Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[on the Committee, the Bill is certain to…]

Socialist Organiser no. 15, January 1980 · scan p. 10 · about 1,230 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

on the Committee, the Bill is certain to reach its third reading in February in undiluted, or even more restrictive, form.

The National Ab. ortion Campaign is calling for strikes and other protests on Tuesday 5th February, in the week of the third reading. It is clearer and clearer that such mass action is the only way to defend abortion rights. MANDY WILLIAMS review: the committee proceedings.

BOTH THE previous_ anti'abortion Bills - James White's and William Benyon's - eventually tell for lack of Parliamentary time, after pro-choice MPs had fought them every inch of the way in the committee stage.

The Corrie Bill's backers want to make sure nothing similar happens again. So the committee stage has been pushed through in the most bureaucratic way, with substantial evidence excluded and most of the Press barred.

The late publication of the Bill has made dratting amendments very difficult for those opposing it.

William Benyon produced series of amendments in mid-October after three months of deliberation and consultation, giving the opposition little more than the three hours of that committee sitting to produce amendments of their own.

And since the chair judged that the amendments did not substantially alter the nature of the Bill, and therefore needed little consideration, the amendments were rammed through in doublequick time.

Then Corrie, complaining about the length of deliberations over the first clause (time limit and grounds for abortion), pushed through a move for six sittings a The first clause considered concerns the lowering of the time limit for legal abortions to 20 weeks. The major amendment, more or less idential in effect to Corrie's original clause, was put by Benyon, and, of course, won.

The main addition is a proviso that the Secretary. of State can lower the time limit at some future date by a resolution put to Parliament, with no need for another Bill. Such a procedure only allows for 90 minutes debate, usually late on a Friday night.

Of course, there is no provision for adjusting the time limit upwards.

According to Benyon, It is straightforward: after hearing all the evidence, one decides whether 20 or 24 weeks is the right period. It is a simple, straightforward decision" . He regards it as a simple matter of arriving at the correct formula through considering the medical evidence. Yet, after making great play of having consulted various medical bodies about this, he was forced to admit that the great majority disagreed with him.

John Corrie admitted that all the medical weight is 26 weeks now" , but, because of the possibility of mistakes" , and because the limit of viability may fall in the future, "why not come to a point where there can be no doubt?" He quoted, once and without conviction, the World Health Organisation definition of live birth, which makes no mention of independent viability, only of various physical signs visible in many fetuses incapable of independent life. the mother's physical mental health must be 'serious' or 'grave' Benyon, who is much more active than Corrie in speaking to the Bill, was unwilling • to go over all the arguments which arose over exactly the same terms in his own Bill, and again tried to treat the matter as extremely simple.

While admitting that the definition of such terms as "grave" and "substantial" is difficult, he argued that the issue could confidently be left to the courts who will eventually be required to interpret the Act. so wo men's rights, and doctors' safety from prosecution, will be subject to the say-so of. aged, right-wing. uppercrust, male judges.

Benyon also introduced a. new part to Clause I, allowing abortion regardless of time limit in certain medical cases. But since risks will again have to be "serious" and "substantial" even mothers whose children are sure to be born with, for instance, spina bifida, will only be offered the choice of an abortion by a consultant who is willing to risk prosecution.

The second clause, on conscience, was passed unamended. Doctors will be enabled to opt out of arranging for an abortion on any grounds they see fit, and without saying what those grounds are. In such cases women may believe that they have been refused abortion on genuine medical grounds.

The promoters of the Bill produced no evidence that the present conscience clause is inadequate - none of the medical bodies say it is - so they relied on hearsay reports of doctors being refused jobs because of their conservative views on abortion. argument was that because between 90% and 98% of those who go to the charities for advice and counselling end up having an abortion, a large proportion (if not all) of them must be persuaded or tricked into it. thereby enriching the charities and those who work for them. In fact the charities are non profit-making and the people who work for them get fixed salaries regardless of the number of abortions «done Braine's evidence consisted of what consultant friends, not a few in private practice and in competition with the charities, have said to him. DHSS as at present. The British Medical Association, among others, is very unhappy about such a list, since it means effectively referring women to counsellors who may not deserve any confidence.

There is little likelihood of amendment to this clause. The hopes of amendment raised by the strong criticisms of the Bill from the British Medical Association and other medical and nursing bodies are falling flat.

Braine and his colleagues have quoted at length from the evidence subnitted to the Lane Committee a few years ago by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, who at the time supported a 20 week limit. When they were forced to admit that the RCOG now. favours a 24 week limit, and when Stan Thorne read a recent resolution from the BMA stating that it "deplores the persistent attacks on the 1967 Abortion Act and reaffirms its belief that it is a practical and humane piece of legislation''' , the anti-abortionists' faith in medical bodies disappeared. They expressed doubts in doctors' ability to make such decisions, and on the democracy of erich of e poprice ses by bunch of doctors" are made. selves from the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Church, that it is a mother's "duty to die" if that might enable the fetus to live: "Better that ten thousand mothers should die, than one fetus should be unjustly killed".

Vaughan had no answer when Jo Richardson asked why there has been no enquiry into the death of Susan Bradbury in childbirth after having been refused an abortion although she had severe heart, circulatory and kidney problems. Richardson read from a letter which Susan Bradbury's husband sent her, unsolicitthere is nothing anybody can do to help me; Susan is dead and that is final and irreversible. I have heard of a certain Mr Corrie who is said to be holy and pious and very concerned with life, but doubt whether he can raise the dead!

"To forget the whole affair would probably be the least painful course for me, but not only would that be disloyal to Susan s memory, I am concerned by how many other women will be killed in coming years to placate ival of Light brigade";

----- pull-quotes -----

e Actually, though I say! am asking for your help,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 15

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →