Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

A Red Gloss for Rate Rises

Socialist Organiser no. 15, January 1980 · scan p. 7 · about 572 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

119р El of Present Har96.5р). 102p in Ties. • AssocCouncils, Is promut sensible Heseltine's cene for couna successful with the Tories rates until they Government. parameters of asures, Heselpose carefully Is to penalise. salised councils hoose whether to raise rates still-futther (to make up the money lost by the penalty) or to make cuts They can pull harder and harder at the rate-rises rope until it strangles them. Having backed rate rises as an answer to cuts, when do they say 'no further'? And how do they credibly mobilise labour movement support on that basis?

Moreover, different cuncils will be penalised to different extents, at different times. It will be much more difficult to mobilise a united front against the Tories than The Tories are putting councils, and the services they provide, into a vice. Either Labour councils and the labour movement will mobilise working class action to break the jaws of that vice - or our services and our jobs will be squeezed to death. IN HIS ARTICLE in the December issue of Socialist Organiser, Martin Cook discusses several themes of the SCLV Conference.

While I disagree with most of what he says on all of them, I wish to concentrate on the issue of rate rises.

The motion which was passed at the Conference took the position that rate rises are against the interests of the working class, and do not amount to a tighting option for Labour councils who want to avoid implementing the Tory cuts. Instead, the motion committed the SCLV to fighting for working class action to stop the cuts in their tracks. Labour Councils could be the focus for this fightback by refusing to implement cuts and to put up the rates.

Martin Cook disagrees with this position. Fair enough. But his presentation of the arguments is way off beam.

For example, he states that "one comrade presumably myself] stated that the main divide in the movement lay not between those prepared or not to fight the cuts, but between intransigents and those who tactically resorted to raising rates (i.e. including Lambeth Council. which the SCLV claims to BREWER, who moved the successful resolution on rate rises at the SCLV conference in November, replies to Martin Cook's letter in the last Socialist Organiser criticising th conference decisions.

not leave councillors. this excuse The effect of comrade Cook's position is merely to paint these cour cillors with a coat of red g.oss, rather than taking our storting point from the needs of the struggle.

But if comrade Cook's presentation of the majority position lacks something in accuracy, how are we to explain his position?

The clue, it seems to me, is in comrade Cook's use of the term "strategy'. He attacks me and the others who argued against rate rises for not putting forward any alternative strategy for Labour Councils that refuse to implement cuts.

In a certain sense this point is correct. We do put Torward a strategy based on mobilising the labour movement — but we do not put forward any strategy based on giving councillors good budget-making advice on how to avoid cutting services. for the simple reason that there is none. There is no way that councils on their own, and within a traditional Labour conception of what. councils can do. can stop the cuts.

----- pull-quotes -----

if a clear 'no cuts. no rate rises' line is taken now.

support". GORDON

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 15

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →