Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Don't take the A train

Socialist Organiser no. 16, February 1980 · scan p. 9 · about 1,704 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

demagogy and bluster, of Course, expected and discounted on both sides.

Thus, last October, several dissidents in Czechoslovakia, members of the Charter 77 group, were given long jail sentences -for campaigning for rights supposed to be guaranteed in the constitution of their country. Without doubt the Kremlin had a hand in it. Like the Mexican regime in 1968, they were 'cleaning up' in preparation for the Olympics. No talk of boycotting the Olympics then.. Ireland and in Zimbabwe, propping up oppressive regimes. The US gave up its efforts to bomb Indochina into submission only in 1975. Their pious tury over the invasion of ATghanistan is a sick joke.

While proclaiming the right of nations to self-determination, Carter has said he will go to war to stop any threat to US interests in the Gulf. To show his concern for human rights, he will give military aid to the Islamic military dictatorship in Pakistan. To prove his opposition to great-power bullying, he €1,000 million on updating Polariswand said that plans would be laid to spend €4,000 to £5,000 million on replacing Polaris. Only 51 Labour MPs voted against the Tories.

There has been no sign of opposition from the official Labour leadership to the Tories' plan to have NATO Cruise missiles installed in Britain, either.

Behind the smokescreen of hypocrisy, what is at stake in the cold war outcry over Afghanistan is preparations for hot war -preparations to restore imperialism to a state of military readiness where it can fight another Vietnam war without facing an immediate domestic anti-war revolt.

Account

These preparations put all our lives ever more under threat - and the Labour leadership is going along with them hook, line and sinker. It is time the rank and file of the labour movement called them to account. stan as recently as 1919] can have no rights in Afghanistan. Their allies in the region tell us exactly who they are and what they stand for — Zia, Islamic reactionary dictator of backward Pakistan, where the masses are bitterly oppressed: the reactionary forces in Afghanistan; the Chinese Stalinist bureaucracy, still allied with the Pol Pot forces in Cambodia; the Sultans of the Gulf States; and so on.

No, these are not progréssive alternatives in Afghanistan: and socialists have no basis for supporting attempts by any or all of them to drive the Russians out of Afghanistan. We can in no sense support the idea that the forces of imperialism and its allies are any sort of progressive alternative to the Stalinist bureaucracy in Russia itself, either: the Russian and world working class will settle with them, and maybe the reckoning will be sooner than they think. -For these reasons we must oppose the revival of the cold war, which is now at freezing point again. We must oppose recruitment drives and any attempt to introduce conscription. We must expose the imperialist considerations that motivate the US and British governments" outcry against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan - including their new preparations for war on the USSR itself. y RACHEL LEVER oner or later, the nuclear nergy programme will be rought to a full stop. Not by guments about costs or aste disposal or alternate fuels or ways to live withat fuel, but by the occurince of a major disaster. Whether it's a core meltown at a reactor near ristol, or the crack-up of a actor in an earthquake one in California or Iran, or e collision of a waste train ith an inter-city passenger ain or one loaded with inammable chemicals at indon's Willesden Junctn, no-one yet knows. In response to this probabty the attitude of the nucar industry is to get as far it can as fast as it can — id make the biggest profits can - before it is stopped. crecy is all-important re. At all costs, dangers, fects, incidents and accidits, cracks and leaks and nics must be kept secret om the people living in the adow of the reactors or the path of the nuclear aste transport, or from orkers on the sites.

The haste and the secrecy Il themselves only hasten e first major disaster. At arrisburg the control room aff did not know what ench engineers had disvered about pressuriser iter level indicators and Ives. As a result, Harrisrg came within thirty mines or an hour of a core eltdown, according to the est NRC report on the cident.

Shoja Etemad, formerly a nior engineer in the French clear industry, has written length for The Guardian terly questioning the entific integrity of the ole operation in these conions of both public and Harrow & Wealdstone Kenton South Harrow North Wembles Kensington Olympia Wandsworth Streatham Common 17th) he described trying to obtain equipment needed to test cracking which had been discovered throughout the French pressurised water reactors.

His own company Framatome had no such equiptruth are mocked and degraded. The critic finds that he is faced not with debate but with total silence.

Faults, like the multiple cracking which affects PWRs everywhere they have been built, have not simply been kept secret from other nuclear users and from the public living around the affected PWRs, but have been kept secret from the reactor operators - the men in the control room. This is an absurdly dangerous situation for it means that they could make entirely wrong decisions in an emergency.

He also points out that had the Harrisburg incident occurred a year or two later, a disaster would not have been preventable with current knowledge: If the fuel had been more highly irradiated — say after the third partial re-fuelling -the decay heat of the reactor throughout the emergency sequence would have been about doubled ... and a major catastrophe could not have been avoided.

Another aspect of the secrecy and defensiveness is that real evacuation plans are impossible. A campaign to tell people about radiation contingency plans comparable to the London flood warning plans would cut right across all the soothing bromides about million-toone chances of an accident: it would be political dynamite, leading to an explosion of questions and inquiries.

For instance, a recent meeting held by the CEGB (in secret of course) for London MPs and councillors to reassure them that the transport of 150 tonnes of deadly nuclear waste across the heart of London was perfectly safe backfired, leaving its audience more worried. after it than before it.

Manor Park Forest Gate Maryland Stratford Clapham Junction Greenwich Balham Extent of radiation spread from Willesden. on a west wind!

In response to questions about emergency procedures the CEGB had clammed up. It turned out that in the event of a leak or an accident, the nearest people who know how to deal with it are at Bradwell nuclear power station, which is two hours' drive away unless the roads are choked up with people trying to get to safety -and to prevent that, will a leak or accident be kept secret from the people living in the area? (Is it even possible that incidents have already occurred, but were small enough to be hushed up?)

Councillor Ernie Stanton of Newham is quoted in Time Out (which carried the story of the secret CEGB meeting) saying: "No local authority is geared to radiation. It's clear from many meetings I've attended with the CEGB that they have intention of introducing proper emergency procedures for the accident we all know will happen. It seems we have been written off."

Tony Benn has complained that while he was Energy Minister, he was about the last person to be told about things going wrong in nuclear power stations, such as the chronic and irreparable leak of irradiated cooling water from Windscale. Little wonder then that local authorities are kept in the dark.

They are not told about the movement of waste through their areas. British Rail claims to inform local fire stations, but there has been no drill or even verbal preparation for what to do if a nuclear train crashes, and FBU members say they certainly have never been informed about waste movement.

An article in New Society last year commented that while the outright opposition to nuclear power had not got very far, movements in affected areas had mobilised thousands of people, and won the support of dozens or hundreds of local organisations, against the siting of nuclear stations near them, or the movement of fuel through their areas.

This is certainly happening in London now. The nuclear waste flasks - which travel past thousands of back gardens east to west and south to north through London - are tested (or rather, small scale models are tested) to withstand only a 30mph impact and half an hour's intense fire. They're known to contain faulty welding, and the actual flasks are not tested to see whether each does comply with the set stand. ards, such as they are.

The flasks carry a certain amount of radioactive contamination on the outsides, as they are immersed in contaminated water for loading. Nor are they built to withstand corrosive chemicals, although ICI has a depot at Willesden Junction and nuclear flasks often pass within yards of dangerous chemicals. (At Willesden, the nuclear flasks sometimes wait for several hours before being hitched to a train for Windscale in the north west.)

These revelations have led to a sizeable anti-nuclear movement now in London, though there are apparently some who would prefer to see a more altruistic appeal. Newham, Lambeth and Brent councils are looking into what they can do to stop the trains. And on January 26th two demonstrations narched along parts of th routs of the North Londo Line, which forms one of the waste routes.

Our first objective must be to end the secrecy. If there is any way all for nuclear energy to be made safe (and that seems very doubtful, especially under capitalism it certainly won't be through secrecy. And if there's no way it can be safe, the sooner we stop the nuclear speculators the better - before they are stopped by a major disaster at the cost of thousands of lives.

----- pull-quotes -----

Wembley Stonetndge Willesden

commercial secrecy. In the latest Guardian article (Nov.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 16

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →