[reports on the big debate between the Labour…]
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-04-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
reports on the big debate between the Labour Coordinating Committee and speakers from the revolutionary left. OVER 2,500 people attended in Central Hall, Westminster, on March 17th. Tony Benn, Stuart Holland and Audrey Wise spoke for the Labour Coordinating Committee, and Foot of the SWP and IMG Hilary.
Tariq Ali of the Paul Wainwright (co-author "Beyond the Fragments') were the speakers for revolutionary socialism A SCLV leaflet pointed out that the real alternatives were not represented in the debate:
Tonight is a debate between revolutionaries who are outside the Labour Party and reformists who are in it. But what about revolutionaries in "Do revolutionaries have to be outside the labour Party. leaving the field open for the reformists to dominate the political horizons of most working Predictably but disappointingly, both the LCC and the speakers from the revolutionary left assumed the answer 'yes' to that question.
Tony Benn made a spirited defence of reformism in Labour Party, arguing that "reform has not failed, it has not been carried through All the LCC speakers argued that the next Labour government will not be like the last one, but hardly gave a convincng explanation of why or hot Paul Foot and Taria Ali bot concentrated on attacking the records of past Labour governments and the strategy of a Parliamentary road to socialism. They were convincing when they argued that we canMARTIN THOMAS BL CAR WORKERS, and Longbridge in particular, have long been reckoned to be one of the most militant and best-organised sections of the trade union movement.
Over the last two years, these workers have suffered a series of blows and defeats. Certainly they are no longer particularly well-paid. But the organisation is still comparatively strongLongbridge has some 800 stewards, making up a Joint Shop. Stewards Committee which is coordinated by a small works committee and six unit committees in different parts of the works. The stewards are linked up across BL through a Combine Committee.
After 1975 the stewards power seemed to have reachion a peak wit, "aticipatAt unit, works and national level they were regularly consulted by the bosses over dozens of issues.
Bur the appearance of consultation was illusory. On February 1st, 1978, BL boss Michael Edwardes put his plans for BL to a conference of convenors, senior stewards and union officials. The bamboozled 'representatives' gave him a standing ovation. • Two weeks later Edwardes ripped up participation" by anpouncing the closure of Speke no.2 plant without any prior consultation.
It took some time for the message to get through to the senior stewards and convenors. But with the sacking of Derek Robinson last year and the bosses' current drive to impose their 92 pages of "strings' without trade union agreement, it has become clear to anyone that the days of peaceful coexistence are over in BL.
Not just the illusory power of participation' is at stake, but also the real power of shop stewards" organisation. In the coming struggles - perhaps even in this immediate struggle - either Edwardes will be routed, or the stewards' organisation in BL will be shattered and strangled.
In the car firms whic step-by-step amalgamated ti create BL, as in engineering generally, the shop stew ards' movement gainer strength mainly during thi Second World War and in thi relatively prosperous year of the 1950s and '60s.
During World War 2 tradi union organisation wa: allowed to expand, in retur for and together with trad union cooperation in keeping 'class peace' in wartime After the war, demand fo cars boomed, and the manufacturers could easil! sell cars as quickly as the! came off the line.
It made more sense for the bosses to hand out conce eSSions than to risk damag ing strikes. So the stewards w ere able to gain real stren gth through bargaining ver piece work rates and ot her shop floor issues.
In Longbridge, 10 trade unionism was esta #bIished around the end of the 40s. In 1953 the bos Uses made an attempt to check the growth of trade un ion strength.
It was common then for car firms to sack work ers during seasonal downtu rns in sales, and take them on again when sales picked i up re-employ him.
McHugh was secretary of the Longbridge joint shop stewards and chairman of the Austin-Morris Merger Committee of shop stewards. His union, the NUVB (now amalgamated into the TGWU), struck in his defence. It was one of the biggest car workers' strikes of the 1950s, but it was eventually broken when the bosses forced a piecemeal return to work by saying that everyone who stayed out on strike was sacked.
With the industry still expanding fast, the 1953 defeat was overcome After a big strike against sackings in 1956, Longbridge management began to have informal meetings with the works committee, and finally recognised it formally.
As late as the Ryder report of 1975 (which brought in "participation') the bosses were still thinking of expansion. But world capitalism was stumbling into crisis, and the car industry into acute crisis. Soon the projections in the Ryder report looked like science fiction. Cutbacks were the order of the day. -There are always two basic ruling-class responses growing working-class militancy and organisation. They are usually combined in various proportions. One is to try to beat down the workers by direct assault. The other is to divert and blunt the workers' militancy by doling out concessions, drawing the workers' leadtion, and helping to establish those workers' leaders as a bureaucracy separated from the rank and file.
The 1975 'participation" scheme in BL was the high point of the class-collaboration approach. Giving time off and office facilities to the senior stewards, and organising negotiations with them in plush hotels, are all part of the same approach. But - in periods of crisis, at least - this collaboration approach is always a temporary tactic for the bosses.
Trade unionists like Derek Robinson may be 'pleasantly surprised to find that Lord Ryder would phone him up' (as 2 Longbridge steward reported it to Socialist Review). They may imagine that a new era of industrial democracy has arrived.
But for the bosses it is just a matter of using the class collaboration schemes to demoralise the workers and weaken their organisation -and then sweeping the schemes aside when they have served their purpose!
Once the workers' organisation in BL had reached a certain strength, its leaders had two options: either to make their organisation a focus and a centre for a reorientation of the whole labour movercent, taking a lead in solidarity in every major struggle, making its struggles models of democratic organisation and advanced militancy - or tc accept the bosses' class. collaboration approach.
The stewards' leaders, dominated politically by the Communist Party, took the second approach. Instead of building up , militancy and awareness in the rank and file, they have built up cynicism, disillusion, and confusion.
Now the need for a sharp turn is urgent. With the car industry tobogganing into slump, there is little chance of a big defeat being surmounted as easily as 1953's.
BL workers need a drive for democracy in their organisation, and a new policy based not on making the firm 'viable' but on fighting for workers' control in BL as part of a fight for workers power in society
----- pull-quotes -----
WOn the great BRUCE ROBINSON