Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[uggle itional Programme or something very much like…]

Socialist Organiser no. 14, December 1979 · scan p. 7 · about 1,003 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

uggle itional Programme or something very much like that" And. by downplaying the definite demands. *it would leave us as a smaller LCC" just vaguely "for secialism" It would gut the SCLV of the vital element - which •marks us off from the soft reformists and the would-be Marxists who just talk"

The amendment was clearly lost.

In the afternoon. the organisational report by Mike Davis (SCLV Secretary) opened debate raising many similar issues. After the election of a Tory government. *the working class, the Labour Party, and the SCLV all face decisive tests"

*The key issue" said Davis. is whether the SCLV grows and reaches out. or becomes the preserve of a few particular tendencies"

As positive achievements ised distribution, both to increase circulation and make the paper more of organiser, Doug Mackay (Birmingham, Selly Oak) stressed that the paper must cover not just Labour Party internal debates, but also those struggles which at present largely by-pass the Labour Party.

Mike Davis had moved a resolution on SCLV structure from the outgoing Secretariat, which provided for an elected Steering Committee of 25. Frank Hansen (Brent) moved an amendment to delete a clause saying that a 40% minority on the SC could Forum for debate with the LCC leadership. The paper should be controlled by open meetings of SCLV supporters.

The structure resolution was clearly carried. Don Flynn then proposed a lengthy resolution from the Hackney Socialist Organiser group on how the SCLV should operate.

There are three views, maid Flynn, about the way forward. One sees the SCLV as leading the left wing fightback in the labour movement; it presents the SCLV as the organisation with the right politics in the Labour Party.

Flynn supported another view, which he identified with Mike Davis' speech: the left in the Labour Party "has never been better organised, never more clear and confident" . It "does not need us to dive in and Clive Bradley: SCLV needs a clear platform resolution, apparently say ing that no. tendency should have a majority on the Steering Committee, was anti-democratic; it could only mean a restriction on the conference's right to vote whom it wished on to the SC.

Bruce Robinson (Islington) said that straw men had been set up. Everyone agrees on debate, discussion and work within the LCC. But the cutting edge of the SCLV has to be clear political deas.

It is true that the SCLV represents an alliance of different tendencies. That is • its strength and that should continue. Discussion will continue and minorities will have full rights. But the Hackney proposal on the Steering Committee would disenfranchise the SCLV conference.

Geoff Bender (Lambeth) backed the Hackney resolution as pointing to broad left wing alliance rather than a super-cadre sect* The Manchester amendment was carried, and then the Hackney resolution as amended.

The conference concluded with perhaps the most extreme statement of the argument that SCLV perspectives and structure are "sectarian" • John Connolly (West London) denounced the fact that Socialist Organiser has "chosen to tell councillors off in no uncertain terms if it doesn't like what they are doing Because of this "passive propagandist" direction, he said, the West London group now takes no papers.

He moved a motion on SO which, though contain. THE DEBATE on the SCLV and the women's movement centred around two alternative perspectives. The main perspectives document, amplified by an amendment from Lothian, proposed "attempting to create socialist women's movement based in the working class" including by "restructuring and reorientation of sections of the existing women's movement"

Hackney SO group proposed instead an orientation to "support the existence of an autonomous women's movement" and "to strengthen the Socialist-Feminist current."

Both agreed in supporting the SCLV's Fightback for Women's Rights Campaign, though it was given a more central role in the main perspectives document and the Lothian amendment than in Hackney's proposals.

Sexist

Ros Tyrrell, moving the Hackney amendment, said that the main perspectives document was weak because it ignored the SocialistFeminist current. The SCLV should "reaffirm its support to the already existing women's movement" and the work of the SocialistFeminists, trying to raise issues of importance to working class women. but: "the women's liberation movement would not claim to represent working class women and we should not either. We should look at the lessons of the Working Women's Charter. Many trade unions supported it without anything changing much. The WWC focused too much on policy demands, rather than a broader fight against sexist attitudes.

Jo Thwaites (Lothian) argued that sections of the Socialist-Feminist Current. The SCLV supports the National Abortion Campaign for example, as a single-issue campaigning organisation. "The Socialist-Feminist current is not an active, ampaigning body, but an ideological current."

The ideas of the SocialistFeminist current, as expressed for example in 'Beyond the Fragments' , include an evolutionary, semi-reformist concept of socialism. disagree with these ideas" Longman said, "and I think we can't commit the SCLV asi a body to support them, though individuals within the SCLV may do so."

*We should not be passive cheerleaders for the existing women's movement, but build Fightback, and draw in working class women.

Mike Davis (Hackney) argued that we should first support the existing womens movement, focus on the fight against the Corrie Bill and then situate Fightback within that. "Many comrades do not understand the significance of the autonomous women's movement." Even if we do not agree with all of Beyond the Fragments' it does "Raise important points about patriarchal attitudes."

Alice Pfister (Lothian) said that the Brent East amendment would leave us with no clear idea of how to relate to the existing women's movement. On the whole, that movement has no clear orientation to working class women and that flows from its politics and analysis. Sol we must argue for "restructuring and reorientation" Angela Shariff (Brent East) replied: We don't accept that the SCLV can be so arrogant as to think we know the ways for the women's movement to restructure and reorient itself."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 14

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →