A proaramme for A programme or struggle now, or tol next government?
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-02-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Conference resolves that the SCL must take up a debate with the supporters of the Alternative Economic Strategy A socialist policy should take up and develop demands which advance the unity, political independence and class consciousness of workers in struggle; the Alternative Economic Strategy does not do that. Rather it is a series of schemes based on utopian bourgeois economics.
The demand for import controls would throw workers in different countries into competitive, nationalistic attempts to export unemployment. The proposals for price controls and planning agreements are impossible to implement under capitalism short of conditions like a war economy, and then only on a short-term basis. In modern capitalist Britain the result is shown in sham policies designed only to deceive. The programme of 'reflation"
Against these utopian schemes for reforming capitalism, the SCLY proposes demands to mobilise the working class, such as: work-sharing without loss of pay, workers' control of production, automatic wage increases in line with the cost of living, and nationalisation without compensation.
At the same time we recognise that many militant workers see the Alternative Strategy as representing a drive for immediate measures of social change. We should aim for a fighting unity with these workers in struggles over wages, redundancies, against the cuts, etc., and demand that the parliamentary and trade union leaders who back the Alternative Strategy support these strag; les. The more broadly the struggle develops, the better we will be able to convince workers that the Alternative Strategy is a con, and to show NOW IS certainly the time for any alternative economic strategy to prove its worth.
The Tories economic strategy is one which tells each firm "Make profits or die" , and sets o:it to squeeze workers" living standards to make bigger profits possible. Its sharp end is felt in steel and in. British Leyland.
In those sectors, central to British industry, to the British trade union move: ment, and to dozens OI working class communities, huge job cuts and reductions in real wages are threatened.
Yet the sharper the struggle becomes, the more the Alternative Economic Strategy shows its irrelevance.
For a start, it is unworkable. In both steel and the car industry, there is an international crisis. French, German, American steel and car workers face the ['Tribune', the Communist Party, etc.]. would only lead to faster price inflation. them a real fighting alternative. same sorts of problems. Both industries (like most modern industries) depend heavily on international trade. Import control barriers would only make the crisis worse — as well as dividing the workers of different countries, who should be uniting in a common cause.
Set against the huge scale of the crisis, the inadequacy of schemes to boost investment, consumption and production by state expenditure is clear. A real revival will come only through profitability being restored by a big rise in the rate of exploitation — or through the restructuring and reorganisaton of the economy under workers' control.
The Alternative Economic Strategy is unworkable because it aims to have the capitalist state act as if it were above class interests, and set up some sort of halffor further discussion.
Organiser.
against the resolutions.
capitalist, half-socialist economy. For the same reason, it gives no guidance for working class action now.
At best, the Alternative Economic Strategy is a programme for_ a Labour Government elected in 4½ years' time, assuming that Labour does win the next election and that by then the Labour leadership is willing to attempt the Alternative Strategy. It's about what that future government should do, not about what workers should do now. But we need to fight back now: and in reality the chances of imposing left wing policies of any sort on a future Labour Government will be slight indeed if we do not fight back now. and it the lories are able to ger away with five years" cutting and slashing.
This irrelevance of the Alternative Economic Strategy is among the reasons why left wing Labour leaders who broadly support that Strategy, like Tony Benn, while vocal 'enough on other issues, have not been heard campaigning vigorously in support of the steelworkers (or the engineering workers, last year). Those on the left in the Labour Party, who see support for such struggles at the point of production as central to the fight for socialism, need a different programme, from the Alternative Economic Strategy.
SIMON TEMPLE