meetings became rowdy and were accompanied by demonstrations against Gaitskell.

Using its majority on the NEC. the Right went on the offensive. On November 23rd. the NEC launched a the Congress for Cultural Freedom, which was financed by the CIA), that a conference defeat for the right wing might be to their advantage if it gave the Parliamentary Labour Party the chance to dramatically assert independence by defying Party conference, thus shifting the balance of power in the Party in favour of the PLP. After Scarborough, the Gaitskellites carried out this policy and their mixture of intransigence and aggressive action paralysed the Labour left.

To consolidate its Scarborough victory the left needed to face up to the implications of unilateralism, and to organise. Tribune, the organ of the official left, at that time still had some serious influence on the rank and file, and though the org anised left was quite weak (100 attended the annual meeting of the Tribune org anisation Victory for Socialism in 1961; 50 attended the Scarborough fringe meeting of the Trotskyist-influenced Clause Four Campaign Com mittee) the many thousands of CND supporters and activ. ists was a reservoir from which a mass left wing could have developed, as part of a fight for the Scarborough decisions. But a Campaigr Committee for the Scarbor ough Decisions, organised by Russell Kerr, could stil organise meetings of from 100 to 500 in many areas of the country.

Scarborough victory on unilateral nuclear disarmament was transmuted into a unilateral political disarmament by the Tribunites.

Immediately after Scarborough Michael Foot, soon to be returned to Parliament for Nye Bevan's old seat of Ebbw Vale (Bevan had died

July 1960) declared his support for the right of MPs who disagreed with the Scarborough decisions to vote in

Parliament according to their conscience. The necessary response to the revolt of the MPs, a fight to kick out and replace them, was not even aired by Tribune. The executive of Victory for Socialism rejected a proposal by Hugh Jenkins that they should advocate the selection of new candidates where Labour MPs refused to abide by conterence decisions. (So Jenkins told a VFS meeting in 1961, reported in The Newsletter on June 3rd 1961). Rejecting such action meant that Tribune surrendered to the PLP.

Instead of organising the fight and taking on the MPs, Tribune's leaders immediately looked for a compromise. Prominent left winger Anthony Greenwood MP said at the end of October: 'I believe it would be a disaster for anybody to split the Labour Party on an issue which changes from day to day. Neither side can be too dogmatic demanding' meant that he wouldn't 'dogmatic or demanding'.

Talk like that couldn't molify the Gaitskellites; could, however, not fail to dampen down the fighting spirits of those who took Greenwood seriously, and many did.

Greenwood resigned from the shadow cabinet and told Gaitskell publicly that his behaviour was 'quite incompatible with the democratic constitution and spirit of the labour movement Just so - but what to do about it? Certainly Tribune didn't know. *No doubt also there must be consequential changes in the Labour Party itself. It is too early to discern their exact nature. This written after Gaitskell announced that the PLP would defy conference.

In fact in December Tribune simply began to shift its political focus away from unilateralism. that month Tribune carried this astonishing piece of front. page advice to Gaitskell on how to fake: 'And here was a proposition (the Tory government proposal, debated in Parliament, to set up Polaris missile base in the west of Scotland) which could be frontally opposed; not only by those who support the Scarborough decision on the Labour Party but also by the parliamentary leaders of the Labour Party who have criticised NATO's strategy on the technical grounds that it Is too reliant on nuclear weapons. But Gaitskell put down a motion which could not possibly be voted for by supporters of Scarborough ... implicitly accepting the nuclear strategy and specific-

----- pull-quotes -----

witchunt against the youth ATDERMIASITON BIDON

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 13

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →