Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labour's Enquiry: What the Left Should Say Left Should Say

Socialist Organiser no. 15, January 1980 · scan p. 2 · about 917 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

defensive posture în regard ference should not be exto the Inquiry. There are, cluded from discussion by in fact, several areas where the Inquiry. In these circumimportant reforms should stances, we should argue for (i) Expulsion procedures a system under which trade require changing. At pres- unions cast 90% of the ent, members are being ex- Conference votes, although pelled to remove them from this completely overrepres party activity, because they ents their overall financial pose a potential threat, not contribution to the Labour because they have actually Party. It also discriminates infringed party rules. With viciously against constituenmandatory reselection com- cy parties, who at present ing close, expulsions will pay far more to Transport multiply as besieged MPs House for each individual struggle to retain their members they affiliate upon, seats. We should argue that than do the unions. IT WOULD be a foolish pre hui-in Procli majority the Left majority on the NEC Committee of Inquiry into Party Organisation will stay the course and fully withstand all the blandishments and pressures of the Right. Such 'built-in' Left majorities have crumbled before.

However, it is predictable that certain issues will not be conceded to the Right, such as the Manifesto Group demand that the NEC be restructured, with the creation of an NEC section elected by the MPs and another section elected by local councillors. Too many current NEC members have a vested interest in the status quo.

The NEC is also unlikely to capitulate to those Right extremists who clamour for a purge of groups such as Militant, although it must not be assumed that the YS, as constituted at present, will remain inviolate. The low membership of the Young Socialists will inevitably attract heavy criticism.

What Labour Party members must be on their guard against is the more sophisticated approach that is starting to emerge from right wing trade unions, and their research departments, in their strategy of trying to reverse the fundamental swing to the Left that the Party has experienced outside parliament in recent Myears.

Sid Weighell's article in The Times lays out this strategy quite clearly: if they cannot win control of the NEC, then they must seek to undermine the powers and standing both of the NEC, as the supreme committee of the Labour Party, and of Annual Conference, its sovereign body.

Weighell, taking his cue from Roy Hattersley, is now a convert to the idea that Labour's "policy making must be driven back to the grass roots of the movement", Weighell not is notorious for preaching this doctrine in the NUR. He attacks the democratic institutions of the Party thus: "It is ludicrous that annual conference should be required to take an ill-considered view of 30 major policy statements and find that none can be implemented. It would be far more sensible that it should examine three policy areas in detail, with the confidence that they are going to be carried out by a Labour government." On this basis, of course, a major policy area such as Ireland could be discussed once in ten years. Will Labour conference democi try to counter the Brighton refo We are also told that Labour's policies get "endorsed - and, very often, worse, amended - on the basis of a hasty and normally quite superficial debate at annual conference" . Weighell's aim is clear: namely, to reduce the number of concrete major decisions taken at Annual Conference. so that the Party leadership and the trade union bureaucracies can settle matters more easily in private, without having to endure too much pressure from the grass roots.

The much vaunted processes of consultation with the grass roots would remain as precisely that — consultation, and of the worst kind: vague and inconclusive, with few hard and fast decisions at Annual Conference.

Even the regional conferences are under threat. Weighell tells us that they "fulfil no useful function at all. From the Right's point of view, he's probably quite right.

However, it would be tragic and self-defeating if the Left adopted a purely racy be gutted as the Right ums?

or could be fought for. expelled members retain full membership rights until their cases have been heard by the NEC.

(ii) A new form of party branch, the factory branch, should be recognised in the Constitution. We should also aim to enable dynamic social groups such as the tenants" movement and housing directly.

(ili) We should aim to make an honest woman out of the parliamentary labour party, which should be forced to function as the equivalent of a Labour Group on a council, with minutes kept and published, including the voting records of MPs.

(iv) The NEC should be told, if the NEC structure comes under serious consideration, that the progressive position on reform is not to create sections elected by local councillors and by the MPs, but to enlarge the constituency section from its present seven members. allowing MPs only to run for seven of the seats. It is indefensible that since 1947, with the exception of the YS. the NEC has been exclusively monopolised by trade union officials and people whose careers have been in parliament. Our message to the NEC is simple: break the "closed shop" of élites and bring genuine lay representation onto the NEC.!

(v) Finally, it is worth noting that the trade unions have stated that the block vote system at Annual Cona fundamental reform of

----- pull-quotes -----

and industrial co-ops to affiliate to the Labour Party

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 15

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →