Not Mole but Weasels
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
by "DIVIDE AND rule is the motto of those who have devoted so much effort to witchhunting Militant recently. As Frank Allaun put it in "Labour Weekly"
*They are out to remove the National Executive Committee because on some issues it has a left-wing majority.' The right want to force the left onto the defensive and split it. As part of this, the witchhunters have been careful to distinguish between Militant and other "moles" and what they call the 'legitimate left' around Tribune.
Their main argument against Tribune and the legitimate left on the NEC is that they have not come out clearly enough against Militant and joined in the witchhunt.
Tribune's editorial responding to the publication of the Underhill Report shows that Tribune, despite verbal opposition to witch-hunts, is prepared to come out clearly to defend Militant's right to be in the While one sentence at the end of the editorial says We must never fall into the lazy. intolerant and antidemocratic idea that bad arguments can be driven out by disciplinary methods". the whole of the rest of the article is dedicated to showing that Militant does not "belong' in the Labour Party and to distancing Tribune from Militant.
The first half of the article is a general attack on Trotskyism, pointing to Militant using the Labour Party for "entrists" who are their own purpose. As so often, when Tribune wants to attack those to its left, relies on gossip and differences among the far left to make their arguments sound less right-wing than they really are. Thus a large part of the article is devoted to Jimmy Reid explaining that *the other sects" consider Militant to be "reformist" . They write, one can understand why. when militant [sic] supporters accuse those who sympathise with this paper of being 'reformist' they are laughed out of court. For they themselves espouse the idea of public ownership through Parliamentary methods and what is clearly a "reformist" trade union demand for a reduction in the smokescreen for retailing a more sophisticated version of the justifications for the witchhunt put out by the right-wing and the capitalist press.
Tribune nowhere has the courage to argue openly that Militant should not be in the Labour Party. Instead there are all sorts of hints and innuendos, so that readers can draw their own conclusions. Militant, we are told, has "a Stalinist organisation which makes the British Communist Party look like the Liberal Party at prayer. After a reminder of Michael Foot's description of Tribune as "the most open conspiracy in the world" • we are Frank Allaun [above], Underhill [right] asked rhetorically "Is Militant and 'open conspiracy or a 'closed' one?" • The clear implication is that Militant is somehow a conspiracy of sinister plotters, though no evidence is offered beyond the circumstantial statement that if Militant didn't have its own "central committee and an internal membership which takes decisions to which the wider membership are not privy" . then "it is the first "Trotskyite' group which has been run in this fashion"
Tribune is at pains to distance itself from Militant and establish itself as the 'legitimate' left as opposed to Militant. In reply to Ted Grant's claim that Militant is no more a secret organisation than Tribune, the editorial writes, " ...we will make one thing clear: Tribune does not "organise" within the Labour movement. This newspaper has no organic link with the Tribune group in the House of Commons or with the Tribune Groups which have formed themselves_ in the constituencies"* In other words, we are good, well-behaved boys and girls, not nasty "democratic centralist" plotters. Michael Foot is free to be in the Tribune Group of MP's even if he opposes democracy in the party and supports the Social Contract. Stan Orme has "no organic link" with us while applying repression in Northern Ireland. We can live and let live with them, but Militant... they're a bit too much to take. reader to draw their own conclusions. He appears however to be arguing against the revolutionary left.
The theme of his article is the Left the following: "To think that all instance of sectarianism, pseudo-militancy, sloganIsing and posturing, adventurism and reckless gambling with the lives and destinies by FRANCES of workers as if they were just pawns, were merely the MORRELL whim of fate and isolated individuals is hardly logical.
They all have a common philosophical basis: leftist dogmatism". Reid nowhere gives a specific example of what he is talking about sothat this assertion remains an assertion on which Reid bases all sorts of conclusions.
Untrue We are told that the *left dogmatists" have a contempt for democracy in the trade unions — something that is patently untrue if it is the revolutionary left he is attacking.
Wing people tor:
priority of the next Labour Government Reid has obviously not forgotten the lessons how to slander political opponents he learnt in his long years in the Communist Party. Though he now devotes his talents to another cause, he still uses the same tricks. For example. he incomes. writes, "The left sectarians are objectively the allies of the far Right in the trade unions as elsewhere. If the ownership. CIA had been really clever, it would have funded their activities and make them from this programme. even more vocal. There is no: better way of strengthening the extreme Right " its needs.
chamber Parliament. Distance The main practicai conclusion he draws is that "no narrow Left shall House of Commons. meet, preceding Broad Left meetings. we should not allow dogmatists and by Party policy. sectarians to create such trouble by using the mantle of the Broad Left. Out in the open and on their own they by section. haven't got a snowball in • Mandatory re-selection of MPs. hell's chance". • Election of the Leader and Deputy Just as the editorial is movement: grist to the witchhunters" mill, so Reid's article opens Control of our resources the way for the 'broad" left to drive the far left out of the book prices. main left organisations in many unions. agreed objectives..
Tribune has recently Equality for women devoted a large amount of space to attacking Trotskyism and anyone to its left, who it usually contemptuously dismisses as irrelevant.
Tribune's concern is to distance itself from the far • Democratic Control of the Polic against extremists. Position left and assert its living.
THE NEXT Labour Govern- Government drastically ment could be returned to alters its policies it could power sooner than ve ex- fail to complete its term pect, and in circumstances despite its majority because of unprecedented economic it will be in open conflict collapse. with virtually every group Unless this Conservative except the City and multinational management whose interests monetarism exists to serve.
Many of Labour's Parliamentary leaders who under present circumstances will dominate the next Labour Government are virtually the same people whose policies were responsible for the million more unemployed and the £8 billion cuts in public spending between 1974 and 1979.
Their political views have not changed: their strategy is to survive the period of opposition, holding off changes in the policy and organisation of the Labour Party so that the mass movements of protest now growing amongst working men and women will sweep them back to power on the same terms as before.
Such an outcome would neatly fit the political analysis of the SWP. It would not help working people. It can and must be prevented. The left in the Labour Party should be unitedly campaigning throughout the labour movement around a set of minimum demands -minimum in two senses.
All the demands have to be met, and quickly, if the immediate needs of working DeoDie. men and women, for jobs, homes, public serviceds, a decent standard of living, and equal rights and opportunities, are to be satisfied.
Second, the demands only represent objectives broadly held in common by different groups on the left, and amongst trade unionists. They do not represent the total programme of any individual or group, nor seek to supply one.
The demands will be opposed by a section of the Parliamentary Labour Party, Conservative Party, Whitehall and the British Establishment, the press and international financial and industrial management.