Rate Rises: a Way to Fight the Cuis?
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-12-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
AFTER SHARP debate, a motion opposing rate rises was carried. It was moved by Gordon Brewer (Lothian).!
*The question the rates", he said, • is more and more becoming the dividing line between a campaign against the cuts based on direct action, and a campaign that confines itself to verbal opposition"
Rate rises are another form of cut. For council tenants, for example, rate rises are indistinguishable from rent rises. And rate rises as a way of squeezing the middle class are not progressive. *We won't ing them people by attack- win over In any case, rate rises cannot offset the cuts. Without an all-out fightback, the result will be, not rate rises or cuts, but rate rises and cuts. This is double true after Michael Heseltine's recent announcement that the government will take action against councils levying big rate rises.
Rate rises run counter to a fight against the cuts: *It is ludicrous to think you can mobilise people by cutting their living standards And indeed, the arguments for rate rises base themselves not on the class struggle perspective of challenging the capitalist system, but on the existing role of councils, on the alternatives within the existing framework" Rate rises are often "the way right wing and soft left councillors get out of mobilising for a struggle.
Pete Rowlands (West London) agreed that rates are a regressive form of taxation, that "we would not argue that rate rises are some way of offsetting cuts" and that within the next two years it will become impossible to use rate rises. But, he said, in the short term, "if a council feels incapable of fighting both cuts and rate rises, that position should not be opp osed"
Councils opposing rate rises as well as cuts will go down to defeat - just as for our movement" • And "we are not in favour of heroic defeats. Better to have a Labour Council in Lambeth next year, even i if it has to raise rates, than to have Commissioners sent in by the Tories".
Bill Bowring, one of the Lambeth councillors who opposed cuts even in July when the council majority voted for cuts, spoke against Against rate rises: Gordon Brewer, Dave Spencer rate rises. "It is a question of mobilising the working class as a whole politically against this government"
Labour councillors are not shop stewards. touting for the best deal they can get, he said. They are people who manage the local state. 'Are we going to be the agents of the capitalist state in carrying out these cuts" -thus directly opposing the working class?
Rate rises are another form of cut. And it is nonsense! said Bowring, "to say that it is better to have left Labour councils carrying out cuts or rate rises than to have Tories, doing it".
Geoff Bender (Lambeth) said that "none of us is over the moon about the prospect of rate rises", but the question is to have an analysis and strategy rather than posturing.
We must "unite with material forces capable of defeating the Tories" And the real dividing line is on making cuts or nor, not on rate rises. Brewer had said that rate rises were another form of cut - how did he explain Heseltine's promise to penalise councils who raise rates?
Those arguing against rate rises would, said Bender, fail to support Lambeth Council against the Tories if Lambeth raises rates. But without rate Tises. Labour councils will go broke.
Dave Spencer (Coventry) disputed Pete Rowlands' assertion that Clay Cross was a defeat. By making a stand. Clay Cross had shown to wide sections of the labour movement that it was possible to defy the government.
Many Labour councils. like Coventry's, are "anti-cuts" in words — but thev 'speak with a forked tongue" • We should tell them 'we don't want them to mat age on behalf of the Tory government. We want them to make a stand and mobilise against the Tory government"
Al Crisp (UPW. International Telephones) said that *If councils don't raise rates. they will go bankrupt That means not paying wages. not providing services. Those opposing rate rises are "walking away from the fight" and refusing to back councils like Lambeth against the Tories 1 Martin Thomas (Islingon) repiied that there is 'no question" of us not supporting Lambeth's delcontinued on p.8