Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Michael Meacher: it the Right we should worry about

Socialist Organiser no. 16, February 1980 · scan p. 7 · about 1,101 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

mill sho conference mandatory reng the right ious retaliation hrough their ns like the capthan through ovement itself, on that, we d with a right ›elief in demoo further than for travel, secretarial assistance, etc, are met separately).

The mandatory reselection debate has not only thrown up questions immediately related to selection - the procedure and timing of selection, for instance -but questions of the representativity of GMCs. This is in turn linked to a broad range of issues of local organisation. the way in which they decide Conference delegates, and which way those delegates should vote. What should our response to that problem be?

The Party does not allow trade unions to elect their delegations freely. Only individual members of the Labour Party can be delegates. Is this right?

That leads us to the whole question of bans and proscriptions. Should the 'socialist societies' section be reopened, allowing groups to operate as separ ate organisations and still be part of the Labour Party. as the Independent Labour Party used to? Should the rules on who is entitled to be a Labour Party member be changed to permit. for instance, the Communist Party: to be part of the Labion be reformed, too?] And what about the Party programme and its rules and statutes - don' nasd Bristol West Constituency Labour Party is discussing a number of documents which the Inquiry prodded into existence. These are on political educisation of the party, and women in the Labour Party, among others The terms of reference of the Commission of Inquiry suggest finance. election organisation. and the fulltime workers of the Party for the agenda.

In some constituencies. there are special problems of involving ethnic minorities. In others there are problems of the non-existence or poor functioning of the youth section - a scandalously tiny body for a party with such mass influence. All these areas need to be looked at.

The SCLV working party; will be working on a document with proposals, but it hopes to draw on the suggestions, concerns and ideas of our readers. Letters with suggestions must be sent quickly - c/o 5 Stamford Hill, London N16 - if we are to be able to meet, the Inquiry deadline.

the Jurore abour publication of the report blurs the real issue: namely, whether the right wing should have a monopoly of the right to fight for their politics in an organised way. Unfortunately, many people on the left of the Party, whether out of confusion or as a result of right-wing and press pressure, have accepted the argument that Underhill's documents should be published for the sake of "open government" and having nothing What are the arguments? Underhill's report on Militant was originally presented to the NEC in 1976. It was based on documents from even earlier. which were alleged (but not proven) to be internal circulars of the Militant faction proving it is a party within a party thus infringing on the privileges of the Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Manifesto group, the Social Democratic Alliance, the Campaign for Democratic Socialism of the early 1960s.

and other right-wing parties within the party"! A NEC sub-committee decided at that time that nothing was proven against Militant and no action should be taken.

Time and again since then the press and the right wing have resurrected Underhill's report (each time boosting it as a shocking new scandal): Large sections of the documents have been leaked to the press, most recently to hide" Ted Gra aajje e ır the ! MICHAEL MEACHER M.P. has spoken out against the witch hunt on Militant as being If the Right feel that the Inquiry is not running their way, they will try to discredit it or at least play it down. -They will probably try to flood the commission with evidence coming from right wing sources.

For instance, I expect the GMWU will be working overtime to produce proposals. They and other right wing unions will try to operate through the Trade Unions for a Labour Victory. would give an official stamp of approval (even if Underhill's conclusions are not supported) to a bunch of unsubstantiated allegations. and give local Parties dominated by the right wing the go-ahead to expel support ers of Militant.

It would set up a public "trial' of Militant - a trial in which there would be no right of cross-examination of evidence, no right of reply. and no precise charges stated beforehand. It would mean making the Tory press the arbiter of the internal affairs of the labour move. ment. It would be a 'trial' with a disregard for elementary rules of justice that would shame even Lord Denning!

Furthermore, giving in to Underhill's blackmail will allow the Right to use the same trick whenever they want to push the left onto the defensive.

If Underhill publishes the documents himself, he will have put himself in the wrong in the eyes of the vast majority of party members; if the NEC were to publish the report. it would give it the Inquiry Then there is the question of the chairmanship. One thing they will quite likely try is to slow the whole thing down in the hope that this time next year Thatcher will be on the ropes and appeals to Party unity will be able to win the day for the Right.

As to the Underhill document itself, it is an old report and things have moved on since then. In any case there are more bodies to worry about on the Right. added legitimacy.

Another argument for publishing has been that if the Labour Party supports open government, it should apply, the same principles within the Party. This view has been argued by Frank Field MP and, in his speech to the NEC, by Michael Foot.

These apostles of open government' are very selective about what they preach. They single out the Underhill Keport for this purpose, although the papers of all internal Labour Party committees (with the exception of the Home Policy Committee) are kept secret for 15 Foot's arguments were especially grotesque. He argued against the Party publishing and distributing Underhill's report, but in favour of it being made available to journalists. His "modest form of open government" would mean the report was not available to party members, but was available to the witch hunting anti-Labour press, who would use it to step up the pressure for the reintroduction of bans and proscriptions.

----- pull-quotes -----

shelf Howevir. publication

an attack on all the left. Talking to Soc- ialist Organiser, he gave his views on

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 16

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →