Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Letter The start fightback

Socialist Organiser no. 14, December 1979 · scan p. 11 · about 2,356 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

A short report on the cuts in Leicester in our last issue said that the Labour City Council has not yet decided on cuts, "but the prevalent mood is summed up by the Spinney Hill ward of Leicester South Tedlur ongy" who tolk "indiscriminate cutting"

As chairman of Wycliffe Branch Labour Party (Leicester South) and a supporter of Socialist Organiser, may I comment on the article published about Leicester in the November issue.

Firstly, it is relevant to note that my branch supported the SCLV campaign, and Spinney Hill did not./ Secondly, that as far as l am aware, there are no supporters of SO in the Spinney Hill branch. invited an SO speaker and wil branch shortly be deciding on support for SO and a delegate to the Conference.

What your article failed to mention was that both branches agreed to hold 8 joint public meeting as Highfields against the Cuts, but Wycliffe branch refused to endorse the Spinney Hill leaflet and then went ahead to produce its own in both English and Gujerati. The Wycliffe leaflet mentioned cuts in the housing programme, the rate support grant, rent increases, rate increases, and increased defence spendinfiThe Labour It also said City Council must make the stand they promise. They need your support and pressure to oppose these enormous cuts"!

Speakers were invited from the IWA (GB), NUPE, TGWU and NUT in addition to the local councillors and the MP, Jim Marshall. The meeting was publicised over Radio Leicester and nearly 5,000 leaflets were distributed.

The result was, from a few people's hard work, an attendance of over 100 people and a headline in the local newspaper. This has confounded some Labour councillors but is the start of our fightback!

There is also a mass demonstration against the County Council on November 28th, and two petitions entitled *Save our Services' and Save our Schools'. These have been organised by the Public Services Liaison Committee.

Yours fraternally, BERNARD HYNES Chairman, Wycliffe Branch 12 pages.

Revolutionary socialist weekly.

Now includes magazine section. Single copies London N1 ODD Bernard Misrahi presents a minority view on the issue of rate rises.

DESPITE the drenching rain, several thousand council workers, school students and other opponents of the cuts marched through Lambeth on November 7th to show their support for the council which had refused to implement cuts and which had decorated every notice-board and every ofice window with Join the Big March' posters.

Here at last was a municipal authority which was trancending its administrative role and openly campaigning politically.

A great start - but from now on the choices will be more difficult. Massive rate increases to avoid cuts - or bankruptcy next April.

The Government is cutting 5% off the subsidies it gives to local government (about five hundred million pounds) and is distributing more of what is left away from the inner cities to the shires. They have threatened to cut the rate support grant of any council which levies an excessive rate increase, but they MARTIN COOK ference (see report pages 6-8).

EIGHTEEN months ago, more than 200 socialists gathered to launch the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory.

At that time, the los profile of the 'official left' in the movement made it look as if the coming election would pit reactionary Thatcher against reactionary Callaghan, with no visible socialist presence. Our aim was to group together, on a flexible and non-sectarian basis, all the forces inside (and out, in some cases) of the Labour Party prepared to fight for a Labour victory on a clear anti capitalist and class-struggle platform.

OK, so a lot has changed. The left has re-emerged in style at Conference and otherwise, It appears a genuine continued The gist of the AUEW Executive's decision was that all AUEW members were instructed to go back to work. The rest was a disgusting charade - all the more so because the BL bosses still said openly that they would not reinstate Robinson, whatever the results of the inquiry The AUEW Executive apparently proposes nothing at all about the three shop stewards who got minal warnings. need special legislation to do this which will not be ready for this coming financial year. this coming financial year.

Should progressive councils avoid cuts by imposing really massive increases of 50% and beyond - or should they effectively resign by refusing to cut or increase rates?

Some socialists equate rate increases with cuts in services, which both amount to a cut in real wages. By that token, this year's tax cuts should have been welcomed! Anyway, in most boroughs the majority of rates are paid by businesses, but the proportion varies greatly from borough to borough.

Businesses pay 75% of the rates in Camden, but less than 50% • in other places. A rate increase might mean a few pounds less in the bank -but cuts mean less day nurseries and an even longer wait for council flat repairs: hardly likely to help the fight against the Tory government responible for the shortages.

It is all very well to demand *Lambeth (or South Yorkshire) must not stand alone' , and also call on industrial workers to support progressive councils. If sufficient support is not forthcoming the campaign will still have to continue. Rate revitalisation of some shrivelled grass roots in the constituencies may be under way at last.

This implies all the greater urgency in unifying and organising the new Left against the certain right-wing counter-attack and for the battles of the future - not a retreat down the well-troddDays of purist abstentenram and bombastic sloge nising.

In almost every respect, the decisions of the recall SCLV/SO conference held on November 24th represent a consolidated move in the wrong direction. The aim of the Workers' Action supporters, who had a clear majority for their positions on the day, appeared to be the generation of a hard-line intransigent campaign imbued with the idea that it has all the political answers and that the rest of the left is wandering about without a clue what to do next: just waiting for us to corral them in!

Thus, a resolution from West London SO group anc AUEW, Robinson's own union.

On Wednesday 28th the TGWU regional committee called on TGWU members to return to work.

When the news of Duffy's treachery reached the Lohgbridge strike committee on Tuesday afternoon, men cards on the for and some were close to tears.

Before that deadly setback, the BL bosses must have been beginning to think they had miscalculated.

Longbridge struck immediately after the sacking was announced on Monday 19th. increases will be necessary give us more time.

As councillors are personally responsible for any shortfall that arises when they deliberately refuse to raise enough money to meet their programmes, they can be surcharged for the difference.

Some St. Pancras councillors who were surcharged in 1952 are still paying off - as are the Clay Cross councillors (who, incidentally, did increase the rates). Not surprisingly, even radical councillors doubt whether the labour movement will dig deep enough to bail them out./ Yet the option of rate increases might not be open the following year (1981/2). Then, councils might have to go for the final all-out confrontation. Our job this year will be to prepare the movement for this assault by making sure that even progressive councils such as Lambeth refuse to backtrack and implement cuts rather than levy a sufficiently high rate increase.

To put it crudely: we should be arguing for rate increases to maintain services, not against them.

Refusal to raise elg which made a rather obvious lone might think) call for SCLV to be open to those in the Party ready to break with the social-democratic leadership and go forward to the socialist reconstruction of society was thrown out.

So was one from the (UPW) Overseas Telephones SO group, which suggested the 'What We Stand For' platform be re-written "in a less declamatory way, with less emphasis on particular demands and more emphasis on the movement for socialism and how we can build it" '. So we retain the shopping list format of umpteen demands, reading suspiciously like a rehash of the Trotskyist Transitional Programme.

This hardly seems like the way to involve in the Campaign many of the dedicated socialists in the Institute for Workers' Control, Independent Labour Publications and the Labour Co-ordinating Committee - not to mention many of the unaligned socialists around.

The successful Perspectivsection on women blithécalled for the "restructgo down to defeat now, then the BL bosses will have a green light for a major purge of militants.

Robinson's sacking came just after BL bosses had replied with an 'offer' (or ultimatum) of 10% for skilled workers, 5% for the rest, and pages or strings. The strings spell out the details of the "Edwardes plan' which BL workers were blackmailed into voting for in October by the threat of BL otherwise shutting down altogether.

Edwardes had already said 42,000 jobs would go. The 85 pages outline the prospect for the remaining BL workmoney to meet expenditure will almost certainly result in the Tories sending in commissioners who will gleefully savage those services which have the greatest ideological significance - the direct labour building force, the law centres, the radical, locallyfunded community groups and resources centres such as Union Place in Camberwell.

Before this all-out confrontation, the majority of council workers must realise what they are letting themselves in for (the council not having the money to pay their wages, perhaps). Support this action, and have some contingency plans to deal with the consequences. Not that council workers on their own can do much against an intransigent employer, simply by going on strike.

Last winter, Tower Hamlets councillors were unmoved as rubbish decomposed in the street markets, and even when they were locked out of their offices. It is the job of fightback campaigns and Labour Parties to develop this support, based on an understanding of what is at issue, over the next year. Even in Lambeth we have only, perhaps, made a start. uring and reorientation of sections of the existing women's movement... • and so on - an approach that can only be treated with justified contempt by the feminist activists now getting involved in the Labour Party, as being an arrogant and patronising sectarian posture.

WA supporters in fact expressed only distaste for the existing women's movement and its Socialist-Feminist current, while projecting a 'Fightback' campaign which sounds like a re-run of the ill-fated Working Women's Charter Campaign (which ended up as a 'zoo' for rival Trotskyist sects to haggle over irrelevant programmes). For them, the feminist emphasis on consciousness-raising and nonhierarchical forms of organisation is an occasion for snide digs.

The rates issue illustrates a similar mentality. Of course, the conference was quite entitled to pass by more than two to one a resolution condemning rate hikcould follow it, Edwardes is seeking to break the back of trade union organisation in one of Britain's biggest companies.

Whether or not the Tory government has been directly involved in the decision to sack Derek Robinson, certainly it is centrally involved in the whole strategy leading up to that sacking. As a build up to the sacking, Industry Minister Keith Joseph had announced that the government's plans for BL would depend on the workers' reaction to BL's 5% plus strings 'offer'. The consumers of council services, the tenants in particular, have to be mobilised to defend their services. Easier said than done, when the experience of many is shoddy work and bureaucracy.

Another task for our campaigns is to make contact with tenants' organisations (where, usually, no contact previously existed) and together work out how housing managementand, for that matter, care of the eiderly and all the other services - can be changed so that the consumers and workers who provide them can have far greater control.

Don't just defend existing services - fight to change how they are operated./ To grudgingly accept rate increases is not to be defeatist but is to realise the magnitude of the tasks facing us. To oppose rates increases on principle 1s to suppose that 'the masses' will rally in support of a heroic gesture. gestures will have to wait -till 1981 maybe — we have enough to do trying to deveiop a struggle that will venture where constituency Labour parties have never trod. es in principle. Yet no alternative strategy was seriously put forward for the inevitable showdown involving bankruptcy or prison.

One comrade stated that the main divide in the movement lay not between those prepared or not to fight the cuts, but between us intransigents and those who tactically resorted to raising rates li.e. including Lambeth Council which the SCLV claims to support.

The logic of the majority view is either that a mass anti-capitalist movement exists, just waiting for SCLV to give the lead and blow the Tories away... or else that striking a 'holier than thou stance is more important than giving any practical lead on how limited gains or defensive campaigns .. can succeed in the here and now. This is the All or Nothing view of socialism, beloved of the Militant tendency.

So far as this issue of SO is concerned, I leave aside (for reasons of space) the organisational problems left by conference, of which I also have fundamental criticisms. bosses are out to kick over the negotiating tables and tame the unions. Crush the bosses' power, or be crushed by them: that is the alternative which will eventually face our movement.

The whole future of our novement depends on whether we can restructure and reorient it in time.

The combine committee in BL must be reorganised on a more democratic basis, to develop the rank and file confidence and the firm links required to be able to lead battles despite and against the official union leaders where necessary.

----- pull-quotes -----

-23p inc. postage, or sub. rates on request, from PO Box 135.

(Socialist Charter) explains his critic- isms of the decis- ions of the Novem- ber 24th SCLV con-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 14

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →