Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

LETTER: Lambeth - not a question of power

Socialist Organiser no. 13, November 1979 · scan p. 10 · about 821 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Dear comrades.

In an article in the October by Lambeth Couneil - Some supporters of the SCLV make statements which I believe need to be discussed further!

Of course it is the duty of socialists to give all possible support to the stand being taken by Lambeth Council - and any other councils - against the cuts. However, the comrades write:

In the past Socialist Org aniser has printed criticism off Lambeth Council leader Ted Knight for even contemplating any form of temporary compromise with the Tories and central government. In our view, Ted Knight underestimated his own and his supporters' strength.

"But when comrades such as those now leading Lambeth Council feel obliged, under pressure, to make concessions to the superior force of the capitalist state, it is not because they want to: it is because, to the extent that we lack the physical power enabling us to overthrow the whole system of big business, the insurance companies and the state - to that extent all of us are continuously forced to make concessions on the level ot pracucal struggle.

*What these events mean ir reality is that we are involved in a struggle for power. What the Lambeth comrades need now, therefore, is not pious resolutions or recipes for socalism on paper - what ther need is the real power which only all of us through our orgment can provide', Dass move. anisations in the Ted Knight did not just "contemplate" some "form of temporary compromise with the Tories and central government" Lambeth Council decided to implement the cuts and only reversed its decision under pressure from the local labour movement.

Criticism of Lambeth Council for its decision was fully justified, as is criticism of other Labour Councils - be they left or right wing - which refuse to take a stand against the cuts. [Of course, we do not agree with anyone who uses the Council's original decis ion to oppose support now].

The comrades seem to be making elaborate excuses for Lambeth Council's pro-cuts decision. The excuses are not only elaborate, but positively insulting. The argument is: *There was nothing else the councillors could pressure was too strong' - as if the councillors did not have the wit or willpower to do anything but passively reflect contending social pressures.

Any serious political activist tries to help create or resist social pressures, not just respond to them. Those are the standards by which the Lambeth councillors must be judged - and by which, as self-respecting people, they would no doubt wish to be judged.

Of course concessions have to be made 'on the level of practical struggle' , but such concessions are made in struggle, when support is lacking for further struggle. For example, a council could decide to refuse to implement the cuts and be beaten back or fail to arouse sufficient support in the local labour movement. struggle against the cuter ov But how could it further the alone the struggle for the erthrow of the whole system of big business" , for a Council to gree trom the beginnins without any attempt at mobil isation or struggle, to implement the cuts?

The comrades appear to say in some mystified way -that the struggle against the cuts was furthered by implementing them. The comrades would not recognise this conclusion as theirs, but it is the rational thread of the bombast about 'power' Then the comrades turn round, after Lambeth Council has reversed ite decision, a struggle for power" *what the Lambeth comrades need now. is the real power which only all of us through our organisations in the mass movement can provide"

Obviously the view that one decision against thecuts means a struggle for power [apparently meaning state power 1s consistent with the idea that nothing can be done until we can overthrow capitalism. However, it is hardly consistent with reality.

The struggle by councils against the cuts may develop and link up with other battles, so that they broaden into a struggle for power, and this is obviously the direction in which all revolutionaries should strive - but it is the least likely of many possibilities retreat by the Tories, compromise, the council giving way, etc...]| Certainly we need to organise maximum support in the labour movement for Lambeth's stand against the cuts, but talk of "giving councillors the power..." can be misleading. What does this concretely mean? It means that we mobilise maximum support for the Council but leave control of the struggle in the hands of the councillors.

We would argue that support should be built, not on the basis of just depending on the councillors to lead the struggle, but independently, so as to be able to continue the struggle if the Council backs down or falters.

Mobilisation is needed in support of Lambeth's stand, on November 7th and after, but it must be done without myths and mystifications.

PETE FIRMIN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 13

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →