Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

For the Sclv

Socialist Organiser no. 17, March 1980 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,861 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

evident The conference refused though a political rethink SCLV доР

policy was not only in the ence decision one the Labour Party prepared to fight for a Labour victory on a clear anti-capitalist and class struggle basis. Labour lost the election. But the need to develop, clarify and above all unify the growing and revitalised forces on the Labour left is now imperative if we are to defeat both the Tories and the forces of the right in the Labour Party itself. To do this successfully we believe the SCLV needs a relatively open structure capable of forging the widest class unity in action and providing a forum for tendencies and individuals on the lett to come together for debate and action.

We believe the conference vote to amend the Hackney resolution which argued for an open alliance, and to reject the West London motion which made the call th made the call for the SCLV to be open to V to be open to those in the Party ready to Party ready to break with the social-demo- the social-democratic leadership and go: ership and go forward to the socialist, the socialist, reconstruction of society. of society, means that the SCLV hasnow the SCLV hasnow UP UNTIL very recently, Mike Davis and his co-thinkers were citing the Fightback campaign as example no.l of the SCLV's sectarian turn. Now they recognise its success in attracting broad interest. But the loss of their prime piece of evidence doesn't disturb their theory!

What about the secondary evidence for the "sectarian turn"? Campaigns against the Tories and against the witchhunt in the Labour Party have been agreed unanimously by the SCLV Steering Committee in recent months, Equally unanimously, the SCLV has set about preparing a submission for the Inquiry on Labour Party organisation and supported the Labour Committee on Ireland.

In fact, nearly all the SCLV's recent decisions on campaigning have been unanimous. Not much sign of a sectarian carve-up there.

Mike Davis and his co-thinkers disagree with the SCLV's policy against rate rises (and that gave rise to the only recent divided vote on SCLV activity, where two comrades - against 18 -opposed an SCLV appeal for labour movement support for no cuts and no rate rises this spring). But the majority region with representation from 30 CLPs etc, interventions at the Party and TUC conferences, gain wider sponsorship and created a credible image for the campaign with a potential for growth has now been junked in favour of a more tightlyknit organisation, with a hard-line intransigent face.

The problem is one of confusing a campaign for definite aims - the defeat of the right wing in the Labour Party and the creation of a broad socialist alliance — with the functions of a Marxist tendency which has a wider mandate based on programmatic and strategic considerations for achieving socialism. A campaign is by definition an alliance, and whilst it requires guidelines for its activity, should not be policy was not only in the original platform of the ! CLV but also endorsed fter democratic debate at the SCLV Conference last November.

That's democracy, not sectarianism. Moreover, the minority favouring rate rises have had, and still have full freedom to argue their views, including in the columns of Socialist Organiser.

There's no evidence here that the SCLV is no longer a "broad alliance". Not only on rate rises, but also on other issues, critics of SCLV policy have been able to air their views repeatedly in Socialist Organiser... Indeed writing fanciful polemics against supposed sectarian turns now seems to be some comrades' main contribution to the SCLV!

The complaints about conference organisation stand up no better than the rest. How is it sectarian to say that SCLV policy should be decided by people and organisations which support SCLV at least to the minimal extent of taking out a supporter's card or sponsoring the campaign, rather than by anyone who happens to turn up on the day? In any case, the conference arrangements were - after long discussions - agreed unanimously by the old Steering Committee, including Mike Davis and Geoff Bender!

Did the conference decisions show the majority was junking the briginal idea of

Well before the recall conference it was evident that supporters of Workers' Action were working to change the SCLV into a much harder, tighter, more exclusive set-up. The organisation of the recall conference along narrower lines, for example, the refusal to agree to send open delegate invitations to ions to CLPs and other organis- rganisations not sponsoring SCLV the issuing of Supporters Cards before a conference ference decision (we are not opposed pposed to the idea in principle), the e), the creation 'Socialist ocialist

the SCIV? We reaffirmed the SCLV? We the SCLV's origi the SCLV's original platform (with updating (with updating amendments), against a move to ments), against replace it by an unstated replace it by a alternative (i.e. something alternative (i.e. that was not made available that was not ma‹ by its advocates for confer- by its advocates ence decision one way or the other). And we rejected a resolution from West London which would have effectively scrapped the platform altogether.

Julian Wells from West London was very clear when he moved the resolution whose defeat Mike Davis and Geoff Bender so much regret. The SCLV should be an open organisation for debate, he said. 'We want a formulation which would include all the disparate elements who voted for the resolution on party democracy.

The line should be drawn between us and people like Shirley Williams and Roy Hattersley" • Within that broad left spectrum, "the LCC has a more coherent and sharply defined view — one that we in West London would agree with fairly closelyThe main issue here is the class struggle, internationalist politics on which the SCLV was founded, versus the parliamentarian, nationalist politics of the LCC. And to the extent that it is an organisational issue, it is an issue of campaign versus discussion forum, rather than broad alliance versus sect.

Mike Davis and Geoff Bender don't actually agree with most of the political ideas put by Julian Wells. Yet they make themselves spokesmen for them in their letter. The reason for that is that they are indulging

orkers' to accept the need (proposed ng to by the Overseas Telephones a much SO group) for a reworking of exclu- the platform along less lisation declamatory lines, making it e along less of a shopping list of ample, slogans and demands and o send actually explaining out the

and not very fastidiously in a dead-end factionalism that refuses to disarm even

when events like the development of the Fightback show their factionalism to be unfounded. It is the dead-end factionalists who are guilty of "sectarian arrogance" , not the SCLV No: Mike Davis' theory about the SCLV's organisational sectarianism does not stand up. What the dispute is actually about is politics. Since the general election, many Labour politicians who were quite tame during the period of Labour government have suddenly been talking left. Left-wing activity focused on wheeling and dealing around official positions in the labour movement has been given a boost.

There is a tension in the SCLV between that focus and a broader class-struggle perspective, centred on campaigning in the factorand on the streets. The rate rises issue sums it up very well: do we look for alternatives for Labour councillors trying to manage the system or for policies to mobilise anti-Tory mass action?

When Lambeth Council leader Ted Knight makes rousing speeches against the cuts (last June), and then a few weeks later gives a lead for every right-wing and fake left council by proposing cuts, do we draw any conclusions? Do we learn any lessons about the real value of the policy of "rate rises instead of cuts to gain time for a fight" , which Lambeth was supposed to be the model for? Do we draw conclusions now when Ted Knight follows up a battle to get the Lambeth Labour movement to agree to rate rises by also pushing through rent rises and cuts in growth?

Do we learnthe lesson of the need for an independent campaigning policy? Or do we go on fluttering like moths around the illusory

though a political rethink light of the "power" and light of the "power" and *broad labour movement broad labour movement influence" of Lambeth influence" of Lambeth Labour group? Labour group?

The SCLV conference gave The SCLV conference gave a majority to the broader a majority to the broader class-struggle perspect- class-struggle perspective - against those who ive — against those who wanted to veer away from the SCLV's original politics. It

also established a flexible, open structure in which comrades with a different emphasis and different priorities can work, Mike Davis and his co-thinkers have not actually been deprived of any valid minority rights.

All their objections come down to the fact that they are not the dominant majority!

There is a curious parallel - with all the necessary qualifications granted -with the protests of the right wing in the Labour Party against the left's majority on National Executive Committee and the Inquiry... the same protests about the need for a "broad church', the same assumed concern for anonymous unaffiliated individuals who are going to be put off by the left's extremism, the same wrapping up ot political disputes in organisational protests.

The right wing in the Labour Party is trying to appeal over the heads of the conference, of the elected NEC, and of Labour activists, to "public opinion" and to confused and passive Labour voters. They use popular anti-socialist prejudices. Mike Davis and his co-thinkers are — certainly in effect, if not intentionally -trying to appeal to the general, more or less confused and more or less passive broad left. They use popular anti-revolutionary prejudices, which harm the SCLV as a whole.

In fact, though, they will damage themselves more than the SCLV. These comrades are spokesmen for a tendency which is moving strongly to the right and

STOPI THE

which is governed by a strong impulse to divest itself of its one-time, revolutionary politics and to accommodate to the 'Left" establishment and thẻ "powerful" individuals like Ted Knight, It is not coincidental that they are trying to scandalise the SCLV over their imaginary grievances and in so doing present themselves to the broad non-Marxist left as a "good SCLV" • Their political trajectory is not only away from the positive work that the SCLV is doing -on their own admission, even where they opposed the. initiative, as with the Fightback campaign. It is away from serious left-wing politics altogether towards reformism.

In Britain in 1980 a refurbished reformism is the last thing that the working class needs or can afford to waste time on. It needs a serious, hard left. Marxist movement, rooted in the broad labour movement, including the Labour Party. That is what the SCLV conference decided to try and build in the working class struggles that are now opening up.

Scan page 9

Sacialist Orgamiser 9 Cuts

----- pull-quotes -----

Mary meE and John O'Mahony reply.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 17

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →