[who wishes to look back -and forward too…]
Socialist Organiser1979 1979-12-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
who wishes to look back -and forward too - and take -stock will observe tremendous. gains, and glaring faults.
The women's movement. scattered among a myriad local groups, cultural and artistic initiatives, publications, health and self-help centres, caucuses and conferences, has done more in ten years to change attitudes to women than all the good intentions and well-meaning articles and speeches of socialists did over decades. It has produced a real lowering of ideas, a ferment of activity and a rise in confidence and sense of identity among women, all of which is a real gain.
But after ten years, little of material value has changed. and much has changed for the worse. Spare Rib itself included in its new 1980 diary the telling slogan: my consciousness is fine, it's my pay that needs raising.
The gains have been as fragile as any other reforms, easily threatened by an economic squeeze or the ideological assaults of a Tory government.
It is beyond dispute that the majority of women fighting back right now are not organised by the women's movement at all.
One of the most glaring failures of the women's movement has been its failure to organise working class (indeed, working) women, who form the majority of women, who are the most oppressed and exploited women, and who also have the potential for collective action which is massively more powerful and effective than anything the women's movement can mount. -Fight If isn't that the women's movement has tried to organise working women, and failed. Rather, this is something it has never sought to do, for a number of related reasons.
-First, it has been more concerned with 'intimate, personal areas. , self-inquiry, counselling and therapy to cushion the impact of a sexist and brutal society.
Second, there really isn't any way to organise working class women without doing serious work in the trade union movement. The women's movement would have had to summon up the determination to brave that world of brothers and bureaucrats, of resolutions and rules of procedure which it prides itself on having superceded. It would mean organdising in a much tighter way to cope with organisational -structures which are condemned as male.
• Even the most 'rank-andfluenced by utopian concepts ('pre-figurative socialism') of living socialism now This sort of life-style' politics is of course only open to women who are free of the pressures that bear down on the working class.
And, as Lynne Segal observes in Beyond the Fragments, 'Our lack of structure perhaps made it difficult for working class women, outside of our friendship networks, to know how to get involved' Nor do those women who regret the middle class dom¡nation of the women's movement know how to get involved themselves with working class women: without working in the labour movement, all they can see is a patronising populism which not surprisingly they find repellant.
The estrangement of thousands of militant feminists from the workers' movement has meant that trade union attitudes have changed very slowly and very little in response to the last ten years work of the women's movement. Shifting much more slowly than the liberal media or the middle class professions that have made their littla node in the direction of women's liberation, they remain male bastions.
But an active struggle by a significant segment of the women's movement could have forced a much greater response in the trade union movement, bringing the issue of women's rights into a more prominent place on the agenda.
But it should not be posed as a choice women's movement or the trade unions. The trade union movement, though it organises many times more women than are involved or even consciously influenced by the women's movement, can never substitute for a women's movement.
Substitute
It was not built to serve that purpose, and no amount of women's officers, or women officers, or women's caucuses, can serve as a substitute, We need an active, fighting movement in which working class women organise for themselves, set their own priorities and decide their needs, so that women's rights are guaranteed all the emphasis we can give them and are not an optional extra.
Women in such a movement will have to sort out what is and what is not useful to them from the insiehts and methods developed the women's movement far. are very much more oppressed than their middle class sisters who are likely to have more money, more (and pleasanter) space, more leisure, more freedom and a better education.
Moreover, while middle class women can choose to opt for a 'pre-figurative" feminist archipelago, a working class women's movement must confront the broader political issues that face working class women as part of their class.
The womeh who have marched to keep the Corby steelworks open, those who have to walk their kids to and from school because the lollipop man has been cut, and those fighting to keep the local old folks home open are all up against the raw edge of capitalism. Ultimately, to win, they will have to seek out the way to socialişed by smashing capitalism. brtlike lanse swerhes of the mem movement, they can't turn their backs on capitalism or carve out an alternative life-style that can evade the whole question of class power.
Unfortunately without ever drawing the real lessons from her observations, Lynne Segal in Beyond the Fragments makes this devastating indictment of the women's movement as it has been: The split remained Thẻ absence of such women's movement does not mean the absence of women from industrial, political and community struggles.
Hundreds of thousands of women are organising and marching, taking industrial action and petitioning, mobilising and rallying others onto the streets, in a spontaneous fightback which didn't start with the Thatcher government but which has taken on a new urgency and vigour in face of the deliberate onslaught against women by the party of the family. rivate property and the bourgeois state machine.
In the fight against cuts, against the Corrie anti-abortion bill, against attempts to dismantle hard won legal rights and against the especial sex discrimination threatened against our immigrant sisters, the old boundaries may begin to loosen. We could see a regrouping and re-forming of sections of the women's movement and of the working class movement.
Wider Women who have come to see the shortcomings of the women's movement, and who want to engage in a real fight with the government, will be coming together with those drawn in over the cuts or the Corrie Bill or other single issue campaigns who feel the need for national coordination in a movement that has wider and longer term aims than this or that local or specialised campaign. And the pressure of the mass of working class women taking militant action is bound to reverberate through the trade union movement making possible big changes in the old male bastions.
The Labour Movement Fightback for Women's Rights can play an important part in this ferment. It can contribute a conception of a working class orientation that isn't limited to pay and conditions but recognises all the ways in which women are oppressed.
At its conference in March and in building and preparing for that conference, it will set out to bring together a large of specific campaigumber making their work and their understandings more widely known and acted upon.
It will promote initiatives and ideas of the women's movement in the labour movement - both for their own value and worth, and inthe hope of encouraging a wider acceptance among feminists of the possibilities open to women in the labour movement.
Together with other town of Nablus, on the West Bank, have thrown a spotlight on the true nature of Zionist rule.
On November 11 the mayor of Nablus, an Arab town, waS summoned to the office of the local military governor and told that he was to be expelled from the area. The charge against Mayor Bassam Shaka was that he identified himself What strange char appared? with terrorism' indeed Five days before, Mayor Shaka was brought before the local commander Aluf the mayor in a bantering sort of way, but became increasingLy angry when he managed neither to provoke Shaka nor to win the argument.
He then asked him what he thought of the "Coastal Road killers' of Palestinians who lad attacked Isr aelis in a raid last year. *The Coastal Road aRgailants carried out their action, replied the mayor according to a tape recording made by the military commander's staff, becaused of the occupation (of Palestine by Israel)... As. long as there is occupation and killing, you can expect many such actions.
Matt tried in vain to get Shaka to say that he thought that the asseilants actions were all justifiable. Shaka! would only repeat that such actions were the inevitable response to the general situation of Zionist occupation.
The interview soon drew to close: "This conversation democratic country srael is goes show what remarked Matt.
Bassam Shaka didn't quite agree, and how right he was within days he WaS arrested by the same military commander and told he was to be expelled for the remarks he had made in that conversation. The West! Bank immediately erupted into protest: there were strikes some of which are still on), protest marches, hunger strikes, petitions, a United Nations resolution even supported by the US, and protests in the Knesset, Israel's parliament.
Not many miles away lies the settlement of Eilon Moreh. This was established on Arabs land by members of the ultranationalist Gush Emunim (Block of the Faithful) movement. The military authorities had confiscated the land from the Arab farmers and Эго tected the Gush while they ook over.
Now the High Court has ruled that the land, because it was not confiscated for military purposes - a phrase that covers the robbery by Israel of land in the "occupied territories" with a veneer of legality - must be returned.
The Gush, however, have so far refused to budge despite pressure from the rovern ment. They say that if they have to go, then there will be an avalanche of claims by Arabs whose land has been perate is the government not taken for settlement. So deshave to use force against these robbers (who are in any case Begin supporters)
that it has announced a new plan for increased settlement.
that it hopes will bribe the rush to give up Eilon Moreh.
The plan, f implemented would cost the equivalent of half Israel's national budget - that's quite something or a country with an inflation rate of 150%! - and involve the confiscation of even more land.
ANDREW HORNUNG
----- pull-quotes -----
groups and campaigns, it will SAY WHAI TWO RECENT incidents in the