How the Tories Will Wreck Direct Labour
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Joseph and Rippon -Joseph is head of Bovi by PAUL LOWENBERG THE LABOUR movement and local activists are beginning to recognised the fundamental Chreat 0880 by me ones Local Government Planning and Land Bill. What is at stake is a principle which the working class has continually fought to defend and extend: the provision of services based on need rather than on principles of profit or ability to pay.and opposition has folded on and opposion has locused on the new rate support grant system and controls of capital spending; the repeal of the Community Land Act and powers to force the sale of public land; and the setting up of Urban Development Corporations.
However, Part III of the Bill will impose fundamental changes in the organisation of Direct Labour departments, and in its financial and accounting procedures. Because the Tory proposals take a highly technical form, and because of the contradictory policies of the last Labour Government towards DLOs, there is confusion about the impact and threat of the new requirements and controls. Indeed, the Tories have been able to declare that *they are confident that they are on common ground with the previous administration" in this DLO legislation.
In part this is true: the assumptions which underlie both the previous Labour Party ON Wednesday proposals, as expressed in Building Britain's future" and the DoE Working Party "Report on Direct Labour Organisations, and the Tory , are broadly similar -tendering, profit-making and "competition" are accepted as the mark of "efficiency" and "value for money".
The objects of the two parties however were fundamentally different - the Labour Party was committed to an expansion of direct Labour, but the method proposed was misguided and inconsistent. The Tories, on the other hand, seek to curtail and eventually to close down DLOs. The Bill opens the door still further for private contractors to dictate the terms of local authority building and to set up DIOs to lose.
There are four key points in the Tory Bill. DLOs must: i win virtually all of their work (new building, modernisation of repair and maintenance) by tender against at least 3 private contractors; • keep separate trading accounts (that is, accounts which are designed to show financial profits or loss on operations for four different types ol local authority building work; • produce these accounts as public documents, to serve as their mechanism of accountability: • therefore, show that they are making profits to prove their worth. —If any of these requirements are not met, or if the Environment Secretary, for any other reason (which need not be publicly stated) is dissatisfied with the record or performance ot a DLO, s/he has the power to close down the DLO in part or in whole.
The contracting system has shown itself to be exceeding t wasteful. Not only does require unnecessary administration to operate, but, far from assuring high quality building work at a fair price, it reproduces all the worst elements in the construction industry price-rigging, skimping on work tracting and the use of the lump, dangerous work conditions, casualisation the workforce, and massive profits for some amidst bankruptcy for others.
Yet it is the contracting system which provides private sastracton worl s one of Cubitt and tendering strategies which largely dictate their profitability. Profits are no more a measure of building "efficency" than "fair competitand tendering are evidence of lower building costs. To maintain that accountability is achieved and performance measured in DLOs by tendering and profitability is to transform the whole principle upon which DLOs were init¡ally created and still function - building for need and to the requirements of local authority spending committees would be replaced by contractors' principles of building for profit.
As socialists, this 1s a crucial struggle for us: direct labour has demonstrated practical alternative tol the contracting system. • The building industry need not be based on contracting and profit-making.
Direct labour can meet the local authority building requirements within the context of public accountability. Actual costs can be éxamined in the context of:
Da planned building programme;
• the phasing of programme;
• the actual time to complete specific work;
• the quality of work and of working conditions;
• what tenants want, and whether they like what is done and how it is done.
For this reason, the Tories are out to break direct labour and to hand virtually all local authority building work to contractors.
Direct labour is a test case for the running down of local authority services, for forcing higher costs and provision of what is left, and or contracting out virtually every sphere of local authority work.
Not only are hundreds of thousands of council workers' jobs at stake, as are the services they provide, but sois the future of a building service for council tenants. Building workers and their unions, tenants, the labour movement as a whole, are under attack by the Tory direct labour proposals.
A concentrated fightback is the key to the future of local authority building and of council housing. desperate to make friends in high places, at the expense of trying to build up support on the shop floor."
Pete Leyden added: "When they supported the participation set-up and the Ryder plan, the CP was able to argue a policy of expansion and more investment -but in return the shop floor had to accept speed-up and job loss!
----- pull-quotes -----
Tory building and Gilbert Ash;