THE LABOUR Yes to trade union control, no to bureaucracy
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
democracy throughout the party. Isation.
inside the Party. ACCORDING TO the press, the Labour Party is in the pockets of the trade union movement. And they ask with mock innocence, 'Isn't this a case of the tail wagging the dog:
If only the accusation were true. Actually the Party is in the hands of a few leaders of the Parliamentary Labour Party. How else could you get a situation like the one that led in large part to Labour's last election defeat?
The -unions wanted Callaghan to go for an earlier election and not to impose the last round of wage freezes, but Callaghan did what he and the capitalists wanted: he hung on, did the Tories' dirty work and ended up losing the election.
What is progressive about the Labour Party is that it represents the intervention of the organisations of labour into the political life of the nation. To strengthen the Labour Party we must maintain and strengthen trade union control.
On the other hand, much of the trade union weight in the Party is in reality the weight of the trade union bureaucracy, not of the rank and file. It is the weight of a group much the same as the parliamentary leaders: the differences between the trade union leaders and the Party leaders is essentially a difference in the field of work, not in the nature of the work.
Both groups function as brokers for capitalism within the working class movement, and both groups rely on lack of democracy to perform this role.
We need to make the tracie union control rank and file contrel.
Because we don't want to detach the Party from the isation will not afiliate influence of the trade unions, we are not in favour of abolishing the block vote at Annual Conference. Nor are we in favour of downgrading it relative to the votes coming from constituency parties. The SCLV Steering Committee considered two proposals. The first was to break up the block vote by admitting regional and district level delegations from unions rather than national delegations. This would preserve the weight of the trade union vote but allow it to reflect the wishes of the rank and file more. This was narrowly defeated.
Fees
The real answer, we telt, must be to fight for democracy in the trade unions, and democratic rank and file control over the block vote. A fight for democracy in the Labour Party cannot win without a parallel fight for democracv in the unions.
A second proposal was narrowly approved. This was to give CLPs an extra delegate at Conference if the number of trade unionists affiliated rises above a certain number. This would act as an incentive to getting affiliation, but more importantly it represents a way of increasing trade union influence through the CLPs rather than against them.
The suggestion was also approved the affiliation fees for trade unions and other bodies should be the same as the CLPs. If, however, things stay as they are on this score, the higher affiliation fees of the CLPs should not be an argument for upgrading their -The affiliation to Labour Parties of other workers! organisations - like trades councils and shop stewards' committees - would also.
Wi THERE WAS A time when the NEC was firmly in the grasp of the right-wing. Since the rise of a sizeable lett-wing on the NEC and the NEC's insistence that it is the guardian of the will of Annual Conference, the flagrant abuse of democracy by the Parliamentary Labour Party has become more obvious.
Thus the debate has arisen over the relative powers of the NEC and the PLP and over the composition of the NEC.
The SCLy 1s tirmly of the opinion that the PLP's status as a "party within a party"
should be abolished. What purpose does it serve? It merely creates a completely spurious source of authority over and against the only two that should count, the local party and the national party the General Committee and the National Executive Committee.
The MPs constitute together Party fraction, that 1s, a Party group carrying out activity of a similar type. Their along with the creation of workplace branches, boost the working class voice in the Labour Party without increasing the power of the trade union bureaucracy.
It was agreed the SCLV should push for a return to the structure of Trades and Labour Councils, to increase the unity and strength of the working class.
Recently there have been examples of the block vote being abused at Conference by a union leader (Hugh Scanlon did it twice) casting votes against the mandated position of the union.
To eliminate this, before a trade union's card vote can be accepted for voting purpose, this card vote must be endorsed by the signatures of a simple majority of the elected delegates of that union.
Bristol West CLP, which has been working on a submission to the Inquiry since last November and has produced many interesting sugg estions, has a different approach. They argue for increasing the CLP voting strength to 40% or 50% of the total votes at Conference and for an advisory Code of Guidance for delegates -including trade union delegates — which would advise that "delegates should always vote in accordance with a mandate" union to those of the unions as a whole. And making MPs answerable to their sponsoring unions cuts against a clear structure of accountability to the CLPs.
If Roy Mason could be dumped in Barnsley by the NUM Executive giving him the thumbs down, this would conflict with the rights of Barnsley Labour Party and there would be no incentive for NUM branches to affiliate locally. As it is, they have been forced to participate in he fight in the local Party -and a good thing too!
money to go to regional or NEC funds rather than to buy an MP- particularly if in a safe seat.
And doesn't the sponsorship system help workers - in particular manual workers and experienced trade unionists — to get into. Parliament? Yes - though only very imperfectly, because unions often sponsor candidates who are not activists in the union. When was Prentice a militant in the TGWU? • Worker representation could be better guaranteed by there being a list of experienced trade unionists (or trade unionists having the moral endorsement of their unions) hoping to enter Parliament. There could also be a system of positive discrimination in favour of manual workers.
In the submission of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, for instance, there is the proposal that "among the nominees to be considered (for selection as an MP) there must be at least one manual worker and one woman provided such nominations have been made by any Affiliated and Party organisation entitled to appoint a delegate to the General Committee or by the Executive Committee."
be an "A Section" for which all delegates could stand and a "B Section"' where ex-officio delegates to Cod eis Would not stand. This would ensure that Conference elected at least some NEC members who are not MPs or trade union officials.
Of course, ordinary grassToOls acuvisus don't have the Ray as pot rang alone.
they are not really national figures unless they are well known as writers or campaign leaders. It is therefore essential that provision be made for campaign statements and biographies of candidates for the Constituency Section to be cireulated in advance by the Party.
There was no agreement on the size of this section. Suggestion varied from keeping the numbers as they are (the trade union predominance ought not to be fought — the fight should instead be to democratise the unions and turn them to the left) to making the "A Section" 7and the "B Section" 5.