Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stripping the left gloss oft nationalism

Socialist Organiser no. 16, February 1980 · scan p. 10 · about 639 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The SCLV rejects the idea of a campaign for British withdrawal from the Common Market. For the working class of Britain the main enemy is at home: it is our own capitalist class. To label the EEC as the main enemy can only confuse the issue, divert from the class struggle and give credence to the class collaborationist idea of "The National Interest'.

None of the problems of the working class would be solved by Britain leaving the Common Market.

To oppose the EEC on the grounds that it is capitalist makes no sense unless we are to argue that Britain is in some way less capitalist than the rest of Western Europe.

The EEC represents a feeble attempt by the capitalists to overcome the obstacles placed by national frontiers on the development of modern productive forces. Socialists have no interest in supporting the old national frontiers against that attempt. We denounce both Little Englandism and the feeble cosmopolitanism of the EEC, fighting instead for a Socialist United States of all Europe [East and West].

We argue for Europe-wide coordination of workers" struggles for common battles on issues like the 35 hour week or the international crisis in the steel industry; for international combine committees; for united workers" struggles as our answer to the capitalists' attempts to establish a European unity for their class. LAST YEAR French steelworkers organised a series of militant protests against job cuts in their industry - which included seizing railway wagons full of German and Swedish steel and emptying them over the tracs.

Most activists on the left in the British labour movement can see how that sort of nationalist protest is diversionary, and what is wrong with the French Communist Party's slogan "No to a German Europe" And most would also disagree with the Welsh Nationalist speaker at a rally to save Shotton steelworks a few years ago who spoke out against any investment in steel in England!

But SeeIng through others' nationalism is easier than seeing through YOUT own. is the anti-EEC line of large sections of the British left really any less nationalist?

The anti-EEC policy is usually rationalised with the argument that the EEC is capitalist, or designed to strengthen capitalism. and it must be opposed as we oppose every capitalist institution. This is sleight of hand.

No socialist will disagree that we should oppose the EEC in the sense of fighting for its replacement by a Socialist Europe. But in the 'Great Debate' in Britain on the EEC, that has never been the issue. The issue has been: a capitalist Britain in the capitalist EEC, or a capitalist Britain outside the EEC (and therefore forming other capitalist links, with the Commonwealth, with the USA, and so on).

Neither alternative - in or out of the EEC - has any advantages from an anticapitalist point of view. 'Out of the EEC' does have the advantages from a nationalist point of view - from a point of view which makes "foreigners" or "Brussels bureaucrats" scapegoats for capitalism's crisis. The would-be anti-capitalist argument against the EEC 1s only putting a left gloss on that nationalist point of genuine socialistinternationalist attitude was put forward in France in the Euro-election: last June, by revolutionary socialists who got 600,000 votes for a slate under the banner, "For the Socialist They explained: "We are United States of Europe" neither for nor against the Common Market, for we believe that it makes no sense for the workers to take a stand for or against the agreements and commercial contracts which capitalists make between them... [And] to take a stand against lowering barriers between countries when the bourgeoisie itself is forced to move towards lowering them is willy-nilly to take a nationalist line"

It is time that point of view got more support on the British left.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 16

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →