Let's build on tl energy of the strikes and marches
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-02-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
class women. Like most other left-wing organisations, it is overwhelmingly dominated by middle class white males The implication is that the majority of feminists are a bunch of self-indulgent Beautiful People' with nothing better to do with their time than contemplate the ramifications of their personal psyches.
Very likely, the language, accents, life-styles and preoccupations of the existing graduate-dominated Women's Liberation Movement are a barrier to more active involvement of women from more 'proletarian' backgrounds (and ditto for the rest of the left. It is clearly the case that many socialist/ feminists do have a pretty clear perception of the real world out there - they are not starry-eyed enough to imagine that there are any instant short-cuts to influence by the immersion in the trade union movement that Rachel presents as a sort of Equal pay strue at Electrolux, Luton. Now Electrolux shop steward Maralaine Scragg is battling the sexism of the local Trade Union Club. The issues need not be counterposed. delighted than me if the entire women's movement got active in their respective trade unions tomorrow morning. But when she says, *there really isn t any way to organise working class women without doing serious work in the trade union movement', it really is a bit How many blue-collar women ever go to a union meeting? Even in my own white-collar union, NALGO, which is 50% female, activists and elected officials are overwhelmingly male. Even among male trade unionists, turnout is usually pretty poor outside of times of industrial action.
One has to face the reality of a situation where a mass tradition of working class political activism is almost wholly absent in most areas.
While meetings in working hours, creche facilities, and the challenging of patronising attitudes in the labour movement are all important, problems run much deeper. They relate to the whole position of women in this society. left) has in fact meant in the past, as with the late Working Women's Charter Campaign. The demands of the WWCC and similar traditional left campaigns, laudable in themselves, can be and have been adopted without dissent in the labour movement — on paper!
It's all very well to criticise so-called middle class" women (unlike the heavily horny-handed Labour Parties and far left for seeking a prefigurative ghetto of lifestyle politics as a utopian attempt to live out islands of socialism in a sea of capitalism.
True, many working class women do lack the education, leisure, money and general 'space' to emulate radical life-styles at present: but it is precisely their current situation in the home and family that prevents many of them from getting stuck into the labour movement in the first place.
It's all very well for comrade Lever to tell us the answer to the problems of working women is smashing capitalism and working class 1. The word archipelago loes not mean prison camps. H s a geographical term for E formation of countless tiny islands. Solzhenitsyn used it aptly to convey the countless prisons and camps leading sealed-off existence in Stalinist society. It also seemed an apt image for the element in the Women's Liberation Movement who believe in hiving off to build utopian islands liberated living within repressive and sexist capitalist society. Its use as the headline for my article was perhaps mistaken, as it tended to over-emphasise that strand in the women S movement; I wouldn't want to suggest that that's all there is to it. So while it was a one-sided emphasis, I don't think it was "outlandish".
2. Working class doesn't just mean blue collar. 1 simply want to see a greater involvement of women's movement activists in the mainstream of the labour movement, which both blue collar and white collar working women do relate to in far greater numbers than they do to the women's movement. While everything Martin Cook says about the reasons women aren't very active in their more loyalty and allegiance of millions more women than can the women's movement. Such an involvement in the labour movement has, I believe, a good chance of affecting and changing the labour movemerit to make it more responsive to feminist ideas and aims and more meaningful for its women members.
It's not that nesties are 'benighted' in failing to reach and involve working class women in any numbers: many feminists themselves feel that this is a shortcoming and that the way the movement is constituted doesn't help in overcoming this problem. I wouldn't quarrel in theleast with Martin Cook's "modest perspectives and do think that the Fightback Campaign can do useful work in developing outgoing. combative women's alliance under the auspices of, sas trades council women's subcommittees, reaching women in the Trade Unions and Labour Party as well as those in women's groups, tenant's campaigns, cuts committees. and single-issue campaigns.
3. Whether teminists can learn more from socialists or vice versa is a matter of opinion. The important thing is o overcome prejudices on both sides and develop a two-way traffic of ideas.I hopethe Fightback campaign can help in this. and this is one reason why the conference organisers have put some effort into involving a very wide range of campaigns and organisations. It's pointless to go on about whether it's organic or not: the question is, does it tackle the right issues and does it try to involve the right peopie in the right way. Some of these Juestions will be answered bi he Fightback conference itself, and by what the campaign does afterwards. But to dismiss the initiative advance is just destructive and won't achieve anything usetul.
4. I would stick by the nigure of hundreds of thousands of women organising. marching and striking etc. -or does Martin Cook discount the women involved in the engineering strike in the Autumn, or the wornen in Corby. or those involved in last winter's low pay actions or this year's hospital occupations simply because they are 'blue collar'? But this reminder that so many women are getting involved in militant action of one sort or another i not intended to be an assertion that it is easy for them. It is to say that the potential is there, the militancy is there and that if we can make the links between their activity and the ideas and initiatives of the women's movement and of socialists, that will be a tremendous advance for all concerned.
Isn't this a more hopeful and positive political perspective than Martin Cook's, which dismisses and belittles all this activity and pictures the mass of working women as passive and/or housebound whose only hope is, by and by. to "emulate radical lifestyles" that their middle class sisters have pioneered
----- pull-quotes -----
MONEY NOW WITH NO STRINGS
VUTIVE OT CUR INO WANT WA IT !
unions is true, the fact is that then hy. a d can claim the