Scottish Labour debates
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
by GORDON BREWER BETWEEN 50 and 60 people attended a fringe meeting on Ireland at the Scottish Labour Party Conference sponsored by Edinburgh Central CLP.
The meeting was organIsed as a result of discussion in the CLP on a document produced by Edinburgh Central Young Socialists, arguing the case for Troops Out Now.
Tam Dalyell from tne Parliamentary Labour Party spoke at the CLP and suggested a fringe meeting at the conference, with the authors of the document speaking.
Callum McRae, a Socialist Organiser supporter from Edinburgh Central, outlined the history of Ireland since Cromwell's conquest in the 17th century. The lesson, he argued, is that the British have never been a benevolent power, keeping apart two sides in a sectarian conflict.
The British ruling class colonised Ireland, with an eye to nobody's interests but their own. They fostered and used Orange sectarianism to maintain cheir grip on Ireland as a whole.
Another SO supporter, from the YS, Gordon Brewer, spoke on the situation in Ireland today. The central problem, he sald, is the very existence of the Orange State.
Any political solution for Ireland which ignores the question of the border is bound to fail.
And so those who argue for abstract 'workers' unity' while refusing to take sides in the national struggle are as Irrelevant as the liberals who perlodically put out appeals for Protestants and Catholics to be nice to each other.
A socialist policy on Ireland cannot avoid the natIonal question. It must see the fight for socialism as bound up with the fight of the Irish people to win self. determination and to get British Imperialist troops out of their country.
The last speaker, Tam Dalyell MP, argued that the British have no role in Ireland. "No British politician has ever met with any success in Ireland".
For too long, said Dalyell, the British labour movement has ignored the question of Ireland. It is time to make It an Issue in the workers"
movement. And given the history of the British Involvement, the only remaining and as yet untried solution seems to be for Britain to get out.
Speakers from the floor took up various arguments on the nature of the Northern state. One comrade argued that Northern Ireland is culturally part of the United Kingdom and should be totally Integrated into the British political structure.
Tom O'Donnell from Perth Labour Party took up this Idea. "Suppose the whites in Zimbabwe reacted to the Rhodesian elections by buildIng a wall around Salisbury and then claiming they had the right to seize that part of Zimbabwe for their own. We would not be fooled for a minutes.
"It is the same in There can. be no solution until the artificial state is destroyed".
Supporters of Militant got little backing for their rather cheap attempt to cash In on anti-IRA feeling for their line of "workers' unity against the sectarians on both sides".
Gordon Brewer explained the attitude which socialists In Britain must take to the IRA. We unconditionally support them in their struggle against the British forces. On that basis alone can we earn the right to criticise their political programme, with which we have profound disagreements.
To support the right of Ireland to self-determination does not mean to be Irish natlonalists ourselves. The only people on the left who seem incapable of grasping that, said Brewer, are the supposed Marxists of the Militant.
In conclusion the Edinburgh Central comrades raised the idea of a Scottish labour movement conference on Ireland, and as a first step* they suggested that Labour Parties get speakers from the YS on its document.
For speakers contact Edinburgh Central YS, William Graham Memorial Hall, George IV Bridge, Edinburgh.