Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stop Heseltine!

Socialist Organiser no. 18, April 1980 · scan p. 4 · about 1,176 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Michael Heseltine: seeking powers to penalise councils THOMAS and THE TORY Government's clampdown on "overspending' councils could be tighter even than their present announcements indicate.

Already several councils - mainly Labour councils in worse-off working-class areas: Lambeth, Haringey, Camden, Newcastle-onTyne - are in line to have money lopped off their rate support grant from central government for 'overspending" • Now the Guardian has revealed that civil service documents are suggesting detailed central government investigation into the costs of 55 separate local authority services, from allotments to education.

The Tories are also planning to do detailed monitoring on council staffing levels in various departments and services. which attempt to fight *set out to challenge the government" , and explained ow he would select them "It will be quite clear, in view of the very restricted number of authorities affected. from the speeches they have made and the decisions they have made The Tory policies aim to enforce the cuts by radically reducing the autonomy of local councils. As such they Pione even from try cosicils. But they deserve to meet stronger opposition than the sort of Parliament. ary lobbying being done by the Tory councils and by the Labour front bench.

Without having any illusions in the possibilities of 'municipal socialism', and without defending the capitulation of most Labour councils under the Tory pressure (rate rises, rent rises, and usually cuts too), we have to defend the local reforms carried through by some Labour councils - and the autonomy to make such reforms.

backs We should support any Labour councils which fight to defend their autonomy. while at the same time we oppose their capitulations. We oppose their rate rises but defend their right to raise rates against the Tories.

Careerism, petty opportunism. and often corruption run rife in Labour councils. Nevertheless they are much more subject to control and pressure from the labour movement than the Parliamentary Labour Party is. They can and do make reforms, support workers* struggles, or even sometimes take a lead in class struggle, as Clay Cross Council did in 1972.

Supporters of the policy of no rent and rate rises which Socialist Organiser fights for against right-wing and against most left) Labour councillors, are thus put in a paradoxical position by Heseltine's attack.

Not for a moment or ir any, way can we drop our opposition to the pernicious delusion (or treacherous pretence) that rent and rate rises can be combined with a serious working-class mobilisation by Labour councils to fight the Tory cuts - or are themselves anything other than cuts. We must continue to organise in the local labour movement against Labour councillors who raise rents and rates and make cuts.

We fight to get the labour movement to force Labour-controlled councils to adopt a policy of no rent and rate rises, and no cooperation in implementing Tory cuts.

But while thus opposing and fighting the policies of rent and rate rises and cuts which all Labour councils are in fact likely to pursue, we must defend against the Tory government, vigorously and wholeheartedly, the right of such councils to carry out rate rises if that is their democratic decision.

The democracy of local government leaves a great deal to be desired and we fight to change and expand it. But the Tories will not be gunning for Labour coun cils because they break their promises to their supporters..

Though 1 disagree with what you say, I'll defend to the death your right to say it', has been a central watchword of democrats for over two centuries. We oppose and fight what Labour councils do against the working class interest: we will defend the established rights of local government against the central Tory government.

Attack

More or less democratic local government, established in Britain over the last hundred years, is a poor thing when measures against the democracy of workers' councils which revolutionary socialists fight for. But today it is under attack, and there is a concerted drive to strengthen central government by an ultra-reactionary government.

The labour movement must defend the rights of local government until such time as we can revolutionise democracy and replace it by an expansion of democratic rights, liberties, and procedures. At the least the existing rights of local government are now a bulwark against the entrenched powwers of the central bosses' state, Or they could be. If the Labour controlled councils adopted the fighting policy which SO advocates, those councils would now be a barrier against the mad-dog Tories entrenched in central government.

Checks

Even though the revolutionaries may prove too weak in the labour movement to ensure that Labour councils fight for SCLV policies, we can neither afford to ignore the attack on the rights of Labour-controlled councils nor to leave the defence of those rights to those who naively or treacherously say rent or rate rises, or cuts, will help beat back the Tory onslaught.

Those who will not fight the Tory cuts except by imposing their own form of cuts (rent and rate rises) are unlikely to be much use in defending the checks on central government power represented by the traditional powers of local government. If now they think they want to orientate to a fight on a future issue, it is because a promise to fight in the future, in better conditions and on an 'easier and "broader' issue is in line with their politics and their psychology.

Anything but a sharp confrontation now! The struggle always promises to be easier 'on the other side of the hill'. This only means that the Labour right-wing and the soft left make the struggle on 'this side of the hill' easier now - for the Tory government, In fact the defence of local government rights against Heseltine is not best AVON linked with exercising those rights for rent and rate rises, as the soft left say. A probably decisive working class mobilisation to defeat Heseltine could be achieved if Labour councils cleanly counterposed themselves to the Tory government's cuts in their entirety.

If the opponents of rent and rate rises at the same time take up the defence of local government rights, it will cut down the ability of ine sott lett to fake and go through the motions of a sham fight (to end inevitably with their discovery that here too they cannot risk surcharge and jail, and had better give way). It will diminish the ability of the soft left to confuse the labour and rate rises. movement and sell it on rent Some soft left-wingers want an alliance with the right-wing to defend local government rights, an alliince that can mean nothing but talk. The real left must demand that the rent-and-rates raising left actually fight on the issue they say is the best arena for a fight, and do not use the Right as an alibi. We can only do that if we refuse to let the defence of local government rights become the exclusive property of the soft left and the right.!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 18

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →