The Left disarmed over disarmament
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Continued from p.9 nuclear weapons first.
Should Prime Minister Macmillan and President J.F. Kennedy be 'pressed' to declare that they would never use nuclear weapons first? The question 'goes to the root of the recent controversies about defence in the Labour Party' , wrote Michael Foot in Tribune on March 3rd, 1961. Foot was looking for a compromise, or rather a ladder to climb down. But Gaitskell wasn't obliging: a few days after the article was published, Foot and the other four were thrown out of the PLP.
In February. a drafting committee of 12 from the TUC and the NEC passed by eight to four a new right wig 'defence' statement idrafted by Dennis Healey) for the next Labour Party conference. The minority (Walter Padley, Dick Crossman, Tom Driberg and Frank Cousins)
produced a compromise based on the idea of the pledge not to strike first: *While we recognise that the Americans will retain nuclear weapons so long as the Russians possess them, we reject absolutely a NATO strategy based on the threat to use them first and a defence policy which compels NATO forces to rely on these weap: ons in the field'.
Tribune advocated the Crossman compromise' , and thus undercut the whole unilateralist position, which it still formally adhered to. Foot wrote that it would be a major step forward if the Crossman document (or a less cynical variant of the same worked out by Frank Cousins) could secure the general backing of the Labour Party' The 'compromise now became the left's alternative to the Healey draft, and was touted as a basis for unity.
In fact the right conceded nothing, and Gaitskell referred contemptuously to the wriggling of the Tribunites' Device The "compromise" was a transparently cynical device to get the left off the hook. Adopted by USDAW. the "compromise' was not even moved at the Blackpool party conference. Once it had done its work of demobilising unilateralism, USDAW abandoned it.
Not surprisingly, unilateralism lost ground, and when, in May, the AUE came out against unilateralism it was clear that the Gaitskellites would win at Blackpool.
In Tribune on May 12, Foot. recognised defeat. philosophically: * ... the task of transforming British society by democratic means and securing a British government capable of playing an ettective independent role in world affairs is bound to be immensely difficult. The prior task of carrying through a socialist political education of the movement as a whole cannot be avoided. ... Scarborough marked a considerable achievement, more swift than many expected. Given courage and energy on the left the impetus of Scarborough can be recovered' Another time ... another place ... other people...
At Brighton in October '61 the hard line cold war official resolution 'Policy for Peace' was carried by 4,526,000 against 1,756,000. By a majority of about one million conference voted against Polaris bases and against the training of German NATO troops on British soil...
The issue of Tribune that reported Gaitskell's victory advised unilateralists in a front page headline: Don't stop - keep on marching' Just like the grand old Duke of York.
The unilateralist victory at the 1960 conference was something of a windfall for which the left was unprepared and whose implications and repercussions on the terrain of major party politics many of its proponents. had not inderstood. Almost by accident they had begun to pull down the structure of class collaboration and provoked a backlash from the ruling class agents in the labour movement that they couldn't handle. Intimidated by the right's threat of a split, the official left ran awayCrossman sounded the retreat The Gaitskellites had the ruling class and their state system to relate to and serve, and these in turn had a 'programme' expressing their interests. The only alternative programme, that of working class struggle, was not a common property of the unilateralists, who were often utopians.
Hence it was more than a question of the character of the lefts (Foot's record before 1960 was not contemptible) but of their left reformist politics and their characteristic failure to think things through to their conclusion and to draw the necessary conclusions in practice from political positions like unilateralism.
Before Scarborough Foot wrote in Tribune (in a front page article entitled: Don't be afraid of victory') *Scarborough will be momentous. No one can doubt that.