Lambeths year ends in a sell-out
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
by 1979 WAS the year of Lambeth Council. There was a bad start in May; but readers may recall Ted Knight's remark [SO supplement]: "We made the cuts to show what they will mean" . So from July onwards, the Lambeth Labour coun cillors made a stand.| The full programme would be carried out - though not without a little gentle pressure from the Labour Parties and the Unions. There would be a deficit at the end of the year, but that would be a small price to pay for leading the fight against Heseltine's. axe. And on November 7th, 20,000 demonstrated through Lambeth to show their solid. arity.
in the past few months, the Labour Parties have been deciding the strategy for 1980. As in the pages of Socialist Organiser, the debate has centred around the question of whether cuts should be avoided by raising the rates. In Lambeth, we were told that a 56% rate increase would be needed to carry out the programme, without raising rents.
Some of us who felt strongly that such an increase would amount to fighting the cuts by cutting the living standards of the working class, and thus policy believed that Torr nourecuy Councillors should mobilise a movement to challenge the Government — on the principled platform of no cuts and no rate increases.
On my own GMC (Norwood CLP] we lost - by 33 votes to 21. Ted Knight won a majority to his proposal that the Lambeth Labour Group: Councillors should refuse to make any cuts in services or jobs, and should levy the necessary rate" to carry out such a policy. Streatham GMC carried a proposal tor cuts: Lambeth Central supported Ted Knight; Vauxhall couldn't make up its mind - though one ward mandated. its councillors to a no cuts/no rates position.
And so we expected a battle royal in the Labour groups between a largish groups of right wingers in favour of cuts; and Ted Knight and his supporters for the 56%. A few councillors would support no cuts/ no rates.
On Saturday 16th February the Labour Group met, and debated for 5 hours. First, there were several surprises. There was no deficit! Somehow Lambeth would end the year 29,000 in the black.
Next, the Council officers had warned that not to increase council house rents would mean certain surcharge. So Ted Knight told us that there would be a free vote. He would make no recommendation. Members' consciences would decide.
Finally, Ted Knight was rammed schemes for 1980-81 be "revised" to give a saving of £2,130,000. Not a cut, of course. Among other projects, Environmental Imrovements, a One O'Clock Club, Maintenance Depot and Adventure Playgroun street lighting La Civic Amenity site would be "revised" , and two leisure centres would be trimmed down to swimming pools only.
The rents debate camé first. Ted Knight voted for a rent increase - of £1 per week. Ten of us voted against any rent increase. Finally, by 22 votes to 18, an average increase of £1.50 per week from April was chosen, saving 82,157,000 Many right wingers, who had been holding out for cuts to achieve a rate increase of less than 46%, were appeased. After disappearing outside the council chamber, calculator in hand, with some of them, Ted Knight won a substantial majority for a rate increase of 49.4%.
Some questions arise. Will a "wall" of inner city councils, united by high rate increases [and some cuts], be able to defy Heseltine and force him to withdraw his penalties in November? Will such a united front be able to mobilise a real mass movement against the Tories? Will such a mass movement include Lambeth tenants, faced with increases in April of £3 to £4 per week? And what will Lambeth councillors do next time a surcharge is threatened?
There are some lessons to be learned. For decades, the Labour movement sought to carry out reforms within capitalism to pay or such Via reR Taxes, including rates, have been seen as redistributive and therefore acceptable, It has been axiomatic that Labour should, whenever possible, hang on to power, locally and nationally, so as at least to mitigate the effects of the attacks of the class enemy on what has been gained.] So with, the last Labour Government in the face of the IMF demands; so now with Lambeth Council. And, aS in Lambeth, it is likely that the Unions will support a strategy, rather than an immediate threat to and conditions.
Unfortunately for some in the Labour Party, what is now posed is the question of power. The crisis of capitalism worldwide, intensified in Britain by the corruption and decadence of the native capitalists and their desperate policies of repression and mass unemployment, making the working class pay for the crisis, means that for Labour it is no longer a matter of defending a corner and hoping for better times [in 1984?]. The Government must be challenged politically.
Councillors (and union leaders] must not be party to implementing Tory policies.
For one or more Councils to break the law in the present crisis would have qualitatively ‹reaver consequences than Clas Cross or Poplar. If politics can now be brought the Labour movement locally and nationally [21 votes is a start), then there is some prospect of ending Toryism once and for all.
The most pernicious doct rine is that being peddled by Roy Hattersley and his agents: "independence" stake is the that what is at authorities - their right to raise rates, or to delay the sale of council houses. He expects to win some allies from Tory urban councils. But if a future Labour government is faced with another Tameside or, heaven forbid, a Tory Lambeth with a Tory Ted Knight], wouldn't we expect some firmness, some decisive action? The liberals should join the Liberal Party