Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Event"* s Carringi Afghanifirst Parl-on nuclear Francis at…]

Socialist Organiser no. 17, March 1980 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,028 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Event"* s Carringi Afghanifirst Parl-on nuclear Francis at the Tora £1,000 retly startGovernPolaris, to spend illion on a s. He confirmed that 160 NATO Cruise missiles will be based in Britain.

The high point of the response from Labour frontbench defence spokesman William Rodgers was when he established; "in practice, the Government will be spending £115 million less [on defence] in the coming year than the previous Government had intended to spend"

Labour Party policy is against any successor to Polaris and against the Cruise missiles. But there was none of that in Rodgers speech.

While Barney Hayhoe, for' the Tories, welcomed the "support for the NATO decision from the Opposition front bench" , only 54 MPs backed Allaun's motion. The two front-bench Labour MPs who supported Party policy, Neil Kinnock and Les Huckfield, got a warning a few days later from Callaghan that they would be sacked if they did the same again. (Kinnock soon learned his lesson: within days he was proclaiming he would give no promises about a new Labour government restoring the Tory cuts!)

Labour Left MPs did differentiate themselves from the front bench, in speeches as well as Allaun's motion. The Tribune group put out a statement (28 January) condemning the Russian invascow Olympics.

Some Labour MPs justified, or half-justified, the Russian invasion. James Lamond echoed the Kremlin's line: "I believe that Amin's regime [THE Afghan government before the invasion] was fast proceeding along the same lines as that of Pol Pot [in Cambodia]" - Ernie Ross and Tam Dalyell halfsupported him, with Dalyell arguing that the invasion, while not to be approved, was the natural response of a big power to unrest on its borders: the USSR had got dragged in like Britain in No-one said anything bearing any resemblance to the Marxist argument that socialists should defend the nationalised and planned economy in the USSR against capitalist world power, in spite of and against the crimes of

Scan page 8

Mikr Dapisiano geofi Bandomka recall the Fightback campaign liance, and to whilst it requires guidelines West London for its activity, should not be anae riiaisas wbase daon u Perpatremnfy purctu VSwsering Coviwinee by themseives, Jeremy Corbyn, Mark Douglas, 1* MAR-ONASE marads.

The founding conference of the SCLV over 20 months ago brought together over 200 Labour activists who saw the need to organise in the face of the low profile of the official left in the movement to provide a united socialist alternative to the unpalatable choice of Callaghan or Thatcher. Our aim was to group together, on a flexible non-sectarian detached itself from conception which originally created the campaign and motivated it up until the Local Government Conference in London in June 1979. The conception of the SCLV as a broad alliance of tendencies and individuals, as a campaign rather than a revolutionary sect witn an outward-looking approach to involving new people in the paper and campaign activity and with the platform as a Ruide rather than as a catechism has now been rejected.

This conception which enabled us to organise the successful local government conference attended by 230 activists from the London organised or directed by the tighter higher-level-ofagreement prescriptions that bind together a revolutionary tendency.

Many leading SCLV activists seem to be motivated by the view that we're not so much a campaign, more a finished revolutionary grouping imbued with the idea that it has all the political answers while the rest of the left wanders about clueless, waiting for us to rope them in.

We believe that in adopting such a conception, the SCLV is unlikely to attract the many unaligned socialists in the party or outside or involve in the campaign the activists in the Institute for Workers' Control, Independent Labour Publications, the Labour Co-ordinating Committee and Tribune supporters, Campaign for Labour Party Democracy workers and the like. Organiser* groups even where other similar and usually broader forums existed (e.g. Islington) and so on. Whilst motivated by a desire to cement existing supporters, it had the effect of clos ing doors to potential supporters. The most damaging decision was the conference rejection of the Hackney proposal that no tendency should have a majority on the Steering Committee, both de jure and de facto; thus marginalising the vital tension and premium on winning others to particular views that gave the campaign strength in its early days. At the very time that the campaign should be proving itself as a genuine; non-dogmatic alliance of tendencies and individuals and creating a democratic climate capable of attracting Labour Party militants trying to tackle the right, a single -though important - tendency in the SCLV sees fit to assert its own politics. aims of the campaign (as the founding statement did and we have a sectarian, 'holier than thou attitude emerging. The left must be built "around our platform and politics"

On the fight against cuts the Campaign seems to be accepting the view expressed by a speaker that the main divide in the movement is not between those prepared or not to fight the cuts but between those who believed local councils should follow a policy of bankruptcy by refusing to raise rates and those who raised rates to maintain and expand jobs and services.

On women's oppression, the successful amendment to the perspectives document blandly called for the "restructuring and re-orientation of sections of the existing women's movement." Fortunately such patronising arrogance has not at present marred the work of the Fightback campaign away from glib formulas of "for a working class women's movement" is. surely necessary.

For a campaign like the SCLV to have any value it must set it sights on the fight against the right wing within our movement and seek to organise on the left in a patient and non-sectarian manner. Already a number of individual supporters have withdrawn to direct their abilities elsewhere. Can the SCLV return to its original conceptions and recoup the ground that has been lost? Some of us hope so, but the onus is on those conference elected to reassess their direction before it is too late.

----- pull-quotes -----

basis, all the forces inside (and out, in some cases) of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 17

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →