[week instead of one. Those opposing the Bill…]
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-01-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
week instead of one. Those opposing the Bill (Jo Rich. ardson, Oonagh McDonald, Stan Thorne, Jan Mikardo, and William Hamilton) have considerably more commitments outside the committee than the Bill's supporters, and have to divide their time between the various committees on which they serve.
John Corrie and his ally Stan Cohen, particularly, seemed singularly ill-informed about the recent cases so publicised by anti-abortionists and subsequently discredited by a Department of Health and Social Security (DHSS) investigation, and Vaughan was obliged to put them right. Vaughan, under pressure from the British Medical Association and other medical bodies, pushed for a compromise at 24 The fact that there will now be "other grounds" , not religious or ethical, and not specified, for doctors to refuse abortion, particularly worries black women. They fear it could be used selectively - encouraging abortions for those not considered to conform to the medical profession's view of 'good mothers' , like many black women, and refusing them to white women whom the doctors feel will make suitable, if not willing, mothers.
Clause 4, concerning the licensing and running of the pregnancy advisory bureaus, was defeated (after Titerally hours of argument in its defence by Bernard Braine), in favour of a new clause, with identical effect but better drafted, introduced by Benyon. Its main effect is to make illegal any financial connection between the advisory services and abortion clinics.
For Braine, the nub of the
Profit
"In common with all other modern businessmen, they bitterly resent anyone who lessens the potential profit of their enterprise by offering the same service not for profit, but as an act of service. Every abortion carried out under the National Health Service and by the charities represents a reduction in their market and, hence. in their potential profitability...
*The entrepreneurs, therefore, welcome all the more the efforts being made in the Bill to hamper and reduce the activities of the charities. They welcome the prospect of higher profits which that restriction will provide for them"